The Clarkson meta thread.
Discussion
We have had pages and pages and pages about the Clarkson suspension. I don't want to go into the whys and wherefores : there is already a thread for that.
What fascinates me is how that thread has progressed.
Man is suspended for allegedly throwing punch at co-worker.
Approx 1/4 (made up statistic) of the posts have abused the Guardian, we have had gripes about the "illegal licence fee tax", some glorious conspiracy theories, the alleged victim called a lefty green on account of his name (no, really), you name it.
What is it about this case that has raised so much bile?
Would it have been different if it was posted on a different sub-forum to NP&E?
What fascinates me is how that thread has progressed.
Man is suspended for allegedly throwing punch at co-worker.
Approx 1/4 (made up statistic) of the posts have abused the Guardian, we have had gripes about the "illegal licence fee tax", some glorious conspiracy theories, the alleged victim called a lefty green on account of his name (no, really), you name it.
What is it about this case that has raised so much bile?
Would it have been different if it was posted on a different sub-forum to NP&E?
jshell said:
The difference is that JC is a polarising character who is seen to publicly thumb his nose at a lot of the PC crap that we endure on a daily basis. To some a dinosaur, to some a last hope of some media freedoms. None of that excuses physical assault.
What he said.Nothing excuses assault or bullying of work colleagues. I don't think any sane person would try to defend that.
But... Many millions of ordinary people, in their spare time, enjoy:
Rude jokes.
Offensive jokes.
Casually racist jokes.
Sexual innuendos and humour.
Jokes about women.
Jokes about disabled people.
Jokes about vegetarians.
Freedom from constant moaning about environmental concerns and melting ice while they drive their weekend cars at 17mpg.
Firing shotguns and rifles.
Hunting and shooting animals for sport.
Discussing how much other cultures or countries annoy them.
Indulging in a bit of loutish drunken 'rugby club' type behaviour.
But despite millions of people enjoying those things, apparently they aren't 'allowed' to have TV programs or media that reflect this, because somebody somewhere, finds it offensive and disagrees with it.
Clarkson is one of the few people, still in mainstream media, on channels like the BBC, that represent those people and the things they enjoy in life.
If Top Gear/Clarkson/similar things get taken away, what will people be left with as mainstream entertainment? Cookery programs? X Factor?
Edited by NinjaPower on Wednesday 11th March 11:32
What cracks me up most in the thread are:
People who describe his personality in depth as though they've been his best and closest mate for years, based on seeing the bloke on TV for a few minutes a week a few weeks of the year. (and often in direct contradiction with all his other 'best mates' on the same thread!)
People who describe his contract, the BBC's contract, his financial affairs, how much money the BBC makes, etc etc as though they're top ranking Top Gear executives with intimate knowledge of the program's financial affairs, the contracts of the stars, the pay, the costs, the earnings and so on.
It's absolutely laughable and precisely why the cringe thread was so good. At least it held a mirror up to these people. Sadly the mirror got held up to the wrong person and he ran off to complain to the teachers.
So now we get this kind of utter nonsense all over PH completely unchecked.
RIP cringe thread.
People who describe his personality in depth as though they've been his best and closest mate for years, based on seeing the bloke on TV for a few minutes a week a few weeks of the year. (and often in direct contradiction with all his other 'best mates' on the same thread!)
People who describe his contract, the BBC's contract, his financial affairs, how much money the BBC makes, etc etc as though they're top ranking Top Gear executives with intimate knowledge of the program's financial affairs, the contracts of the stars, the pay, the costs, the earnings and so on.
It's absolutely laughable and precisely why the cringe thread was so good. At least it held a mirror up to these people. Sadly the mirror got held up to the wrong person and he ran off to complain to the teachers.
So now we get this kind of utter nonsense all over PH completely unchecked.
RIP cringe thread.
NinjaPower said:
jshell said:
The difference is that JC is a polarising character who is seen to publicly thumb his nose at a lot of the PC crap that we endure on a daily basis. To some a dinosaur, to some a last hope of some media freedoms. None of that excuses physical assault.
What he said.Nothing excuses assault or bullying of work colleagues. I don't think any sane person would try to defend that.
But... Many millions of ordinary people, in their spare time, enjoy:
Rude jokes.
Offensive jokes.
Casually racist jokes.
Sexual innuendos and humour.
Jokes about women.
Jokes about disabled people.
Jokes about vegetarians.
Freedom from constant moaning about environmental concerns and melting ice while they drive their weekend cars at 17mpg.
Firing shotguns and rifles.
Hunting and shooting animals for sport.
Discussing how much other cultures or countries annoy them.
Indulging in a bit of loutish drunken 'rugby club' type behaviour.
But despite millions of people enjoying those things, apparently they aren't 'allowed' to have TV programs or media that reflect this, because somebody somewhere, finds it offensive and disagrees with it.
Clarkson is one of the few people, still in mainstream media, on channels like the BBC, that represent those people and the things they enjoy in life.
If Top Gear/Clarkson/similar things get taken away, what will people be left with as mainstream entertainment? Cookery programs? X Factor?
Edited by NinjaPower on Wednesday 11th March 11:32
Ari said:
<snip>
It's absolutely laughable and precisely why the cringe thread was so good. At least it held a mirror up to these people. Sadly the mirror got held up to the wrong person and he ran off to complain to the teachers.
So now we get this kind of utter nonsense all over PH completely unchecked.
RIP cringe thread.
Like you, I mourn the demise of the cringe thread, but to be fair it was not the NP&E crowd who went crying to teacher, IIRC.It's absolutely laughable and precisely why the cringe thread was so good. At least it held a mirror up to these people. Sadly the mirror got held up to the wrong person and he ran off to complain to the teachers.
