Air marshalls - Myth or reality
Air marshalls - Myth or reality
Author
Discussion

Thankyou4calling

Original Poster:

10,838 posts

194 months

Wednesday 27th November 2024
quotequote all
There was a lot of talk of these after 9-11.

Undercover peeps who'd be armed on flights ready to shoot anyone that seemed dangerous.

Did it ever happen? Are there such people?


CLK-GTR

1,655 posts

266 months

Wednesday 27th November 2024
quotequote all
Yes and they still exist in many countries

Harder to spot the Americans but I've had numerous Middle Eastern flights where they're very obvious.

Sciurus

751 posts

166 months

Wednesday 27th November 2024
quotequote all
They do exist. As for their usefulness, it's been reported that per arrest, it's cost in the region of USD $200 Million so make of that what you will.

https://jobs.tsa.gov/law-enforcement

El Al have Israeli sky marshalls on every international flight and they don't mess about so they are very effective as a deterrent (plus all of the passenger screening that they do).

gl20

1,192 posts

170 months

Wednesday 27th November 2024
quotequote all
Was sat next to one on a NorthWest flight from LHR to US back in ‘08. Only aware of it because the air stewardess reminded him to remove his badge.

soxboy

7,200 posts

240 months

Thursday 28th November 2024
quotequote all
A friend of a friend’s ex-husband (tenuous I know) was reported to have been one - whether it was true or not I’m not sure. I do know he was a firearms officer in the Met, this was about 20 years ago.

LRDefender

375 posts

29 months

Thursday 28th November 2024
quotequote all
They were very much a real thing and still are.

Alex Z

1,936 posts

97 months

Thursday 28th November 2024
quotequote all
Sciurus said:
They do exist. As for their usefulness, it's been reported that per arrest, it's cost in the region of USD $200 Million so make of that what you will.

https://jobs.tsa.gov/law-enforcement

El Al have Israeli sky marshalls on every international flight and they don't mess about so they are very effective as a deterrent (plus all of the passenger screening that they do).
And it’s the deterrent that’s the real (potential at least) value for money

gotoPzero

19,652 posts

210 months

Thursday 28th November 2024
quotequote all
In the US still quite common. As said above some ME airlines have their own "John Cutter".
The US guys have a very, very tough pistol qualification course.

The other thing a lot of people don't know is that a significant number of pilots in the US are carrying firearms too.

They are fully badged, as FFDOs (Federal Flight Deck Officers) and have powers to act as a federal agent. (mostly to get around any gun laws in the airports)

The FFDO course is ran at the same facility as the Air Marshall courses.

FFDO SOPs are kept secret, similar to Air Marshalls but some countries outside the US do permit FFDOs to operate and carry their issued firearm. Whilst the total numbers are kept secret its been said there are 5,000+ active at any one time. So depending where you are flying from you might actually have up to half a dozen or more people carrying firearms on the aircraft.

Huzzah

28,469 posts

204 months

Friday 29th November 2024
quotequote all
gotoPzero said:
In the US still quite common. As said above some ME airlines have their own "John Cutter".
The US guys have a very, very tough pistol qualification course.

The other thing a lot of people don't know is that a significant number of pilots in the US are carrying firearms too.

They are fully badged, as FFDOs (Federal Flight Deck Officers) and have powers to act as a federal agent. (mostly to get around any gun laws in the airports)

The FFDO course is ran at the same facility as the Air Marshall courses.

FFDO SOPs are kept secret, similar to Air Marshalls but some countries outside the US do permit FFDOs to operate and carry their issued firearm. Whilst the total numbers are kept secret its been said there are 5,000+ active at any one time. So depending where you are flying from you might actually have up to half a dozen or more people carrying firearms on the aircraft.
I imagine them all talking into their cuffs, hiding behind pillars and stalking each other for 'suspicious' behaviour. biggrin

Edited by Huzzah on Friday 29th November 11:31

CraigyMc

18,061 posts

257 months

Friday 29th November 2024
quotequote all
Sciurus said:
They do exist. As for their usefulness, it's been reported that per arrest, it's cost in the region of USD $200 Million so make of that what you will.

https://jobs.tsa.gov/law-enforcement

El Al have Israeli sky marshalls on every international flight and they don't mess about so they are very effective as a deterrent (plus all of the passenger screening that they do).
Worth calling out that most Israeli citizens are (or were) in the military due to their national service anyway, so even with incognito sky marshals, the crew are generally all going to have at least experience of firearms, if not be actively carrying them. El Al had a plane taken over in the 1960s, and the Israeli government resolved never to let that happen again. Nothing like it has happened on an El Al plane since.

PH'ers under 30 years old or so may not be aware of the number of aircraft hijackings that happened historically because they more or less ceased when the controls put in place after 9/11 became effective.
They might not know that historically the door to the cockpit had no lock on it, for example. People were invited to see the plane being flown (especially small kids). These lax controls were a factor in loads of hijackings in the 1970s/1980s/1990s. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_hij... ).

A typical hijacking would have a plane's crew told to fly to a different destination than planned, sometimes with the hijackers keeping passengers hostage at the target location until some demand or other was met. Sometimes the hijackers got away with it -- really, it was different times altogether.

One classic in skydiving circles was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D._B._Cooper

Giantt

825 posts

57 months

Friday 29th November 2024
quotequote all
Coming back from Beijing in January,bit of a kerfuffle at the rear of plane,couple of inscrutable looking men in black headed swiftly towards it,separated the miscreants and calm resumed.
Always feel safe on Air China,or indeed transiting Beijing, whatever your opinion of the regime,no way a similar debacle to Manchester would occur