Bloody Religious education as a compulsory subject
Bloody Religious education as a compulsory subject
Author
Discussion

Cpl nobby nobbs

Original Poster:

390 posts

168 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Just been sat with my daughter going through her options for GCSE's. Her school has a really great array of subjects she can pick and she is currently in all the top sets ( certainly did not get that from me wobble ).

Then she handed me the paper with the compulsory subjects

English and Maths goes without saying.
Minimum of two sciences she can do triple.
Physical education

All good makes perfect sense but then there is Religious education! What the actual fk is that a compulsory subject for, she will have to spend 1 or 2 lessons a week learning this st when she could be doing another useful subject.

I have no problem with religion but don't believe any of it my self. I think its a personal choice if you want to follow a religion or not each to their own an all that, so why the fk is this a compulsory subject.

If she wanted to pick it I would have no problem with it but she does not want to so I don't see why she should waste valuable learning time studying what to her is a useless subject.

Sorry just a minor rant, not a religious bashing post.




DanielSan

20,118 posts

198 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Been compulsory for a while, best thing to do is just sit in the lesson and revise/work on other stuff. Test how tolerant someone religious really is hehe

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Cpl nobby nobbs said:
Just been sat with my daughter going through her options for GCSE's. Her school has a really great array of subjects she can pick and she is currently in all the top sets ( certainly did not get that from me wobble ).

Then she handed me the paper with the compulsory subjects

English and Maths goes without saying.
Minimum of two sciences she can do triple.
Physical education

All good makes perfect sense but then there is Religious education! What the actual fk is that a compulsory subject for, she will have to spend 1 or 2 lessons a week learning this st when she could be doing another useful subject.

I have no problem with religion but don't believe any of it my self. I think its a personal choice if you want to follow a religion or not each to their own an all that, so why the fk is this a compulsory subject.

If she wanted to pick it I would have no problem with it but she does not want to so I don't see why she should waste valuable learning time studying what to her is a useless subject.

Sorry just a minor rant, not a religious bashing post.
OP doesn;t understand what is in modern RE syllabuses it;s not 'Religious Instruction' and in most schools hasn;t been for 40 years ( standfast the 'church schools' especially those who kick with the wrong foot)

Pixelpeep7r

9,050 posts

173 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Maybe the point is to give children all the facts so they can make an informed decision rather than just following the parents opinions on the subject?

i'm personally non religious and was not christened so i could 'make up my own mind'

and i did.

However a bit more education on the subject might have helped me understand why others need a rule book and the threat of burning for ever in order to behave.

Actually, my tiny glimpse into that world suggests you can do what you like, as long as you tell someone everything you've done and that you're sorry.


STW2010

5,919 posts

193 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Back when I was at school my Dad wrote a letter to the school requesting that I be excused from RE so that I could work in the library.

The school obliged and I spent 2 hours each week doing homework in the library.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
i would also suspect it's probably the 1/2 sized course as well ( or have 1/2 sized GCSEs been reformed out of the system again)

smn159

16,154 posts

248 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
As has been said it's an education about different religions rather than instruction in a particular one. Likely to be useful in later life to understand what's driving them when colleagues and / or employees spend their free time starving themselves or celebrating some mythical figure having some sense nailed into him.

Hoofy

80,190 posts

313 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Presumably what irks you most is that it's not even a religious school? At the Catholic boys' school, RE was an option. biggrin

I think the way to look at it is that subjects such as history and RE, whilst completely pointless compared to physics and maths, do help to prove to an employer that you can string a sentence or two together if you don't quite get a decent grade for english language and literature.

Cpl nobby nobbs

Original Poster:

390 posts

168 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
mph1977 said:
Cpl nobby nobbs said:
Just been sat with my daughter going through her options for GCSE's. Her school has a really great array of subjects she can pick and she is currently in all the top sets ( certainly did not get that from me wobble ).

Then she handed me the paper with the compulsory subjects

English and Maths goes without saying.
Minimum of two sciences she can do triple.
Physical education

All good makes perfect sense but then there is Religious education! What the actual fk is that a compulsory subject for, she will have to spend 1 or 2 lessons a week learning this st when she could be doing another useful subject.

I have no problem with religion but don't believe any of it my self. I think its a personal choice if you want to follow a religion or not each to their own an all that, so why the fk is this a compulsory subject.

