Solar panels fitted to house roofs...
Solar panels fitted to house roofs...
Author
Discussion

dreamz

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Thursday 20th May 2010
quotequote all
do they really save you money in the long run or is it just a bit of a gimmick??

considering i'm in cold rainy lancashire...

grumbledoak

32,355 posts

255 months

Thursday 20th May 2010
quotequote all
Gimmick. You can forget the windmills, too.

I think the water heating systems are viable here, but not electricity generation.

dreamz

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Thursday 20th May 2010
quotequote all
i was thinking that - i mean your spending a few grand to have them on the top of the house - i couldnt see them powering a 48" lcd or a pc that runs all day long.

daveparry

988 posts

222 months

Thursday 20th May 2010
quotequote all
Solar heating does work! but solar energy requires sooooo many batteries!

dreamz

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

215 months

Thursday 20th May 2010
quotequote all
so how do they work?

would it work alongside a combi boiler or seperate?

dugt

1,657 posts

229 months

Thursday 20th May 2010
quotequote all
We have a heating system on our(parents) roof

First off, if your planning on recouping your money, walk away now. You wont.

My parents bought the system (i think it was about £7000ish) before they retired as a way of keeping the bills down when they were retired.

You have another coil in your hot water tank, which is heated by the panels on the roof. You still have the coil from the gas boiler and you can put an imersion heater in it aswell.

Once we had all the problems itroned out, it works great. We only put the gas on for about 10 minuites in the morning before we get up and thats it for the day.


daveparry

988 posts

222 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Don't work with a combi as you need a storage tank!

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

276 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Solar/photovoltaic realy just isnt viable anywhere as yet.

Proviso theres a system in the US which uses about 400-500sqm of photovoltaic cells linked to hydrogen production and recovery through a fuel cell or something, $1/2mil to install and seems to work.

Solar water heating is popular here but we get a fair bit more sun than the UK.

bogie

16,887 posts

294 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
you mean "not viable" as in the panels are expensive, so that the payback time is long?

...I think they are "viable" as in the latest panels generate electricity quite well (even on an overcast day) ....you would just need to live there a long time to break even on the financial outlay

the water only systems work differently, but even they are too expensive for us - the payback time is just as long (only 2 of us, and not home often, dont use a lot of water)



Edited by bogie on Friday 21st May 05:54

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

276 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Not viable vs the area you need and storage requirements (summer -> winter) for an average modern household.

Not sure even if you covered the whole roof (average UK house) in 100% efficient panels that it would cover the power used even if you ignore storage issues etc .

bogie

16,887 posts

294 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
dont you just sell it back to the grid if you are generating more than you are using? i.e. mid day when everyone is at work

I guess the roof of a 3 bed semi is going to struggle to take a 3-4kw of panels right now, so see what you mean

we are an odd case (I looked into it a year or so) in that we have a household of 2 people, but a large roof on a 5 bed detached house...so a 4Kw system for 2 working people would be ample ....in fact I reckon we would sell enough back to cover the gas bill for the year, and be "energy cost neutral" ...if it were not for the £20K ish install cost for 4Kw of panels frown

sjg

7,639 posts

287 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
I think at the moment if you have solar panels and are feeding your excess power back into the grid, it's credited at a much higher rate than when you're taking from the grid. Assuming you've got some roof pointing in the right direction you can be building up that credit during the day (when the lights and appliances tend to be off), then drawing it down (at a cheaper rate) in the evenings when you're using a lot more power.

Not to mention all kinds of tax breaks on installing them too.

ralphrj

3,925 posts

213 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
My parents installed solar panels on the roof of their house last year.

Total cost to them after receiving the grant was £13k.

They generate more electricity than they use and sell the surplus back to the energy company.

Taking into account the money saved by all their electricity being free plus the income they receive from the energy company they are making (if I remember the figure correctly) an 11% rate of return on their investment.

blackcab

1,259 posts

222 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Ploughcroft in brighouse are pretty big with solar installations they do free calculations for you etc - the guy that owns the co - Chris is a real nice guy

cptsideways

13,820 posts

274 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Theres a big difference between solar heating panels & solar electricity panels!

daveparry

988 posts

222 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Actually the parts you need to make your own solar heating system are readilly available so a DIY job is not out of the question, the only difficult bit is mounting the solar collector on the roof



http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&source=web&am...

Tuna

19,930 posts

306 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Can we make a sticky for this subject.. it comes up a couple of times a month at the moment and I'm fed up of answering.

To the person who's parents paid £7000 - ouch, they were ripped off. Our system (6 sq.m of panels) cost under £2K for the hardware, and fitting it was a couple of days labour. The solar panel industry is where all the old double glazing salesmen went - you have been warned.

Solar thermal (hot water) works in the UK for your domestic water needs, but not for space heating. By 'works', I mean it produces useful amounts of hot water for a reasonably cost effective installation with a decent lifespan (ie 20 years+). If you don't pay much for your hot water each year (eg. you're a childless couple who shower every other day and have mains gas), then you won't save that much money so it's probably not worth it. If you're a family that has regular baths and currently heat your water with electricity, you will save a lot. The panels themselves are the least important part of the installation - it needs to be properly integrated with your hot water set up and use an energy efficient pump system. You can use solar hot water with combi boilers, IF your boiler can accept pre-heated water (some can, some can't).

Solar electric (PV panels) also work, but the cost of the gear is currently prohibitive. There are some promising new technologies coming on stream at the moment, so this may change significantly over the next five years or so.

The proposed new Renewable Heat Incentives will shake things up a lot - basically you get paid (and the proposed amounts are pretty generous) to have solar, heat pumps and other technology installed. The return rate looks to be quite good so it would make installations a decent investment - but as it stands the system will require that you have an 'accredited' install, which puts us back in the hands of double glazing salesmen who charge over the odds for a special sticker.

Ferg

15,242 posts

279 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
ralphrj said:
They generate more electricity than they use and sell the surplus back to the energy company..
The new feed-in tariffs pay you for what you generate regardless of whether you use it or not.

Hereward

4,878 posts

252 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Tuna,

What is your opinion on solar heating for an outdoor swimming pool in the UK?

My pool currently has an 80KW boiler that produces barely lukewarm water due to the very high flow rate of water through the heat exchanger. In fact I wonder if the boiler is working properly...

I was wondering if passing the water through an array of solar panels would have any discernable effect? Pool holds about 22,000 gallons.

mackg

152 posts

202 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Hereward said:
Tuna,

What is your opinion on solar heating for an outdoor swimming pool in the UK?

My pool currently has an 80KW boiler that produces barely lukewarm water due to the very high flow rate of water through the heat exchanger. In fact I wonder if the boiler is working properly...

I was wondering if passing the water through an array of solar panels would have any discernable effect? Pool holds about 22,000 gallons.
A ground source heat pump might work well for the pool, I'm sure some body will correct me if I'm wrong