Tube travel / Oyster card??
Tube travel / Oyster card??
Author
Discussion

cmc60

Original Poster:

4 posts

161 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
We're going to London as a family, arriving mid-day on Sunday, and leaving at 1945hrs on Monday.

Not quite 48 hours - are we best to get normal daily travel cards for each day, or are Oyster cards more sensible over two days?

We'll only be needing Zone1.

OzzyR1

6,402 posts

263 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all


How many kids have you got and how old?

TBH, sounds like you'd be better with travelcards. Make sure you buy them after 9.30am on the Monday otherwise you will be hit by peak fares - adult travelcard off-peak = £7.30/day.

Children's depends on ages.

Terminator X

20,985 posts

235 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Oyster card is always cheaper than a travelcard isn't it? Probably not worth the hassle of getting them just for 2 days though; as a daily commuter then definitely yes.

TX.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
Oyster card is always cheaper than a travelcard isn't it? Probably not worth the hassle of getting them just for 2 days though; as a daily commuter then definitely yes.

TX.
It's hardly a hassle - no harder than buying a ticket in fact since you can get them at the ticket office at a tube station. They then last forever so you can use them next time you go to London. The only problem is remembering where you put it. biggrin

Terminator X

20,985 posts

235 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Ah ok, thought you had to get them through the post for some reason redface had mine for so long, perhaps it was like that back then wink

TX.

rich85uk

4,390 posts

210 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
i guess it depends how much you will use the underground, my brother lives in London and i used one when i saw him last. you were billed each time you used the underground and 1 or 2 stops was something daft like 60p, but more if you went further.

Also from what he told me they wont use more than £5 in one day, so i would be tempted with the Oyster card

OzzyR1

6,402 posts

263 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
rich85uk said:
i guess it depends how much you will use the underground, my brother lives in London and i used one when i saw him last. you were billed each time you used the underground and 1 or 2 stops was something daft like 60p, but more if you went further.

Also from what he told me they wont use more than £5 in one day, so i would be tempted with the Oyster card
That must have been a while ago!!

Off-peak journeys are now about a couple of quid on an Oyster - even if you go one stop from Oxford Circus to Bond Street or similar which is walkable in about 5 minutes.

Daily cap on an off-peak oyster I think is £7.00 in Zone 1 vs. just buying an off-peak Zone 1 travelcard for £7.30.

The amount of hassle you will have to go through to get Oysters if you don't have them already - assuming 2 kids, filling in 4 forms in total (2x adult, 2x children) and then paying £5/deposit on each oyster card and THEN, if you don't plan to keep them, you have to queue up again in the station to get your deposits back when you leave just isn't worth it imho.

Sounds like you are arriving by train too and the queues at the staffed ticket offices at the stations are horrendous.

Just get travelcards.

ETA: Oyster vs Travelcard prices:

http://www.tfl.gov.uk/tickets/14416.aspx







davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
OzzyR1 said:
The amount of hassle you will have to go through to get Oysters if you don't have them already - assuming 2 kids, filling in 4 forms in total (2x adult, 2x children) and then paying £5/deposit on each oyster card and THEN, if you don't plan to keep them, you have to queue up again in the station to get your deposits back when you leave just isn't worth it imho.
You don't need to fill in any forms AIUI. Just go to the counter (or even a ticket machine in some cases(), pay your money, get the card. If you want to, you can then register the card online for automatic top-ups, but it's not necessary. Having the Oyster card is incredibly handy even if you only travel to London irregularly since you'll never need to queue for a ticket again. Also it's fun to feel like a "proper" Londoner, even just for a day or two. biggrin

If you want to return the cards for a refund of the deposit you can do it by post when you've got home.

OzzyR1

6,402 posts

263 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all

You can't get an oyster card from a machine, you have to buy, register them and fill in various details at a counter.

You can apply for a refund from home true - but if you didn't fill out forms and pay the deposit at the counter in the first place, how would they re-credit the deposit when you returned them by post?

If the OP doesn't visit London that much, daily travelcards are far easier.


surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
OzzyR1 said:
You can't get an oyster card from a machine, you have to buy, register them and fill in various details at a counter.

You can apply for a refund from home true - but if you didn't fill out forms and pay the deposit at the counter in the first place, how would they re-credit the deposit when you returned them by post?

If the OP doesn't visit London that much, daily travelcards are far easier.
You can get OC from machine's and then register them for topping up later online. I know this as this is what I have done.

I'm also not sure why you need to waste time getting one for kids, unless they are over ten.

stu67

891 posts

219 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
OzzyR1 said:
You can't get an oyster card from a machine, you have to buy, register them and fill in various details at a counter.

You can apply for a refund from home true - but if you didn't fill out forms and pay the deposit at the counter in the first place, how would they re-credit the deposit when you returned them by post?

