Support In Place Of An Internal Wall
Support In Place Of An Internal Wall
Author
Discussion

Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Planning to knock through the kitchen and dining room but it's a supporting wall (1980's cinderblock). The idea would be to leave the lower section in situ (minus a doorway) to act as a a base for a breakfast bar.

The wall is 3400mm long. How much of it can be removed? How much must be left at each end and what size RSJ (or similar) should be installed?

Lastly of course, what'll it cost me to have done to a plastered finish (East Herts)?

Thanks.

mk1fan

10,844 posts

248 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Blockwork doesn't always mean it is structural.

If it is structural you'll need to give more detail before any calcs can be done. You should also give notice to Building Control about the works.

A local Structural Engineer who can visit and look at it properly would be worth the fee.

Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
mk1fan said:
Blockwork doesn't always mean it is structural.

If it is structural you'll need to give more detail before any calcs can be done. You should also give notice to Building Control about the works.

A local Structural Engineer who can visit and look at it properly would be worth the fee.
Ta. I'm calling it structural because it supports a wall above, not because of the material wink

B17NNS

18,506 posts

270 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Get a structural engineer round to have a look at what you want to do. I pay about £70 for a simple 'knock through' calc.

He will tell you how much of the wall can be removed (maybe all of it, possibly you may need to leave a nib either side for the beam to sit on).

He will design you a beam to suit the application.

Call building control and tell them you want to do work to your property on a building notice basis.

They will want to check the SE's calculations and the standard of workmanship at various stages.

Get a builder to quote.

Too many variables to give an accurate cost but less that £2k all in.

Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Excellent. Just the sort of thing I was hoping for.

Thanks B17NNS.

shirt

25,050 posts

224 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
'design you a beam'. what? does he get a good deal on one off beams from the steel mill?

on a standard build, a decent builder can do the calcs required. its not remotely difficult unless frank gehry designed your house.

Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
I was thinking they'd...........

Scaffold boards on the floor.

Position Acrows at (say) one meter centres.

Wind up Acrows with scaffold boards on top.

Hack out plaster and blockwork.

Position, pack/level the beam.

Bolt beam into position.

Make good.

Remove Acrows and boards.



What have I missed?

Incorrigible

13,668 posts

284 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Flintstone said:
What have I missed?
only that the beam may need to rest on engineering bricks or similar

The spec will be in the engineers calcs though

FWIW When I did my lounge/old kitchen (kitchen now moved) I hid the RSJ in the ceiling space, because I didn't want that obvious break in the ceiling when a joist sits under it. PITA at the time but well worth it


Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Incorrigible said:
Flintstone said:
What have I missed?
only that the beam may need to rest on engineering bricks or similar
I just logged back in to post 'padstones' or similar. Honest biggrin

Think I'll search the Yellow Pages tomorrow and see who's nearby. Unless there's a PH structural engineer in the East Herts area who fancies the job?

Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
I pay about £70 for a simple 'knock through' calc.
£70? Where? I've just been quoted £575.

shirt

25,050 posts

224 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
seriously? I had an rsj installed for less! post a pic of the wall please.

Busamav

2,954 posts

231 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Flintstone said:
B17NNS said:
I pay about £70 for a simple 'knock through' calc.
£70? Where? I've just been quoted £575.
they are taking the pi$$ .

B17NNS is spot on , a tad expensive actually wink

Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
I took it to be a "Can't be arsed" quote.

mk1fan

10,844 posts

248 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
You should be able to get a single pracitioner Structural Engineer to visit, collect all the info they need and provide you with a design and calcs for £175 to £250.

If you want an SE to provide you a design and calc based upon the information you supply then you should get one for £100ish. However, you'll be taking the liability on - the SE can't be resonsible for the information you supplied.

If you have all the info then there are online steel calculators you can use.


Edited by mk1fan on Tuesday 31st August 20:26

Flintstone

Original Poster:

8,644 posts

270 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Given that I'm not sure I'd know what info to collect I'd go with the SE doing it. However, it seems the local ones are in collusion. I've a second estimate, this time for £600.

Someone's tekkin the pish.

shirt

25,050 posts

224 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
as I said, get a builder to quote. knocking through brick/blockwork is bread & butter. a larger outfit who do commercial work may well have their own se anyway.

I had my lounge & dining room knocked through, providing the steel myself to the builder's spec. (used to get them free). my mate (chartered se) checked the calcs (5min job) and all was well.

Si 330

1,306 posts

232 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
you have mail.


AcidReflux

3,210 posts

277 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
We paid £700 all-in for a local builder to do what you've asked on a block wall in our new-build house back in 2004. Took two days and a massive RSJ. No mention of building control or engineers' reports.

I assume that although the house is still standing we're just incredibly lucky and could die at any moment.