Don't be a mug. How to save £120 in ten minutes
Don't be a mug. How to save £120 in ten minutes
Author
Discussion

Wacky Racer

Original Poster:

40,481 posts

269 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Just had my renewal quote through for House and Contents with a very well known and respected insurer, it covers everything, accidental damage, emergency call outs etc,

The quote was £570 and last year I paid £550.

I rang them up, said I wasn't happy, the lady went away for two minutes and came back with "£450. Is that OK?"

The same thing happened with them last year, they shaved £70 off without any fuss,

Same with the AA, came down £70 without any hardball negotiating,

Don't be a mug.

Always query your renewal quote.

WR. A very happy bunny. smile

ChocolateFrog

34,723 posts

195 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Mine went from £95 to £120.

Rang them up and she had the audacity to say "it's only 25 pounds."

"You've raised it over 20% in a year"

We can do £103.

CMTMB

662 posts

17 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
They fully rely on people forgetting / not having the motivation to challenge it and the direct debit continuing, and to be fair that worked with me this year. Although the quote was only very slightly higher than last year. I usually shop around every renewal.

Simpo Two

90,893 posts

287 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Every year the AA try to increase my breakdown cover premium by 300%. Every year I ring them up and get it back it to almost where it was.

We call it the 'annual game' and they don't put up much fight.

The surprise last year was car insurance which was down about 20% without even asking!

Wacky Racer

Original Poster:

40,481 posts

269 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
The surprise last year was car insurance which was down about 20% without even asking!
So did mine, my motorbike came down 40% ffs!

Happy Jim

1,070 posts

261 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
EE for me, was on a £14.90 Sim only deal and then got a text letting me know that it was going up by £2.90….er, WTF that’s nearly 20%

So off I jolly well F&cked

Knobbers

Jim

bmwmike

8,237 posts

130 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Every year the AA try to increase my breakdown cover premium by 300%. Every year I ring them up and get it back it to almost where it was.

We call it the 'annual game' and they don't put up much fight.

The surprise last year was car insurance which was down about 20% without even asking!
AA are bad for this. Its a game if you enjoy it, but a pain in the backside and utterly demeaning if you don't. Why do they think they can waste your/our time - just give a fair price ffs. I thought this practice was illegal these days anyway.

I usually try to give them a single use credit card if i take cover, so they can't auto renew the following year (i dont use it every year, only when i think the car is a bit flakey).

Despite them being told not to autorenew, they'be obviously tried because i've been getting emails and a letter saying I might lapse cover if i dont give them a valid credit card - its due for renewal in August iirc!!


snuffy

12,050 posts

306 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
The Telegraph are never more stupid.

It's around £25 to £30 when you first subscribe.

After a year they want £270 to renew.

Ring them up and say you are cancelling. Why they ask? Because it was £30 last year and it's £270 this year, that's why. Ok, they say, how about £100? Nope. How about £70? No again. How about £50? No. OK, £30? Yep, that's fine.


Bazil Bush

188 posts

71 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Virgin, boiler, buildings, contents, cars, mobiles, every single one of them.

Have to set aside an hour to get through to a human and have the “ I don’t know about yourself but I haven’t had a 20% pay rise this year, yada, yada” conversation.

From experience, best doing it a few weeks out to get a better deal.

I find the whole charade of it tiresome but as OP references, big savings to be had

allegro

1,276 posts

226 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
I rang my car insurance company minutes after paying for a new policy just to say I wanted the auto renewal removing (they cunningly made mention of it until I had paid) the lady on the other end got the wrong end of the stick and assumed my policy was almost up and immediately offered me a £100 discount. I camly explained I had literally just paid for a new policy and asked would that offer still stand biggrin

BoRED S2upid

20,913 posts

262 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Happy Jim said:
EE for me, was on a £14.90 Sim only deal and then got a text letting me know that it was going up by £2.90 .er, WTF that s nearly 20%

So off I jolly well F&cked

Knobbers

Jim
Should have phoned them up it comes back down to £10! Then creeps up every year.

Pitre

5,659 posts

256 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Martin Lewis is on itv this evening at 7:15pm talking about car and home insurance and how not to be ripped off.

I normally find him too intense to watch for long, but I'll watch tonight to see what he has to say. I never 'automatically renew' and do comparisons every year. Not sure what else he's got to say....

Escort3500

13,077 posts

167 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Every year the AA try to increase my breakdown cover premium by 300%. Every year I ring them up and get it back it to almost where it was.

We call it the 'annual game' and they don't put up much fight.

The surprise last year was car insurance which was down about 20% without even asking!
In my annual call to them I always get the “you’re a valued gold AA member sir, so I’m sure we can do something…” bks. It’s then a tennis match until I wear them down to a reasonable figure. Citing (fictitious) quotes from the RAC, Green Flag etc tends to help smile

snuffy

12,050 posts

306 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Pitre said:
Martin Lewis is on itv this evening at 7:15pm talking about car and home insurance and how not to be ripped off.

I normally find him too intense to watch for long, but I'll watch tonight to see what he has to say. I never 'automatically renew' and do comparisons every year. Not sure what else he's got to say....
He'll tell you something like "rain makes you wet" or "putting milk on your cornflakes makes the soggy" or other such pearl of wisdom.

Mark V GTD

2,891 posts

146 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Sky TV are another company you have to engage with like this. Although, on the other hand, their home insurance products are excellent and don't go up in price very much on renewal.

tim0409

5,606 posts

181 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
I never automatically renew and would never dream of calling an existing insurer to negotiate their inflated quote; if their renewal quote is higher than I can get on a price comparison site then I switch.

Last Visit

3,288 posts

210 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
snuffy said:
He'll tell you something like "rain makes you wet" or "putting milk on your cornflakes makes the soggy" or other such pearl of wisdom.
Not accurate. He covers off some really useful information that I imagine helps a lot of people who perhaps arent as financially savvy as yourself.

Pitre

5,659 posts

256 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Last Visit said:
snuffy said:
He'll tell you something like "rain makes you wet" or "putting milk on your cornflakes makes the soggy" or other such pearl of wisdom.
Not accurate. He covers off some really useful information that I imagine helps a lot of people who perhaps arent as financially savvy as yourself.
He mentioned tonight that if you do a price comparison (go compare the market, moneysupermarket etc) the best renewal price is obtained 25 days before renewal (+ or - a day or two). Leaving it until the day before renewal can double the quote. I didn't know that.

Sheepshanks

38,943 posts

141 months

Tuesday 27th January
quotequote all
Pitre said:
He mentioned tonight that if you do a price comparison (go compare the market, moneysupermarket etc) the best renewal price is obtained 25 days before renewal (+ or - a day or two). Leaving it until the day before renewal can double the quote. I didn't know that.
I tried this the other day for one of our cars that's due for renewal and I played around with the date. I found it did make a big difference if the renewal date was in the next few days, but further out than that it made no difference.

jrb43

890 posts

277 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Pitre said:
He mentioned tonight that if you do a price comparison (go compare the market, moneysupermarket etc) the best renewal price is obtained 25 days before renewal (+ or - a day or two). Leaving it until the day before renewal can double the quote. I didn't know that.
I tried this the other day for one of our cars that's due for renewal and I played around with the date. I found it did make a big difference if the renewal date was in the next few days, but further out than that it made no difference.
I do wonder if in the future all the extortionate amount of computational resources currently making AI smut could
be re-focussed on optimising my car insurance renewal. Probably too far fetched…