Fascia boards and Soffits - Painting v PVC Cladding
Fascia boards and Soffits - Painting v PVC Cladding
Author
Discussion

pubrunner

Original Poster:

505 posts

108 months

Yesterday (13:05)
quotequote all
Hi All,

Our fascia boards and soffits need repainting; I got a painter in and he gave me a quote of £1500 for four sides of the house.

However, he said that he'd require scaffolding for the two gable sides of the house - as shown in the pics.

The quote for scaffolding each side, was £1600 plus VAT - I was told that the VAT could be 'dropped', if I was prepared to pay cash - as if I have £3200 lying around in cash.

IF I paid the bill and included the VAT, I'd be looking at a total of £1,500 + £3840 = £5340 . . . which seems a lot to me, especially as the painter said that he could do the job in 5 days. I think the painting quote is 'reasonable'; the scaffolding quote less so.

Or I could go for UPVC Cladding - a salesman dropped off leaflets at all the local houses and the quote for ours was £3200 (I'd hope that they have their own scaffolding).

The wood seems to be in very good condition, just in needs of a repaint for cosmetic purposes.

I'd welcome any advice/guidance as to what the best course of action might be.






carinatauk

1,571 posts

277 months

Yesterday (13:18)
quotequote all
I would get a price to replace, and then it can be forgotten about for a few years.

From your quote, scaffold is about right against what I was charged for when my solar was installed last year [basically I was told to expect £1000 inc VAT per side of the house]. Labour and paint doesn't seem overpriced at all


Sir Bagalot

6,915 posts

206 months

Yesterday (13:22)
quotequote all
5 days to paint?laugh

Forget cladding, go for replacement

pubrunner

Original Poster:

505 posts

108 months

Yesterday (14:39)
quotequote all
carinatauk said:
I would get a price to replace, and then it can be forgotten about for a few years.
Sir Bagalot said:
Forget cladding, go for replacement
Thank you for such prompt replies.

If I go for replacement, should I go for wood, or should I go for solid UPVC - which should never need painting ?

carinatauk

1,571 posts

277 months

Yesterday (15:57)
quotequote all
pubrunner said:
Thank you for such prompt replies.

If I go for replacement, should I go for wood, or should I go for solid UPVC - which should never need painting ?
If it were me I would go for a good quality UPVC

SonicHedgeHog

2,755 posts

207 months

Yesterday (16:06)
quotequote all
Am I the only one thinking “buy a quality ladder, make sure it’s secure and then do it yourself?” If you have quick drying primer you’ll have that done in a day, maybe a weekend if you have to do a bit of sanding a filling. If you use a quality paint you’ll probably have to do it again in five years. This is no different to hanging the lights of the guttering at Christmas. Ladder, primer, paint, brushes, £500. Job jobbed.

Mr Pointy

12,962 posts

184 months

Yesterday (16:09)
quotequote all
pubrunner said:
If I go for replacement, should I go for wood, or should I go for solid UPVC - which should never need painting ?
Good quality PVC & then you can forget about maintenance other than getting the window cleaner to clean it - it might not be scalloped though.

Mr Pointy

12,962 posts

184 months

Yesterday (16:11)
quotequote all
SonicHedgeHog said:
Am I the only one thinking buy a quality ladder, make sure it s secure and then do it yourself? If you have quick drying primer you ll have that done in a day, maybe a weekend if you have to do a bit of sanding a filling. If you use a quality paint you ll probably have to do it again in five years. This is no different to hanging the lights of the guttering at Christmas. Ladder, primer, paint, brushes, £500. Job jobbed.
No chance. That's a long way up to the ridge & the angle is way too steep. Maybe reachable with a tower but it would be a bit marginal.

SonicHedgeHog

2,755 posts

207 months

Yesterday (16:18)
quotequote all
said:

A compact scissor lift will cost about £200 to hire. Save money buying the ladder and use the lift all the way round the house. £5000 to paint soffits or £3500 to replace with UPVC to avoid a bit of DIY seems unnecessary to me.

Chumley.mouse

909 posts

62 months

Yesterday (16:27)
quotequote all
How is £3200 +vat anywhere near reasonable for scaffolding 2 gables on a 2 story house ???. They’re having your pants down…..

carinatauk

1,571 posts

277 months

Yesterday (17:11)
quotequote all
SonicHedgeHog said:
Am I the only one thinking buy a quality ladder, make sure it s secure and then do it yourself? If you have quick drying primer you ll have that done in a day, maybe a weekend if you have to do a bit of sanding a filling. If you use a quality paint you ll probably have to do it again in five years. This is no different to hanging the lights of the guttering at Christmas. Ladder, primer, paint, brushes, £500. Job jobbed.
When I was young and very fooish, I climbed a ladder and painted them from the roof. After dropping the brush for the second time I tied to my neck. When I finished I decided the next time I would get them changed to UPVC. Oh and several new underpants eek

carinatauk

1,571 posts

277 months

Yesterday (17:12)
quotequote all
SonicHedgeHog said:

A compact scissor lift will cost about £200 to hire. Save money buying the ladder and use the lift all the way round the house. £5000 to paint soffits or £3500 to replace with UPVC to avoid a bit of DIY seems unnecessary to me.
Looking at the photos access may be a problem

mart 63

2,466 posts

269 months

Yesterday (18:16)
quotequote all
2 days work for a decent painter with a ladder and cherry picker.