If the OP doesn't visit London that much, daily travelcards are far easier.
You can get OC from machine's and then register them for topping up later online. I know this as this is what I have done.

I'm also not sure why you need to waste time getting one for kids, unless they are over ten.
You can get the cards from the machines, had to get another for myself yesterday as my son had "borrowed" mine ( probably because it had some money on it). They cost £5 plus whatever you put on them in £5 increments. Would have thought it worth having them for a long weekend and you can always use them again if you come back to town. Kids are free on the tube under 11 years, be careful if you use the London overground as the age limit is lower, think 5 years?.
Have a great time around town

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
stu67 said:
surveyor said:
OzzyR1 said:
You can't get an oyster card from a machine, you have to buy, register them and fill in various details at a counter.

You can apply for a refund from home true - but if you didn't fill out forms and pay the deposit at the counter in the first place, how would they re-credit the deposit when you returned them by post?

If the OP doesn't visit London that much, daily travelcards are far easier.
You can get OC from machine's and then register them for topping up later online. I know this as this is what I have done.

I'm also not sure why you need to waste time getting one for kids, unless they are over ten.
You can get the cards from the machines, had to get another for myself yesterday as my son had "borrowed" mine ( probably because it had some money on it). They cost £5 plus whatever you put on them in £5 increments. Would have thought it worth having them for a long weekend and you can always use them again if you come back to town. Kids are free on the tube under 11 years, be careful if you use the London overground as the age limit is lower, think 5 years?.
Have a great time around town
http://visitorshop.tfl.gov.uk/help-centre/travelling-with-children.html



Edited by surveyor on Sunday 11th August 20:24

Nickyboy

6,826 posts

265 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
The single trip price for an Oyster card is a lot cheaper but it is per trip whereas a day travelcard can be used as many times as you like in the validity period. Is that right?

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
If you make lots of pay as you go journeys in one day, we'll make sure you never pay more than the price of an equivalent Day Travelcard*.

http://www.tfl.gov.uk/tickets/14837.aspx#tube

PF62

4,065 posts

204 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
stu67 said:
They cost £5 plus whatever you put on them in £5 increments.
To be more precise, the first £5 is a refundable deposit, not a cost.

Anyway, for visitors, if you pay for your Oyster card in cash, when you have finished with it at the end of your visit, hand it in at the last London Underground ticket office you pass through (with proof of your name and address) and they will give you the cash remaining on the card (including the £5 deposit) straight back. Pay on card, and it gets more complex.

anothernameitist

1,500 posts

166 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
From personal experiance I'd not use an Oyster card and thats the advice I received from a relative who lives in London too.

Mine had some fault on it, not always scanning when leaving the station, staff were quiet helpful ( all bar one who thought I'd jumped the barrier!) ,but in the end I got sick and tired of the problems and didn't want a fine, so bought a day card.

To be honest TFL were helpful and after sending off copies of all the problems I'd had I got a refund for the day ticket, so wasn't really out of pocket.

Next time I'll just buy a day card.
HTH

Guvernator

14,501 posts

196 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Yep the problem with an Oyster card is you HAVE to touch in and touch out at EVERY journey, not a problem if the stations have barriers that you have to open using the card but a quite a few don't.

If you forget to touch in\out with an Oyster you will get charged the full fare which is something like £7 and you could also end up with a fine if you get collared by a ticket inspector. Not worth the hassle especially with a couple of kids in tow I reckon as even I have been caught out by this on occasion and I travel into Central London most days. Just get a offpeak travelcard which will cost you the same amount of money for the day and you don't need to worry about it or remembering to get your deposit back etc.

Timja

1,955 posts

240 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Can you get a travelcard as part of your rail ticket into London? I know when I travel in at the weekend it is £8 to get to St Pancras or £12 for a 1 day travelcard. So only costs £4 extra for unlimited travel in all zones. Not sure if this is possible if you are there for 2 days though..

Not sure how old your kids are or what family tickets cost, but I know they offer a group save ticket in my line, so 3/4 adults tickets cost the same as 2. Just have to ask for it at ticket desk/may be possible frm machine too.

knight

5,235 posts

310 months

Saturday 24th August 2013
quotequote all
Had a weekend in London last week and decided to get an Oyster card, picked it up at the travel office at Victoria and bought it on a debit card, when we left we went back to the same office and got a full refund of what was left on the card and the £5 deposit in cash. Took all of a few minutes to do and would definitely use them again.

iphonedyou

10,424 posts

188 months

Sunday 25th August 2013
quotequote all
Always get the oyster. Once you're over the travel card cost for the day they max out and you pay no more regardless of how much you travel. The advantage is that if you only take one journey on a day, you on,y pay for that. I you buy the travel card, you've wasted a fiver in that situation.