If she wanted to pick it I would have no problem with it but she does not want to so I don't see why she should waste valuable learning time studying what to her is a useless subject.

Sorry just a minor rant, not a religious bashing post.
OP doesn;t understand what is in modern RE syllabuses it;s not 'Religious Instruction' and in most schools hasn;t been for 40 years ( standfast the 'church schools' especially those who kick with the wrong foot)
I think you could well be right but still don't see why it needs to be compulsory.

lufbramatt

5,697 posts

165 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
I'm a pretty strong atheist but I actually found RE pretty interesting at school, it's not just "believe in God or you'll go to hell", lots of stuff about other religions, philosophy, moral issues like abortion, the holocaust etc. glad I paid attention, good material when I get I discussions about religion as an adult :-) One of the best lessons I ever had at school was a q+a session with a Buddhist monk in an RE lesson, really interesting and genuine guy.

Cpl nobby nobbs

Original Poster:

390 posts

168 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Pixelpeep7r said:
Maybe the point is to give children all the facts so they can make an informed decision rather than just following the parents opinions on the subject?
This is a very valid point, although I don't push any anti religious views on her as I'm not anti religious, but I suppose she is likely to be biased by my thinking

Podie

46,650 posts

306 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
It was compulsory when I was a kid too. Something like 30 minutes a week - hardly anything too strenuous.

That aside, we covered the basics of a variety of religions - some of which has actually been useful. Nothing wrong with having an appreciation and understanding of other viewpoints - also saves you from making embarrassing gestures (like a colleague who bought a Muslim guy a bottle of whisky as a thank you).

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
lufbramatt said:
I'm a pretty strong atheist but I actually found RE pretty interesting at school, it's not just "believe in God or you'll go to hell", lots of stuff about other religions, philosophy, moral issues like abortion, the holocaust etc. glad I paid attention, good material when I get I discussions about religion as an adult :-) One of the best lessons I ever had at school was a q+a session with a Buddhist monk in an RE lesson, really interesting and genuine guy.
as above, though without the Q+A with the buddhist guy, quality did improve with the retirement of the dried up old prune who was subject lead when i first started secondary school ...

kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Looking at the state of the world at the moment, one could argue that it's about the most important thing they could learn about so they don't end up making the same screw-ups their parents' generation did. smile

I'll certainly be encouraging my daughter to learn as much as she can about religions so she can (a) make up her own mind what she believes and (b) avoid offending anyone who believes differently through her ignorance.

Edited by kambites on Sunday 1st March 18:37

Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
I disagree with RE as a separate subject - especially as this country is becoming more and more secularised and fewer people seems to be identifying with religion (one fairly recent poll puts the number of people identifying as "no religion" at greater than 50% of the GB population).

Surely it would be better if RE was rolled into history, geography, sociology etc?

ILoveMondeo

9,617 posts

257 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Pixelpeep7r said:
Maybe the point is to give children all the facts so they can make an informed decision rather than just following the parents opinions on the subject?
Indeed, they aren't preaching, it's education about the worlds religions, learning a bit more about them. Can be handy stuff to know so they don't go through life ignorant of other peoples beliefs. Hopefully it fosters understanding and tolerance too.





kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Moonhawk said:
Surely it would be better if RE was rolled into history, geography, sociology etc?
Do schools actually teach anything called "sociology"? If so, I agree it could be part of that but they certainly didn't when I was at school.

Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
kambites said:
Do schools actually teach anything called "sociology"? If so, I agree it could be part of that but they certainly didn't when I was at school.
It was a GCSE subject when I took my options and it seems it is still available. Don't know whether all schools offer it - but mine certainly did.

http://www.aqa.org.uk/subjects/sociology/gcse/spec...

RE could also be taught as part of general studies (if such a thing still exists).

kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Moonhawk said:
RE could also be taught as part of general studies.
True but in order to teach enough to be useful, it would probably tripple the amount of time they had to devote to general studies which would make reclassifying it a bit pointless. smile

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Moonhawk said:
I disagree with RE as a separate subject - especially as this country is becoming more and more secularised and fewer people seems to be identifying with religion (one fairly recent poll puts the number of people identifying as "no religion" at greater than 50% of the GB population).

Surely it would be better if RE was rolled into history, geography, sociology etc?
All of which are optional. Giving the children of radical dheads the option to avoid being taught just how much of a dhead their parents are.