BA Club or Virgin Upper to US West Coast
BA Club or Virgin Upper to US West Coast
Author
Discussion

nofuse22

Original Poster:

215 posts

206 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
I need to travel to the US West Coast: LHR to LAX on way out and probably back from San Francisco...

2 options: BA Club or Virgin Upper

In BA's favour, for the LA leg likely to be an A380 (+ have a BA gold card so may get upgraded to First from Business)

Virgin - never used them before (hence the BA Gold Card...), but hear it is pretty good

Thoughts?

LooneyTunes

9,517 posts

189 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Are you travelling with others?

BA's seats are more private, so would be my preference if by myself, but prefer UC's more open layout if travelling with a small group.

That said, I find Virgin's seats are more comfortable for sleeping (the last BA revision placed a ridge in just the wrong position for me).

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Personally I'd avoid the 380, far too many people. Travelling business on Emirates on the 380 you are one of about 70 which means that the lounge is rammed before the flight, preferential boarding makes you one of 70, preferential baggage doesn't mean your bags are off particularly soon and they can take an eternity if mixed up with the rest. Then embarking and disembarking takes longer...

On the plus side, yes it's quite smooth and quiet.

toohuge

3,501 posts

247 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
As you're flying into the US and are a gold Avios member, I would fly BA. Virgin do have limited flights in the US, whereas BA is partnered with AA and your ff status is respected at AA too so if your flights are delayed or diverted flying with BA will be a much better choice.

Chris

Extra 300 Driver

5,282 posts

277 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
If you're BA gold then go BA. A380 will be less chance of an Op Up as it has more J seats and is less likely to be full. I would go 747-4 and grab 62K or 64K and if you get an Op Up then even better.

audidoody

8,598 posts

287 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Going out is a day flight so the beds are irrelevant. Virgin UC has a cabin bar. For night flight BA Club World compartments have a bit more privacy for sleeping (especially next to the window). Either way it will be a comfortable flight!

Kenty

5,287 posts

206 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
BA A380 every time.

trickywoo

14,282 posts

261 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
I can't comment on the fancy seats but in cattle class BA every time for me. I think I'd rather swim the Atlantic trailing chum than go Virgin again.

petop

2,410 posts

197 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
If the BA 380's are like the Emirates ones then go for that. Economy is very good in the Emirates planes. I now travel business but wouldnt complain if i had to slum it in A380 economy!

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
Virgin all the way, imo.

BA aren't BAD (try a US carrier for a horrible experience), but Virgin are always better imvho.

It was a few years ago now, but Virgin Upper Class to SF (and back on another trip) ruined every other flight for me frown

M

NormalWisdom

2,184 posts

190 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
Virgin all the way, imo.

BA aren't BAD (try a US carrier for a horrible experience), but Virgin are always better imvho.

It was a few years ago now, but Virgin Upper Class to SF (and back on another trip) ruined every other flight for me frown

M
Ditto - Have spent many years commuting long-haul with Virgin, one flight from Mexico City with BA was a nightmare (Just to go Virgin I used to go via Miami but on one occasion had no choice)

miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
BA on the A380.

LooneyTunes

9,517 posts

189 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
toohuge said:
As you're flying into the US and are a gold Avios member, I would fly BA. Virgin do have limited flights in the US, whereas BA is partnered with AA and your ff status is respected at AA too so if your flights are delayed or diverted flying with BA will be a much better choice.

Chris
Unless it's changed recently, AA business is awful - make sure you don't accidentally end up on an AA operated codeshare! Mind you, I have got a >50% upgrade rate with AA, and their F isn't too bad.

miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
toohuge said:
As you're flying into the US and are a gold Avios member, I would fly BA. Virgin do have limited flights in the US, whereas BA is partnered with AA and your ff status is respected at AA too so if your flights are delayed or diverted flying with BA will be a much better choice.

Chris
Unless it's changed recently, AA business is awful - make sure you don't accidentally end up on an AA operated codeshare! Mind you, I have got a >50% upgrade rate with AA, and their F isn't too bad.
If flying from LHR do consider American Airlines operated flights, their new business class is supposed to be excellent. Available on all flights operated by their new B77W aircraft - these definitely to the LAX route, not sure about SFO though.

