Flying to US, driving to Canada, returning to UK from there
Flying to US, driving to Canada, returning to UK from there
Author
Discussion

PhillT

Original Poster:

2,489 posts

256 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Chaps,
I've sent this query to a couple of official agencies, but am not always terribly hopeful of getting a response from such places. So thought I'd consult the PH knowledge bank to see if anyone already knew.

The missus and I are doing a big road trip later this year. Our plan is to fly to the US, travel by land into Canada, and either 1) return to the UK from Toronto or 2) go back to the US by land and fly back to the UK from either New York or Boston.

We're both Brits and will be entering the US under the Visa Waiver Program. Our total time in North America will be less than 90 days.

What's pickling me a bit is the logistics of how this will work, and what we'll need to have evidence of when we first enter the US. Will a ticket to the UK from Toronto or New York/Boston be sufficient, or will we also need to book some form of documentable journey from US to Canada to show that we're definitely leaving the US?

We were originally planning to take a cab over the border between Detroit and Windsor. If anyone has experience of doing that, it would be much appreciated.

Also, if we leave the US at the Detroit land crossing and re-enter a week letter in Niagara, will we need extra paperwork or anything like that?

Thanks in advance.

ViperDave

5,775 posts

284 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
I've not tried your exact scenario but have crossed the land boarder a few times. I wouldn't worry too much about your arrival with a return ticket from Toronto, All they will care about is an intent to leave, just carry a copy of the e-ticket receipt and to be honest there not much else you can do. I would be more worried about leaving at Detroit and coming back a week later in buffalo after you have been there for a large chunk of your 90 days, They may see this as an attempt to extend your stamp, although in theory Canada doesn't count as an exit for that purpose, and they should just re-admit you on your original stamp and entry fee, not sure how well that works when you don't get an I94W "green VWP" card via air anymore.

Entering Canada has always been a lot easier than the USofA but I would be inclined before you drop of your car, to check with a taxi firm that they will transport you across the boarder, worst case you could always nip across in the car, check into the hotel and drop the luggage then go back drop the car and walk across the bridge and take in the view of the falls at the same time, But that's a lot of faff and I'd allow at least an hour for a CA>US land crossing, as even in pre 9/11 days it was a visit to secondary. If your lucky and the guy on the gate is happy with your stamp you just have an extra hour free.

I'd seriously consider starting in Vancouver if I was you. Hire the car and return it in the same country as one trip, if your still doing the Olympics it wont add any time via Vancouver island and Victoria, and the ferries across there have some nice scenery.

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
I did this without trouble last year. LHR to Dallas to Seattle, drive to Vancouver fly to LHR.

No eyes blinked, no challenges or problems. The drive from Seattle was also very nice.

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
I did this without trouble last year. LHR to Dallas to Seattle, drive to Vancouver fly to LHR.

No eyes blinked, no challenges or problems. The drive from Seattle was also very nice.

hoegaardenruls

1,224 posts

163 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
PhillT said:
Also, if we leave the US at the Detroit land crossing and re-enter a week letter in Niagara, will we need extra paperwork or anything like that?

Thanks in advance.
Have done this a couple of times without an eyelid batted, last time into Canada at Niagara and back into the US at Sarnia, Michigan.

Your passport will have been stamped at the port of entry into the US, with a date showing admitted until ddmmyy. This with your onward flight details will be enough. I think the only question I had concerned where the car was rented from..

tvrolet

4,771 posts

313 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Have done it 'both ways round' but only on the west coast, but I can't see the other border crossings will be much different.

Canada to US (certainly on the Vancouver/Seattle route) you have to get out of the car and go into the 'office', then its the same procedure as airport immigration - fingers on finger-print reader, photo etc. Heading from US to Canada (that was a few years ago now) I don't think we even had to get out of the car.

And no problems entering the US when the 'exit' is planned as a drive-out; never been asked as to the method/route of leaving the country, and I go there a lot (and off again on Friday).

I note you say 'under 90 days'. Just remember there is no mandatory minimum time the immigration officer can give you if you are planning a particularly long jaunt (like 89 days). I'm pretty sure every stamp I've ever had has been 3 months and I haven't heard of folks having problems unless they're taking the pi$$ with continual back-to-back trips, but it is up to the immigration officer's discretion so be nice to the bloke (or lass) wink

I've never driven in the Detroit/Toronto/Niagara area so can't comment on its suitability as a road trip, but if you're tempted with a California/Canada road trip then the best advice is probably don't. California is great - San Diego to San Francisco, and there's some nice drives from Vancouver too....but from San Francisco north to Seattle there's 800-odd miles of nothing really worth seeing.

Burrow01

1,989 posts

223 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Only issue I had doing this when going across the border from Canada and back again was to make sure that we gave the notification of leaving the country (US) on our last exit from the US - cannot remember if we had to give them back part of the visa or something, but we definitely had to make sure the exit was recorded.

Other than that it was not a problem

ViperDave

5,775 posts

284 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
I haven't heard of folks having problems unless they're taking the pi$$ with continual back-to-back trips, but it is up to the immigration officer's discretion so be nice to the bloke (or lass) wink
We got a snarky comment from one once following two 4 week trips and on entering for 3 weeks all well spaced out but within a 12month period. The comment was along the lines of "I'll let you in this time, but you need to be careful of your 90 days welcome"

tvrolet said:
I've never driven in the Detroit/Toronto/Niagara area so can't comment on its suitability as a road trip, but if you're tempted with a California/Canada road trip then the best advice is probably don't. California is great - San Diego to San Francisco, and there's some nice drives from Vancouver too....but from San Francisco north to Seattle there's 800-odd miles of nothing really worth seeing.
I don't know, Mt Shasta is worth turning you head for whilst you speed by on I5 thankful for something interesting to see on that soulless road, Crater lake is defiantly worth a visit, as is a detour up the Columbia river gorge, Mt St Helens is a pilgrimage and Mt Rainer if your not bored of volcano mountains by that stage. There's a few other interesting geological features off in the woods east of Redding, but you'd have to be getting desperate for places to go having been everywhere else first, been there don't them lol

tvrolet

4,771 posts

313 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Burrow01 said:
Only issue I had doing this when going across the border from Canada and back again was to make sure that we gave the notification of leaving the country (US) on our last exit from the US - cannot remember if we had to give them back part of the visa or something, but we definitely had to make sure the exit was recorded.

