Solar panals and feed in Tariff.
Solar panals and feed in Tariff.
Author
Discussion

andy c

Original Poster:

1,216 posts

222 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Any one have any results yet? Are they actually generating enough to earn any money from it?

Ed.

2,176 posts

267 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Not sure how this is car related but
They do not need to make money, the Government subsidy is for every unit of power produced no matter what is done with the power. There is a case for companies to rent your roof space letting you use or sell the power while they keep the subsidy.

anonymous-user

83 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
ashadegreener is coming to fit some on our place sometime soon - weather dependent timetable...

Simpo Two

92,708 posts

294 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
My cousin in Wales (where it always rains) bought a roof-full of solar panels last year and is getting a remarkable income from them. OK it's false as it's a Government wheeze, but the deal is guaranteed for quite a few years regardless of Government.

Can get you more info if you like.

sinizter

3,348 posts

215 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
My cousin in Wales (where it always rains) bought a roof-full of solar panels last year and is getting a remarkable income from them. OK it's false as it's a Government wheeze, but the deal is guaranteed for quite a few years regardless of Government.

Can get you more info if you like.
Yes please. Interested in knowing more about this stuff.

From what I had read previously, they wouldn't really give any sensible payback before the feed in tariff.

Laurel Green

31,120 posts

261 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
There was an advert for this on the TV earlier this evening. I wasn't paying much attention but, did notice something about a 25 year contract.

JustinP1

13,363 posts

259 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
There is a 'white elephant' in this and also home wind generators:


They show you how much it costs and the payback period being 8 or 10 years or whatever, and how much you will 'make' over the following 15 years.

All very nice and green and even a good business plan.

If you read between the lines and the small print, all of these forecasts are based on the current rate of government subsidised electricity back into the system. Which is currently 40 odd pence.

Is the government still going to be paying Joe Public five times over the market rate per unit for electricity in 15, 20, 25 years time?

I think not. And if I'm right, then the payback period means that your gear now is going to have to run without fail for about 20 years.

You'd make more money in an ISA by quite a long way.




andy c

Original Poster:

1,216 posts

222 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Been looking for a bit.
I gather the 41.3p/unit is guarenteed for 25 years + RPI uplift each year, and that rate islimited to 5k units per annum.That is why they dont try to sell you enough to fill a field.You dont get paid that rate for generation over the maximum.

What I need to know is ,has anyone recieved payments yet.It all kicked off in April so someone must have.There is a special meter that tells you how much you have generated apparantly.

The returns quoted are at least 9% of the investment per annum, which is good,possibly alot more.

Only issue is will they last 25 years without servicing/replacement.I gather that some systems are warrented for around 6 years by the manufacturer and that there is a big difference in the standard of the fitting by suppliers and the quality of system they quote on.I suppose going for a well known brand and U pay for what you get ring true here.

It is all very difficult to assess as it is all such a new thing and there are no statistics.To me its all guess work at the moment.

Smiler.

11,752 posts

259 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
The quality of the install is the big issue for me, considering the state of some replacement PVC-u windows I have seen.

I'm having an initial report done at the mo to consider if it's economically viable. I suspect that the report will say that it is, regardless of the facts.

We will see.

If nothing else, I should get a better insight into how it all works.

Dupont666

22,887 posts

221 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/utilities/free-so...

The government will pay £800 per year to you so over 25 years its £23k to have something that cost £12.5k.

Assuming the government dont resind this offer.

Or contact Isis and they will fit them free and then they take the £800 instead of you.

JustinP1

13,363 posts

259 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
andy c said:
I gather the 41.3p/unit is guarenteed for 25 years + RPI uplift each year...

Only issue is will they last 25 years without servicing/replacement....
If you take out the emotional greenness of it, looking at it from a business perspective solely, either of these would be major risks in going forward.


The problem is that if either of those things don't continue for 25 years, then the project struggles to break even. If both, then you will have made a loss.

And I must be honest, if you installed a wind generator that didn't need servicing or replacement for 25 years, and the govt still forked out a silly rate to feed in in 25 years time, I would eat my hat.

Herbs

5,117 posts

258 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
andy c said:
I gather the 41.3p/unit is guarenteed for 25 years + RPI uplift each year...

Only issue is will they last 25 years without servicing/replacement....
If you take out the emotional greenness of it, looking at it from a business perspective solely, either of these would be major risks in going forward.


The problem is that if either of those things don't continue for 25 years, then the project struggles to break even. If both, then you will have made a loss.

And I must be honest, if you installed a wind generator that didn't need servicing or replacement for 25 years, and the govt still forked out a silly rate to feed in in 25 years time, I would eat my hat.
Seeing as I work for a decent govt approved solar company i'll straigten a few things out for you.

