Suitcases on spinners, look a tad fragile?
Suitcases on spinners, look a tad fragile?
Author
Discussion

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

315 months

Sunday 15th September 2013
quotequote all
Need some new suitcases and much as they move nicely on spinners, they look a bit easy to damage. Worth a punt or will they be going back for refund/repair?

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Sunday 15th September 2013
quotequote all
jmorgan said:
Need some new suitcases and much as they move nicely on spinners, they look a bit easy to damage. Worth a punt or will they be going back for refund/repair?
Depends how you use them. Given reasonable care they should be OK my cases are two years old no probs.

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

315 months

Sunday 15th September 2013
quotequote all
Happy with them out the plane, but should add they will be checked.

smack

9,777 posts

222 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
The OH and I have been using a large Samsonite case with spinners, and the the last 10 months it must have done just under 19 flights and counting, and the OH lived out of it for 5 weeks on the road. The case has some decent battle scars, but all superficial and the case has performed flawlessly. I thought the spinners would be the weak link with the case, but any hit they rotate and the wheel take the force. At the end of the day it has a 10 year warranty, so they must have some faith in their design.

I was impressed enough to by a 2nd one of the same type, in the medium size which being used to take my motorbiking kit to the US next week (large case to be filled stuff to be brought back!) for a bit of play time once work has been dealt with.

h0b0

9,101 posts

227 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
I will only buy spinners. I'm over 6 foot tall and walking a case on all 4 wheels is the most comfortable way to get around an airport. We have 5 suitcases with spinners, 2 have been around the world and abused at every airport they have passed through. The wheels are still in perfect condition. The other 3 are just starting their life due to my expanding family.

One thing though. Don't buy cheap.

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

315 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Cheers. Not going cheap but some of the top end cases are going to be too far considering. OK, not that flimsy then if you get one well made.

Matt..

4,035 posts

220 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
I have a hard sided Samsonite with two big wheels that i bought ~6yrs ago (for approx £200). It's perfect. The big wheels make it easy to pull along, and dragging it up curbs, or across rough ground isn't really an issue. I didn't go for a spinner for the basic fact that i take it to more places than the airport, then to a waiting taxi, then to a hotel biggrin I am 6ft4, so not short, and find this setup ideal for me.

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

315 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Got the encased two wheelers at the moment, thinking they were a good design at time being part protected but out looking for replacements and the options are narrowing, seems like more spinners being the norm. Increases the size as well whilst having no benefit for carrying capacity but that is a small issue in the grand scheme. Get from A to B with minimum fuss, worst comes to the worst the wife can carry it.


Edit. Still have a Carlton that was made in England (yep, that long ago 1992??) where one of the corner wheels has disintegrated, plastic tyre part that is, bearing etc still good. Need to chase Carlton see if they do a spare. Still in good working order overall but too small. Problem with this type though is they have the wheels on the narrow side and the damn thing flips on its side at the slightest. But the clasps rather than the zip is what I like about that one, samsonite looks like it may fir the bill.

Edited by jmorgan on Monday 16th September 08:34

NorthDave

2,541 posts

263 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
You might want to look at Eastpac. I bought a wheel on case a few years ago and when paying the lady told me it had something mental like a 30 year guarantee. Its been around a bit now and still looks new.

fizz47

3,252 posts

241 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
I have a American by Samsonite 4 wheel spinner hard case which I use for my work travel.

Over the last 12 months I have taken probably over 35 flights and wheels seem fine. Case has a few scratches but nothing serious.

The 4 wheels are great on a smooth surface however when you go to slightly uneven services or a surface which may have small stones then it can be a little annoying and at that time would prefer to large wheel suitcases.

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

315 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Larger the wheels the better. Check.

You would think someone would have come up with the idea of retractable all terrain wheels. A proper PH case with shiny bits and chrome everywhere....

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
smack said:
The OH and I have been using a large Samsonite case with spinners, and the the last 10 months it must have done just under 19 flights and counting, and the OH lived out of it for 5 weeks on the road. The case has some decent battle scars, but all superficial and the case has performed flawlessly. I thought the spinners would be the weak link with the case, but any hit they rotate and the wheel take the force. At the end of the day it has a 10 year warranty, so they must have some faith in their design.

I was impressed enough to by a 2nd one of the same type, in the medium size which being used to take my motorbiking kit to the US next week (large case to be filled stuff to be brought back!) for a bit of play time once work has been dealt with.
Don't put too much faith in the warranty. It excludes handling damage and only covers manufacturing faults.

That said, I have some well used Samsonites with spinners and they have lasted well.

Alex L

2,596 posts

285 months

Tuesday 17th September 2013
quotequote all
I bought 2 of the Samsonite Firelight cases earlier this year and have been used on 3 international trips. They have picked up some scratches but appear to be very strong while only weighing 2.9kg.

I bought from here when they were doing 10% discount for signing up and received a further discount via Quidco, brining the price to about £250 each. http://www.bagsdirect.com/samsonite-firelite-spinn...

The Leaper

5,734 posts

237 months

Tuesday 17th September 2013
quotequote all
Several years ago I needed a new suitcase for global business and holiday travelling, not too large but not small either. I did a lot of research and eventually I bought a Briggs and Riley with 2 wheels, extending handle etc. This case has been superb. It was not cheap but comes with a life time guarantee and I am not expecting to replace it. My wife has bought an Antler but envies the quality of my B&R and the way it takes as much as her case although mine is smaller (must be a man thing!).

R.

jmorgan

Original Poster:

36,010 posts

315 months

Wednesday 18th September 2013
quotequote all
Yeah, saw them and they do look solid but the price is a bit further than my wallet otherwise they would be on the list.

Corpulent Tosser

5,468 posts

276 months

Wednesday 18th September 2013
quotequote all
I was looking for a new carry on and found this.

Didn't buy it though.