Plastering advice
Author
Discussion

a13x

Original Poster:

59 posts

224 months

Saturday 1st November
quotequote all
After a little more knowledgable advice when it comes to having some ceilings skimmed. Late 90s with the artex style finish. Had 2 plasterers round, 1 says he will pva and skim over. The other says blue grit and skim. Both have a good reputation and have come from word of mouth recommendations.

Not looking to overboard as will mean having to remove the coving, plaster ceiling roses etc. But not sure what method to go with… if it makes a difference, the artex style finish will scrape off easily, leaving a not too hard a job to get a good finish.

Crumpet

4,720 posts

199 months

Saturday 1st November
quotequote all
My plasterer always used Bluegrit on all ceilings and any surfaces where there was any doubt. It does work, so does PVA, but I think it s worth the minimal expense to use Bluegrit. That being said it s all hanging on the strength of the bond of the previous layer of paint ..

Edit: I think Artex had asbestos in it until a certain point, no? I thought the advice was always to knock the high points off if really necessary but to generally leave it undisturbed.

Pistaaah

150 posts

190 months

Saturday 1st November
quotequote all
as said above - Febond Blue Grit - its £25 for a large tub, that should do even the biggest ceiling - it'll stabilize the artex and give the Multifinish a good key.

All PVA really does is slow down the suction.

Magooagain

12,071 posts

189 months

Saturday 1st November
quotequote all
Either works provided it’s applied and left to seal, dry and harden for 24 hours. It’s all about the preparation.

JoshSm

2,212 posts

56 months

Saturday 1st November
quotequote all
In theory at least PVA is more about controlling suction, blue grit is more about bonding.

With PVA I think people get into a habit of using it for all sorts even when it's not a great idea.

LennyM1984

933 posts

87 months

Saturday 1st November
quotequote all
We've had 200sqm of artex covered up this year (still a couple of bedrooms left but they can wait until we next redecorate).

Our plasterer knocked off the high spots, PVA'd (or the equivalent), and then skimmed. They all look good and despite the massive temperature fluctuations this year have been (knock on wood) crack free.

Our artex was in very good condition (ie. No cracks and well adhered to the ceiling) and was that stippled effect style.

My sister had slightly more crumbly and amateur looking artex and her plastered used blue grit. Her ceilings all look good now too.

If both plasterers are well regarded, I wouldn't worry too much about the approach they recommend - one would assume that they know what they are doing and have recommended what they believe to be the best approach

fourstardan

5,892 posts

163 months

Saturday 1st November
quotequote all
Did artex skim a few years ago with pva/plaster.

I Scraped the lot myself. Never heard of blue grit tbh.

I'm in a late 90s build so after free, but I've noticed a few cracks over the years, this was more down to the construction I think as it happened in the kitchen that was replasteboarded.


dhutch

17,281 posts

216 months

Yesterday (15:50)
quotequote all
Crumpet said:
Artex had asbestos in it until a certain point, no? I thought the advice was always to .... leave it undisturbed.
Yeah, surprised the OP is suggesting it will just scrape off, but be very careful if disturbing it, and or get it tested.