So now we get this kind of utter nonsense all over PH completely unchecked.
RIP cringe thread.
Buff Mchugelarge said:
NinjaPower said:
jshell said:
The difference is that JC is a polarising character who is seen to publicly thumb his nose at a lot of the PC crap that we endure on a daily basis. To some a dinosaur, to some a last hope of some media freedoms. None of that excuses physical assault.
What he said.Nothing excuses assault or bullying of work colleagues. I don't think any sane person would try to defend that.
But... Many millions of ordinary people, in their spare time, enjoy:
Rude jokes.
Offensive jokes.
Casually racist jokes.
Sexual innuendos and humour.
Jokes about women.
Jokes about disabled people.
Jokes about vegetarians.
Freedom from constant moaning about environmental concerns and melting ice while they drive their weekend cars at 17mpg.
Firing shotguns and rifles.
Hunting and shooting animals for sport.
Discussing how much other cultures or countries annoy them.
Indulging in a bit of loutish drunken 'rugby club' type behaviour.
But despite millions of people enjoying those things, apparently they aren't 'allowed' to have TV programs or media that reflect this, because somebody somewhere, finds it offensive and disagrees with it.
Clarkson is one of the few people, still in mainstream media, on channels like the BBC, that represent those people and the things they enjoy in life.
If Top Gear/Clarkson/similar things get taken away, what will people be left with as mainstream entertainment? Cookery programs? X Factor?
Edited by NinjaPower on Wednesday 11th March 11:32
I think everyone assumes that JC just speaks his mind as he sees it and people get offended.
To be honest he changes his opinion so much depending on who or what he is writing for, I don't think anyone can honestly say what Clarkson's 'mind' is.
As such - on the face of it - it appears that it isn't that people are offended by who he is/what he thinks. It is that he actively goes out of his way to offend - because it is his bread and butter, his 'brand'.
Whilst there have been occasions where people have sought him out (see the racist nursery rhyme that was never broadcast - someone must have been actively finding dirt). But other times he has brought it on himself - and done it deliberately knowing it would create a media s
t storm. There is no way it could be otherwise. Obviously even falls into the claiming to know what he thinks cringeyness that Ari mentions - but its just my take. I am staying away from the other threads because it devolves into mindless political tubthumping and name calling.
Buff Mchugelarge said:
NinjaPower said:
jshell said:
The difference is that JC is a polarising character who is seen to publicly thumb his nose at a lot of the PC crap that we endure on a daily basis. To some a dinosaur, to some a last hope of some media freedoms. None of that excuses physical assault.
What he said.Nothing excuses assault or bullying of work colleagues. I don't think any sane person would try to defend that.
But... Many millions of ordinary people, in their spare time, enjoy:
Rude jokes.
Offensive jokes.
Casually racist jokes.
Sexual innuendos and humour.
Jokes about women.
Jokes about disabled people.
Jokes about vegetarians.
Freedom from constant moaning about environmental concerns and melting ice while they drive their weekend cars at 17mpg.
Firing shotguns and rifles.
Hunting and shooting animals for sport.
Discussing how much other cultures or countries annoy them.
Indulging in a bit of loutish drunken 'rugby club' type behaviour.
But despite millions of people enjoying those things, apparently they aren't 'allowed' to have TV programs or media that reflect this, because somebody somewhere, finds it offensive and disagrees with it.
Clarkson is one of the few people, still in mainstream media, on channels like the BBC, that represent those people and the things they enjoy in life.
If Top Gear/Clarkson/similar things get taken away, what will people be left with as mainstream entertainment? Cookery programs? X Factor?
Edited by NinjaPower on Wednesday 11th March 11:32
Buff Mchugelarge said:
NinjaPower said:
jshell said:
The difference is that JC is a polarising character who is seen to publicly thumb his nose at a lot of the PC crap that we endure on a daily basis. To some a dinosaur, to some a last hope of some media freedoms. None of that excuses physical assault.
What he said.Nothing excuses assault or bullying of work colleagues. I don't think any sane person would try to defend that.
But... Many millions of ordinary people, in their spare time, enjoy:
Rude jokes.
Offensive jokes.
Casually racist jokes.
Sexual innuendos and humour.
Jokes about women.
Jokes about disabled people.
Jokes about vegetarians.
Freedom from constant moaning about environmental concerns and melting ice while they drive their weekend cars at 17mpg.
Firing shotguns and rifles.
Hunting and shooting animals for sport.
Discussing how much other cultures or countries annoy them.
Indulging in a bit of loutish drunken 'rugby club' type behaviour.
But despite millions of people enjoying those things, apparently they aren't 'allowed' to have TV programs or media that reflect this, because somebody somewhere, finds it offensive and disagrees with it.
Clarkson is one of the few people, still in mainstream media, on channels like the BBC, that represent those people and the things they enjoy in life.
If Top Gear/Clarkson/similar things get taken away, what will people be left with as mainstream entertainment? Cookery programs? X Factor?
Edited by NinjaPower on Wednesday 11th March 11:32
Google [bot] said:
Coming up today: what made Jeremy Clarkson punch a defenseless Down syndrome child and his elderly wheel-chair bound mother in the face? Denise Robertson will be here to speculate.
I know someone who accidentally teabagged a downs syndrome lad whilst spotting him on the bench press!Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



The cringe thread would have gone into meltdown being filled with quite a few of the posts in the various TG / Clarkson threads in the past 24 hours 