1: It isn't a white elephant.
2: So long as you sign up before April 2012 you will received 41.3p on every unit your system produces each year
3: It is valid for 25 years and set in stone.
4: Any excess electricity can be sold back to the electric company for a minimum of 3p (giving you 44p for that unit of electric)
5: The Feed in Tariff is index linked meaning it will go up with inflation so it will be "worth" 41.3p in future money
6: It isn't costing the government as the energy company's have to pay this themselves and have to offer it if they have over 40,000 customers
7: The running of the scheme has been passed over to an independent setup meaning the government now have no say in the scheme and CANNOT change it.
8: It is the safest risk free investment on the market giving minimum returns of 7+%

The free solar panel companys are a good idea but do a lot of investigation first to see if they are right for you. there is a reason why investment comapnys have set these up and ploughed £200-300 million inbto each one - it's because its a guaranteed return.

think about when you use your electric.... if you rent your roof out then you need there permisison to sell your property and any potential buyer has to agree to continue with the scheme.

They take the feed it tariff payemnt and you benefit from the electricity it produces. HOWEVER, if you are at work all day then it will power your fridge, freezer alrm clock easily and the excess will get sold back which they benefit from - not you. When you get home from work you have a couple of hours sunlight left then they stop working just as your consumption starts increasing......

Pv panels will save/earn you the best part of £1000-£1200 a year for a standard sized system whereas you will benefit probably a max of £200 with a free system which when combined with all teh restrictions doesnt make it worth it.

best off getting a cheap loan or adding it to your mortgage and receive all of the benefits without the drawbacks.

If anyone wants a quote and factual figures PM your details

Andy



Edited by Herbs on Friday 24th September 15:06


Edited by Herbs on Friday 24th September 15:07

Simpo Two

92,708 posts

294 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Sound stuff and no doubt all true. But at the end of the day isn't it an economically unsustainable wheeze funded by the taxpayer, just like car and boiler scrappage schemes?

Herbs

5,117 posts

258 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
nope because the tax payer isn't paying for it....

Apart from the fact it is the energy companies which are having to fund it, the previous government signed us up to a very agressive EU agreement where if you fail to reduce your carbon emissions to a certain amount and increase the amount of energy produced by renewable sources to a agreed percent then the fines that are applied are massive......

It's by far the lesser of 2 evils and at least it is being green as well as the end user saving money as well - it's a no brainer imo.

Simpo Two

92,708 posts

294 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Herbs said:
nope because the tax payer isn't paying for it....

Apart from the fact it is the energy companies which are having to fund it, the previous government signed us up to a very agressive EU agreement where if you fail to reduce your carbon emissions to a certain amount and increase the amount of energy produced by renewable sources to a agreed percent then the fines that are applied are massive......

It's by far the lesser of 2 evils and at least it is being green as well as the end user saving money as well - it's a no brainer imo.
But take the long view. The energy companies - where do they get their money from? The utility bill payer.

And when our Government fines them for breaching some fantasy world-saving games, where does that money come from? The utility bill payer.

I'm happy to believe that it's a sound 7% ROCE but it's all just an artificial money merry-go round fuelled by half-baked green politics, and paid for by us. A lucky few have the wits to cash in - for example you, and those who sign up.

Herbs

5,117 posts

258 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
The long view is that it is a drop in the ocean for the energy companies.... coupled with the ever incraesing costs trying to extract gas and oil - look up how much BP has spent/lost over from that one accident recently.

yes you are right, but without renewables - solar or otherwise then energy bills are only ever going to rise. At least with renewables that rise is going to be less. smile

Simpo Two

92,708 posts

294 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Herbs said:
At least with renewables that rise is going to be less. smile
I thought energy from renewables was the most expensive, and subsidised by fossil fuels.

Agreed that it can't last for ever. We need nuclear fusion!

Herbs

5,117 posts

258 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Herbs said:
At least with renewables that rise is going to be less. smile
I thought energy from renewables was the most expensive, and subsidised by fossil fuels.

Agreed that it can't last for ever. We need nuclear fusion!
yes we do and the govt have left it way too late to commission these in time so will be intersting to see what their plan actually is - no doubt they will bugger it up as per usual laugh

RichB

56,247 posts

313 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Herbs said:
At least with renewables that rise is going to be less. smile
I thought energy from renewables was the most expensive, and subsidised by fossil fuels.

Agreed that it can't last for ever. We need nuclear fusion!
Yep, now if it was a case of a domestic nuclear reactor for every home then I'd invest in that!

Herbs

5,117 posts

258 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
followed by mass immigration from Iranians! laugh