Other than that it was not a problem
Was that maybe the old green I94 form counterfoil pre ESTA? With ESTAs there's nothing to 'hand back'. I've also had instances on the old I94s where the airline didn't take the counterfoil so there was no leaving record and I called the US embassy to see what to do. They just said on the next trip take proof of departure such as the air ticket, plus some evidence that you had been out of the country such as bank statements with UK purchases, payslips and utility bills. I was fully armed with evidence on the next trip but immigration didn't even mention that there wasn't a record of the last departure.

tvrolet

4,771 posts

313 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
ViperDave said:
..and Mt Rainer if your not bored of volcano mountains by that stage.
I had a few days skiing there at Crystal Mountain in January this year smile

Mini-Road trip from SF to Lake Tahoe this weekend - the Cadillac Escalade awaits smile

ViperDave

5,775 posts

284 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
You'd hope standing on the wrong side of the boarder would indicate you had left, but I doubt the CBP officer would see the funny side

ViperDave

5,775 posts

284 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
ViperDave said:
..and Mt Rainer if your not bored of volcano mountains by that stage.
I had a few days skiing there at Crystal Mountain in January this year smile

Mini-Road trip from SF to Lake Tahoe this weekend - the Cadillac Escalade awaits smile
Do they have any snow up at Tahoe yet? had to nix our trip there in jan, ended up driving around UT, WY and CO looking for fresh stuff.

tvrolet

4,771 posts

313 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
ViperDave said:
Do they have any snow up at Tahoe yet? had to nix our trip there in jan, ended up driving around UT, WY and CO looking for fresh stuff.
Certainly not as great as I've seen it at this time of year http://www.skiheavenly.com/video-and-interactive/w... but there's snow. It's an annual jaunt around this time and we've usually struck it lucky with there being a decent dump mid-March but not this year. Quite a few times it been 4WD/chains only through the mountains even in April but no new snow for a wee while now, so I gather its spring conditions. I should just stay at home as Scotland's getting another dump this weekend - but we're forecasting gales and Heavenly's forecasting sun so I'll be happy with the latter! Got some really good freshies at Morzine in Feb so I can't complain.

ViperDave

5,775 posts

284 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Salt lakes only a days drive away, Visit Bonneville on the way too.

ViperDave

5,775 posts

284 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Anyway back on topic, yeah the east border crossings were much the same as Vancouver. CA>US @ Niagara, sent to park up pay the $6, CA>CA having turned around before the bridge after missing the last exit, Waved through but still had to pay the bridge toll. Interestingly, Detroit to Windsor was out of the car on the Canadian side, we were ok but our American hosts were a bit caught out having never been sent to secondary before and not having the correct ID, The Americans at the tunnel on the way back just grumbled a bit but as we had our I94 green card let us back in without drama, this was pre 9/11 though.

Burrow01

1,989 posts

223 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
tvrolet said:
Burrow01 said:
Only issue I had doing this when going across the border from Canada and back again was to make sure that we gave the notification of leaving the country (US) on our last exit from the US - cannot remember if we had to give them back part of the visa or something, but we definitely had to make sure the exit was recorded.

Other than that it was not a problem
Was that maybe the old green I94 form counterfoil pre ESTA? With ESTAs there's nothing to 'hand back'. I've also had instances on the old I94s where the airline didn't take the counterfoil so there was no leaving record and I called the US embassy to see what to do. They just said on the next trip take proof of departure such as the air ticket, plus some evidence that you had been out of the country such as bank statements with UK purchases, payslips and utility bills. I was fully armed with evidence on the next trip but immigration didn't even mention that there wasn't a record of the last departure.
This was in 2012, but was definitely a green form with a counterfoil

5potTurbo

13,697 posts

199 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
hoegaardenruls said:
PhillT said:
Also, if we leave the US at the Detroit land crossing and re-enter a week letter in Niagara, will we need extra paperwork or anything like that?

Thanks in advance.
Have done this a couple of times without an eyelid batted, last time into Canada at Niagara and back into the US at Sarnia, Michigan.

Your passport will have been stamped at the port of entry into the US, with a date showing admitted until ddmmyy. This with your onward flight details will be enough. I think the only question I had concerned where the car was rented from..
I've driven from Chicago-Sarnia-Toronto-Niagara-NY and the border officials didn't really care. The only aspect that would concern me is renting a car in the US and leaving it in Canada. That 1 way fee could be huge. If you can, leave the car in Michigan, cross the border by taxi, rent in Sarnia.... actually, you could end up with 2 x 1 way rental fees there? confused
Check out the costs first. The border's less of a problem.

(I was fortunate that my brother's in the auto industry in the US, so rents loads of cars for customers, and the rental firm waived the 1 way fee for me to leave it in NYC)

PhillT

Original Poster:

2,489 posts

256 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry for the delayed reply - thanks all, much appreciated. Sounds like it should all be fine, we'll just make sure we have any possibly paperwork they could ask for.