St Lucia-Barbados-Antigua ??
St Lucia-Barbados-Antigua ??
Author
Discussion

Husky610

Original Poster:

114 posts

180 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
Im sure some folk have been to these places, Pro's and Con's question really.


Looking to go 10 day mid June just the Two of us, we don't really get to go away with out the kids so looking for somewhere nice but all 3 look fab.


Jos Notstoppen

511 posts

172 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
All nice in their own way!

St Lucia - very green and tropical I stayed near the Pitons, nice beach and views. Only visited once though

Barbados - Can be "touristy" around the Gap area. again good beaches and some good hotels also some poor hotels!

Antigua - flatter than St Lucia, popular with sailing people and could be said to be expensive, Some very nice beaches, they say there are over 365 different ones.

What are you looking for?

The Leaper

5,739 posts

237 months

Monday 14th January 2013
quotequote all
In my view, Aruba, St. Maarten, Union Island and Grand Cayman are better than any of the three you mention. It all depends what you're looking for, of course.

R.

Freddie328

687 posts

232 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Have you thought about Tobago? Haven't been for many years so it could easily have changed but was much prettier & less commercialised than Barbados.

Husky610

Original Poster:

114 posts

180 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
I have worked off Trinidad & Tabago before on a gas platform and spent a good amount of time on both, It's a lovely place actually but I was looking for somewhere I have yet to visit. Done the Cayman Islands and visited Aruba (Be it only for 6 days).. Just a relaxed chilled out Vacation really. Going to knock Barbados on the head I think it is a little too touristy..

Thanks for your input,just looking at Maarten now but afraid to look at the cost!



The Leaper

5,739 posts

237 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
If you're looking at St. Matin/St. Maarten, I'd recommend the French side: the Dutch side is very much set up for visiting Americans and cruise ships.

R.

BaronVonVaderham

2,322 posts

178 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Barbados is wonderful. They 'get' tourism as have been doing it for a few generations. Silverpoint is the best bit of the island. Highly recommend the heli-transfer from airport too, stunning way to see the island.

St.Lucia is ok, but as tourism is relatively new to them it can all be a bit rough around the edges.

Both far nicer than the UK at the mo!

megaphone

11,723 posts

282 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Out of the three I would choose St Lucia, it's varied terrain and scenery win it for me, great rain forest trekking and nice beaches. I've been to all three many times but only on cruise ships.

5pen

2,210 posts

237 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
I like all 3. My experience of them may well be different to others of course, but in general...

Barbados - by far the most developed and upmarket, but still has its charm. The locals are very friendly and helpful. The buses are cheap and fun. Not as 'pretty' as the other two in my opinion and remember that strictly speaking it's in the Atlantic Ocean, not the Caribbean sea, so the water is a bit rougher (even on the west coast) than the those further west. Daily direct flights make it the easiest to get to (from London at least).

Antigua - probably has the best beaches of the three and it's better than the others for snorkelling in my experience. Hotels to suit all budgets. I found it a bit more interesting historically - Shirley Heights, Nelson's Dockyard etc. It's definitely a bit rougher around the edges than Barbados and the whole Stanford affair has had a detrimental impact on the economy recently.

St Lucia - probably the prettiest and least developed of the three. I'd say the beaches were nicer than Barbados but not as good as Antigua. For a small island transfer from the airport to many of the hotels (those in Rodney Bay at least) can take longer than you might think (75 mins). The others are better in this respect if that matters to you.

I'd happily visit any of them again.

Fishtigua

9,786 posts

226 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
As you may have guessed from my name, I spend a lot of time in Antigua due to family and work. After almost 20 years trundleing up and down the Isles, I've learned a bit about each Island.

June is hot, not stupidly hot, but be aware. Depending on the age of the kids, this may be a consideration. High season is either side of Christmas to March/April, low is June/July/August/Sept. The hurricane season is end of May to early November (normally the big ones are Aug/Sept/Oct). This means you can get stinking hot, muggy days followed by pouring rains.



Barbados is really geared up for tourism, if that's what your looking for, but that can get expensive.In summer, you can sometimes get the tattoos & tracksuit brigade there. St.Lucia is getting that way too in certain parts, other parts are still a little backward. Do visit our family's restaurant, the Hummingbird, in Soufriere. Antigua is changing too, there is more to do and see, as mentioned above but you can still be a beach-bum and loll around in a sanitised all-inclusive hotel with no contact with the locals.

The Caribbean can be what you want of it, a beach holiday to bronze on the beach sipping cocktails served by staff from a cheaper island. Alternatively, you can make it an adventure to explore on your own. I like the smaller islands off the beaten track. Dominica, Bequia or the Grenadines. Saying that, I don't have kids and do enjoy sailing everywhere.

TIGA84

5,616 posts

262 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Barbados - Holidays
St Lucia - Honeymoon

I'd go back to Barbados in a heartbeat, St Lucia - not so much, but I think it was clouded by staying at Sandals Grande which was full of meathead braying americans with their intensley dislikeable wives, also all on honeymoon. No amount of alcohol could make me like them, I tried.

Go to Barbados, hire a car and just bugger about, its great, as are the people. It can be a bit touristy in parts, like The Gap and Oistins but even those are full of locals most of the time, I never felt anyhting other than welcome; even at night in Bridgetown.