LooneyTunes

9,517 posts

189 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
miln0039 said:
If flying from LHR do consider American Airlines operated flights, their new business class is supposed to be excellent. Available on all flights operated by their new B77W aircraft - these definitely to the LAX route, not sure about SFO though.
That's interesting - I've been so enthusiastically avoiding them that I was unaware they'd been updating.

miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
That's interesting - I've been so enthusiastically avoiding them that I was unaware they'd been updating.
http://www.aa.com/i18n/utility/boeing-777-300ER.jsp?anchorLocation=DirectURL&title=fly777 this shows detail of the new cabin and which flights operate with the new cabin. This is a very recent change in cabin but has been positively received thus far - I like you had done everything to avoid American in the last 10 years!!! It would appear though that they've finally realised they need to move the game on to keep up with EU carriers!

Mosman

778 posts

236 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
miln0039 said:
http://www.aa.com/i18n/utility/boeing-777-300ER.js... this shows detail of the new cabin and which flights operate with the new cabin. This is a very recent change in cabin but has been positively received thus far - I like you had done everything to avoid American in the last 10 years!!! It would appear though that they've finally realised they need to move the game on to keep up with EU carriers!
Flew JFK/LHR in the new AA 777-300ER cabin in April. I was expecting the flight to be much better then it was, mostly it was the service that let things down. Seat was close to the galley and quite noisy, cabin lights still on at 2am whilst trying to sleep (cabin crew were rude when I pointed this out). I've flown AA quite a lot in coach and business and although the service in business is normally OK I wouldn't say it was in the same league as BA/Virgin.

I've always had OK flights in BA Club, it's nice and quiet upstairs on a 747 (haven't flow on a BA A380 so have no experience of that).

Remember that Virgin don't have business class, there is only Economy, Premium Economy and Upper Class so it is effectively their First Class (although it's perhaps more of a hybrid between Business an First). In my opinion the seats are better when converted to beds (when compared to BA Club).

The other thing that should be remembered is that you get a limo (well Volvo estate from LHR) to/from the airport which is nice and you do get a nice quick check-in/security experience. I'd say the Virgin Clubhouse is better than the BA Terrace (unless you can get into the First Class lounge?) although the SFO Clubhouse not that great and it's landside.


miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Mosman said:
miln0039 said:
http://www.aa.com/i18n/utility/boeing-777-300ER.js... this shows detail of the new cabin and which flights operate with the new cabin. This is a very recent change in cabin but has been positively received thus far - I like you had done everything to avoid American in the last 10 years!!! It would appear though that they've finally realised they need to move the game on to keep up with EU carriers!
Flew JFK/LHR in the new AA 777-300ER cabin in April. I was expecting the flight to be much better then it was, mostly it was the service that let things down. Seat was close to the galley and quite noisy, cabin lights still on at 2am whilst trying to sleep (cabin crew were rude when I pointed this out). I've flown AA quite a lot in coach and business and although the service in business is normally OK I wouldn't say it was in the same league as BA/Virgin.

I've always had OK flights in BA Club, it's nice and quiet upstairs on a 747 (haven't flow on a BA A380 so have no experience of that).

Remember that Virgin don't have business class, there is only Economy, Premium Economy and Upper Class so it is effectively their First Class (although it's perhaps more of a hybrid between Business an First). In my opinion the seats are better when converted to beds (when compared to BA Club).

The other thing that should be remembered is that you get a limo (well Volvo estate from LHR) to/from the airport which is nice and you do get a nice quick check-in/security experience. I'd say the Virgin Clubhouse is better than the BA Terrace (unless you can get into the First Class lounge?) although the SFO Clubhouse not that great and it's landside.
Virgin Upper is business, not First.

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
miln0039 said:
Virgin Upper is business, not First.
Debatable. They don't have a specific first or a specific business, and IMO Upper is a bit of a hybrid. It's better than business, not as good as first.

The limo service and the lounge are well worth it. The limo and dedicated security channel in particular. It's nice being checked in whilst still sat in the car and then whisked straight through security to the lounge.


Mosman

778 posts

236 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
mattdaniels said:
miln0039 said:
Virgin Upper is business, not First.
Debatable. They don't have a specific first or a specific business, and IMO Upper is a bit of a hybrid. It's better than business, not as good as first.

The limo service and the lounge are well worth it. The limo and dedicated security channel in particular. It's nice being checked in whilst still sat in the car and then whisked straight through security to the lounge.
Pretty much sums it up (and what I was trying to say above)