How random is random?
Discussion
And I don't mean in the sense of "I've got a system for the lottery / roulette, will I be banned from the casino?"
It seems to me (and I fully appreciate the human propensity for finding patterns in stuff) that the "shuffle" on my phone's music player (and ones I've previously owned) isn't that random. I have a lot of music on my phone of all flavours and I usually listen to it in "shuffle all" mode.
Most days I find that the music will conform to a certain type and a large proportion of the tracks are of a similar style. So some days I'll start it and it'll be a bit meh so I skip and that's meh and again so I just stop, restart, "shuffle all songs" and away to go....
I remember reading that MP3 players / iPods once were truly random and people couldn't get used to the fact that truly random means what it says rather than just a crazy mix of stuff.
Am I contradicting myself?

It seems to me (and I fully appreciate the human propensity for finding patterns in stuff) that the "shuffle" on my phone's music player (and ones I've previously owned) isn't that random. I have a lot of music on my phone of all flavours and I usually listen to it in "shuffle all" mode.
Most days I find that the music will conform to a certain type and a large proportion of the tracks are of a similar style. So some days I'll start it and it'll be a bit meh so I skip and that's meh and again so I just stop, restart, "shuffle all songs" and away to go....
I remember reading that MP3 players / iPods once were truly random and people couldn't get used to the fact that truly random means what it says rather than just a crazy mix of stuff.
Am I contradicting myself?

Tallow said:
Thank you. 
Read this earlier: Chance: Is anything in the universe truly random?
My iPod played the same song twice in a row yesterday. Which should happen now and again if it is truly random.
Do they play songs that are on similar parts/the same disc to reduce the loading times between songs?
I think iTunes has a setting for 'Smart shuffle', so that it tends not to play songs by the same artist in a row.
Do they play songs that are on similar parts/the same disc to reduce the loading times between songs?
I think iTunes has a setting for 'Smart shuffle', so that it tends not to play songs by the same artist in a row.
There was program on TV a few years ago about ERNIE. They were concerned that it was not random enough and went into some detail as to how it generated numbers. It was quite interesting. No flipping of coins or rolling of die, think my brain was fried by the end of the program. Seem to remember there was still an issue that it could not truly be called random, pseudo and real??
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