Husky610

Original Poster:

114 posts

180 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Perfect thank you folks, food for thought which was what I looking for... As is with most things the wife has final say but I can kick her in the right direction!

Cheers.

miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Husky610 said:
Im sure some folk have been to these places, Pro's and Con's question really.


Looking to go 10 day mid June just the Two of us, we don't really get to go away with out the kids so looking for somewhere nice but all 3 look fab.
Cons of St Lucia for 10 days in mid-June?!

Easy - I'm there on honeymoon hehe

Proper con that smile

disco1

1,963 posts

249 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Despite being a stunning island I didnt think that much of Barbados, people were always dodgy/trying to rip us off, whether it's trying to sell some coral which was infact plastic, asking for a beer from your shopping or selling aloe. Be warned, if you refuse them you'll get proper abuse! Saying that I was in St Lawrence. I'm sure some of the upper west coast places are better. I may get laughed at for saying this for the dominican was much better in terms of value and welcome.

If I was to pick somewhere it would be down near the pitons in St Lucia. Proper stunning and quiet.

trickywoo

14,287 posts

261 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
I'm surprised no one has mentioned Grenada.

Lovely island, bit quiet but great for relaxation. It has a proper rain forest too.

I'm sure the game has moved on but I had two weeks there a couple of years ago in a nice hotel for £630 (flight and hotel).

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
The Leaper said:
If you're looking at St. Matin/St. Maarten, I'd recommend the French side: the Dutch side is very much set up for visiting Americans and cruise ships.

R.
THIS!!!

Dblue

3,288 posts

231 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
All good advice.
Been to all 3 and a few others.

I like Barbados a lot, more developed more organised than most Caribbean islands, great Golf courses. the west coast is lovely.

St Lucia is geographically spectacular but very 3rd world. Awful roads and staggering poverty in the heart of the island. Airport is a as far south as you can get and the best resorts are near the northern tip.

Antigua is boringly flat except for the very south around Nelsons harbour which is lovely.

Prefer Grenada to all of them I reckon. Tobago is lovely too and conversley to St Lucia was the shortest transfer I've ever had , honestly could have walked to the hotel in the time it took to load the cab, drive around the one way system and then up the 300m to the Hotel biggrin

Miguel Alvarez

5,195 posts

201 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
disco1 said:
Despite being a stunning island I didnt think that much of Barbados, people were always dodgy/trying to rip us off, whether it's trying to sell some coral which was infact plastic, asking for a beer from your shopping or selling aloe. Be warned, if you refuse them you'll get proper abuse! Saying that I was in St Lawrence. I'm sure some of the upper west coast places are better. I may get laughed at for saying this for the dominican was much better in terms of value and welcome.

If I was to pick somewhere it would be down near the pitons in St Lucia. Proper stunning and quiet.
To a point I've seen that in most places I've been to. My family is from Barbados so I've not really done the tourist thing so miss a good chunk of that sort of experience. Same when visiting Jamaica with the missus and her family but sure as the sun shines if I'm on my own in a tourist part they'll try and "sell" me something. I've only had one guy get shirty. Off the tourist areas you don't get any of that.

I'd liken it to be approached by a group of chuggers every five minutes.

The benefit of having family there is I don't and refuse to pay tourist prices for stuff. A quick...

"Aunty should this cost me $xxx??"
"Chilllld iz you mad?!?! Tell him you mummy name and to stop treating you like the other English"
"You heard my aunt. Give me the Bajan price."

The only thing that did scare me was this one time my cousins and I were coming back from a club. My cousin stops the car because he thinks he's got a flat. I get out have a look and he says later sucker and speeds off. I'm like you bellend. All of a sudden I hear "HEY YELLOW BOY WE GON HAVE SOME FUN WITH YOU" I turn around and what can only be described as Wesley Snipes in a tight dress is starting to walk towards me with a group of other Wesley Snipes in dresses. I ran as fast as I could round the corner and there are my cousins wetting themselves with laughter telling me to get in. bds. I've warned them when they come to England there will be payback.




miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Miguel Alvarez said:
The only thing that did scare me was this one time my cousins and I were coming back from a club. My cousin stops the car because he thinks he's got a flat. I get out have a look and he says later sucker and speeds off. I'm like you bellend. All of a sudden I hear "HEY YELLOW BOY WE GON HAVE SOME FUN WITH YOU" I turn around and what can only be described as Wesley Snipes in a tight dress is starting to walk towards me with a group of other Wesley Snipes in dresses. I ran as fast as I could round the corner and there are my cousins wetting themselves with laughter telling me to get in. bds. I've warned them when they come to England there will be payback.
Brilliant!!!! hehe

cailean

917 posts

204 months

Tuesday 15th January 2013
quotequote all
Husky610 said:
I have worked off Trinidad & Tabago before on a gas platform and spent a good amount of time on both, It's a lovely place actually but I was looking for somewhere I have yet to visit. Done the Cayman Islands and visited Aruba (Be it only for 6 days).. Just a relaxed chilled out Vacation really. Going to knock Barbados on the head I think it is a little too touristy..

Thanks for your input,just looking at Maarten now but afraid to look at the cost!
Go on you know you want to have another trini doubles with slight pepper, or goat roti, or lime in a rum shop and drink Stag (a man's beer) or Carib....