JFK to Times Square
Author
Discussion

pincher

Original Poster:

10,647 posts

248 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
Taking my 2 kids over to see NY at Easter and need to sort out transfer to Times Square - what's the best option these days? Yellow cab or pre-book something?

Are the yellow cabs still a fixed price and if pre-book, are there any recommendations on who to use/avoid?

COLONEL_SMITH

275 posts

268 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
Yellow cab set price was $50 or $55 back in may..That was JFK to fifth avenue..

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
IIRC the liveried limo firms are not much more expensive, and offer less chance of being driven into something at 90 miles an hour by a driver who is simultaneously shouting at his mobile phone and eating a sandwich.

That said, sliding around on the vinyl seat of a Crown Vic is a quintessential NY experience. And unless you intend to get arrested this is probably the best way to do it. wink

theaxe

3,571 posts

253 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
I go to New York fairly regularly (was there last week) and although my company will pay for a 'Black car service' I always just get a cab. Trying to find your Black Car is always a faff and there are nearly always yellow cabs queuing up.

IIRC the fare is fixed at $52 plus the toll (about $5.50) to anywhere in the city/Manhatten so I usually round it up to $65.

You occasionally get an 'interesting' ride but it seems to happen less than it used to. Also these days the seat belts generally work which wasn't always the case!

audidoody

8,598 posts

287 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
+1 for a limo

Last time we had a driver with a Mercedes GL for $75 (plus $20 tip).

Having a guy meet you and help you carry your bags is MUCH more civilised than queuing for a Yellow Cab and sitting in a vinyl cell behind bullet-proof perspex with a Ukrainian driver whose conversation starts with "grunt" and ends with "grunt" and who likes to see how fast his barge will go on FDR Drive.

Just Google "NYC+airport+ Limo".

There are dozens of them.


5MUG

734 posts

295 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
I use Dial 7 Limo service. Very good. They text / tell you the car number and name of driver.

pincher

Original Poster:

10,647 posts

248 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
Will check out Dial7 beer

MarkJS

2,191 posts

178 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I used Strussers for a Limo last week - excellent service.

They got better reviews than Dial 7 (I heard mixed things about them TBH).

skibum

1,032 posts

268 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I tend to be a cheapskate and get the airtrain to Jamaica and then the subway (7?) all the way into Manhattan. But probably not great with two kids and luggage in tow.

In your situation, I would go with Limo. Would be great for the Kids to see some bloke in a suit with your name on a card as you come through the gate - much more of an experience than queueing up with everyone else for a cab.

pincher

Original Poster:

10,647 posts

248 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
MarkJS said:
I used Strussers for a Limo last week - excellent service.

They got better reviews than Dial 7 (I heard mixed things about them TBH).
I'm finding the same (which will teach me to look on TripAdvisor!!).

That said, CarMel seem to get even worse reviews smile

pincher

Original Poster:

10,647 posts

248 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
skibum said:
Would be great for the Kids to see some bloke in a suit with your name on a card as you come through the gate - much more of an experience than queueing up with everyone else for a cab.
Thats a very good point - am sure they would love that.

From what I can work out, you have to go and hunt for your Dial7 driver? I guess someone like Strussers would actually greet you as you come through Customs?

MarkJS

2,191 posts

178 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
pincher said:
Thats a very good point - am sure they would love that.

From what I can work out, you have to go and hunt for your Dial7 driver? I guess someone like Strussers would actually greet you as you come through Customs?
The Strussers driver (Mike) was waiting for me with a board showing my name. It all worked faultlessly.

pincher

Original Poster:

10,647 posts

248 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Strussers it is then! A good way to start the weekend biggrin

Now, does anybody know if the New York Pass is worth it? ears

BigBen

12,161 posts

261 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
You can get a fast train to Penn station which is not far from Times Square, takes less time and more importantly a consistent journey time.

audidoody

8,598 posts

287 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all

scratchchin

Limo:
1. Exit arrivals doors.
2. Meet man holding card with your name on it
3. Walk to car
4. Enter car
5. Arrive destination
6. Exit car

Train
1. Exit arrival doors.
2. Walk to JFK Airport Airtrain carrying bags
3. Board train
4.. Hump luggage onto luggage racks
5. Find seat
6. Arrive Penn Station
7. Hump bags off train
8. Pay $5 pp fare to exit station
9. Exit station - carrying luggage
10.Hail a cab to final destination (or catch subway)



GCH

4,142 posts

233 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Just be aware that most limo companies at JFK will charge past a certain waiting time....say, if you get held up at immigration.

Dial 7 are pretty reliable

BigBen

12,161 posts

261 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
audidoody said:
scratchchin

Limo:
1. Exit arrivals doors.
2. Meet man holding card with your name on it
3. Walk to car
4. Enter car
5. Arrive destination
6. Exit car

Train
1. Exit arrival doors.
2. Walk to JFK Airport Airtrain carrying bags
3. Board train
4.. Hump luggage onto luggage racks
5. Find seat
6. Arrive Penn Station
7. Hump bags off train
8. Pay $5 pp fare to exit station
9. Exit station - carrying luggage
10.Hail a cab to final destination (or catch subway)
You missed step 4.5 on the car which is: sit on Long Island Express way for an hour breathing in fumes, get car sick as driver uses slip roads as 'short cut', etc

Travelling for the return flight I often use a car service as it tends to be much later in the day but during the day the traffic is often a disaster, would rather spend more time at my destination than in a car.

Ben



MarkJS

2,191 posts

178 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
GCH said:
Just be aware that most limo companies at JFK will charge past a certain waiting time....say, if you get held up at immigration.

Dial 7 are pretty reliable
No waiting charge with Strussers which was another factor on my booking.

5MUG

734 posts

295 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
GCH said:
Just be aware that most limo companies at JFK will charge past a certain waiting time....say, if you get held up at immigration.

Dial 7 are pretty reliable
Oh yes I'd forgotten immigration.......... it's looooooong queue.

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
5MUG said:
GCH said:
Just be aware that most limo companies at JFK will charge past a certain waiting time....say, if you get held up at immigration.

Dial 7 are pretty reliable
Oh yes I'd forgotten immigration.......... it's looooooong queue.
Not always. We were there for 5 minutes a year ago. Expected far worse.