What motivates some posters on PH?
What motivates some posters on PH?
Author
Discussion

spitsfire

Original Poster:

1,061 posts

166 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
I've enjoyed being on PH. There are a lot of true petrol-heads on here, and plenty of genuine experts. Before the flaming starts, I'm not posting this to complain, try to change the collective behaviour, or encourage folk to self-flagrate. I'm simply bemused by some of the postings I see on here, and find it more than a little depressing.

I'll often click on a thread with an interesting title and find an OP posting about something they've witnessed or experienced. There will then be a couple of posts engaging with the substantive points raised by the OP, before somebody (often with a very high post count) pops up and does one of the following:

  • Vigorously asserts the OP is lying/missing something out before demanding to see 'evidence', and asserts that absence of evidence to their satisfaction means the OP isn't telling the truth
  • Finds fault with the level of detail, spelling, grammar, description, or anything else and starts a personal attack on the OP, opening the door for other posters to follow.
  • Constructively mis-interprets what has been written and takes umbrage at a meaning that wasn't originally there.
  • Adopts a contrarian position, purely to be a contrarian.
There will then be a trip down a futile and irrelevant dead-end alley involving name calling, custard, bizarre comparisons and other stty behaviour. The longer this lasts, the more posters commit to their position, and the less relevant the thread is to the original issue.

Even when an expert (such as agtlaw, breadvan, or any of the car dealers/mechanics) posts, a plethora of idiots pop up claiming to know better than the expert, despite having sfa education, training, or professional experience in the subject matter.

I became particularly conscious of this after posting on a thread about a motorist who deliberately ran over a pedestrian. I struggle to get my head around the idea that fellow PHers can dispute that deliberately running over a pedestrian is pretty much inexcusable. My posts in that thread have been quoted/referenced at least 6 times in a thread that runs to 10 pages. It was clear from some responses that posters making very confident statements about what is legal/illegal didn't understand that Scotland and England have different legal systems. banghead

Around the same time I started a thread about an old SAAB 900 Turbo I'd bought. I thought this would have been a very PH car, and hoped to get some decent engagement and banter from fellow motoring enthusiasts. A total of 3 others posted on the thread. Most other car threads get a similarly listless response.

We seem to be evolving into mumsnet, but with a higher cock content.

Is PH primarily for people who like cars, or for people who like getting angry and feeling offended?

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
To be honest that pretty much describes most forums on the internet, I try and use PH for amusement now rather than serious debate or providing assistance (occasionally I'll slip up and give help)

Try not to worry about it otherwise you'll get caught up in the madness.

Tickle

6,544 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
I would say this behavior is more apparent in the General Gassing section

catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
I have also noticed this trend, and it's changing Pistonheads for the worse. I hope that we can get back to the way it was before.

Tim

StottyEvo

6,860 posts

194 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
I'm bewildered by some of the responses I see to decent OPs.

The people who spoil for arguments too confused. Right now on the 6 series thread someone is trying their damnedest to argue with me laugh

spitsfire

Original Poster:

1,061 posts

166 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
StottyEvo said:
I'm bewildered by some of the responses I see to decent OPs.

The people who spoil for arguments too confused. Right now on the 6 series thread someone is trying their damnedest to argue with me laugh
I did notice that one. What is the point?

I'm also conscious that this thread now has 5 posts, so I'm presumably about to get flamed or suffocated by aggressive contrarianism.

whistle

jimi

521 posts

294 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
high post count - nothing better to do maybe??

djdest

6,542 posts

209 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
The spelling and grammar thing is really annoying to say the least.
Yes, some people struggle with it or make mistakes, so what?
Are you all frustrated wannabe english teachers or something?
Its boring and tedious at best, take it elsewhere FFS.

On a lighter note, I often notice the spelling comments usually get wheeled out when someone has lost an argument and they need another angle of attack, a bit like name calling laugh

Dog Star

17,650 posts

199 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
spitsfire said:
  • Vigorously asserts the OP is lying/missing something out before demanding to see 'evidence', and asserts that absence of evidence to their satisfaction means the OP isn't telling the truth
Ooh there's one person in here that is the perfect description of rofl. I deliberately try to avoid certain subjects or threads just because I can't be arsed being addressed in a condescending manner or called a liar.

But yes, OP, your post is correct. It's just the internet.

Chris1255

203 posts

142 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
Seems to be a rule of the internet that the further away from the original post the less interesting/relevant the replies get. I often end up just skimming past the stupid arguments in the hope of threads getting back on topic.

Vacumatic

188 posts

144 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
StottyEvo said:
I'm bewildered by some of the responses I see to decent OPs.

The people who spoil for arguments too confused. Right now on the 6 series thread someone is trying their damnedest to argue with me laugh
Agreed. PH does seem to have more than its fair share of people who are aggressive and confrontational, people who go out of their way to judge you and be unpleasant. I have no idea what they get out of that other than to make themselves look six inches taller by standing on you.

SturdyHSV

10,443 posts

198 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
If you want help, friendliness or enthusiasm I think you need to look to the marque specific sections, as these tend to end up more like communities and thus people are a little more accountable for their actions.

The more populous areas of PH are just the same as most other forums, albeit with even more opinionated sausage than usual. At least it's still a step or two above the cess pit that is youtube comments...hehe




RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
I think it's just an aspect of human nature that comes across when you remove direct face to face contact. Road rage is another example.

It's a shame because it ruins a lot of threads where someone's genuinely asking for advice. I think the most innocent thread I've ever started was asking for spark plug advice for my Dad's 1957 MG - despite the thread's innocuous nature I got a tirade of abuse within about a day!

On the plus side, my heavy posting on PH and numerous experiences dealing with pedants and ill-informed loud mouthed people (who always seem to shout down the people who really know the answers..) is that in everyday life I am now far more able to articulate things clearly and unambiguously and I can spot argumentative people much more easily and avoid them or calm them down before they start off on a rant. smile

spitsfire

Original Poster:

1,061 posts

166 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
djdest said:
On a lighter note, I often notice the spelling comments usually get wheeled out when someone has lost an argument and they need another angle of attack, a bit like name calling laugh
I do love it when somebody gets pissy about spelling or grammar and posts something along the lines of 'you're spelling and grammar are apalling'...

The Mad Monk

11,578 posts

148 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
spitsfire said:
I'll often click on a thread with an interesting title and find an OP posting about something they've witnessed or experienced. There will then be a couple of posts engaging with the substantive points raised by the OP, before somebody (often with a very high post count) pops up and does one of the following:

  • Vigorously asserts the OP is lying/missing something out before demanding to see 'evidence', and asserts that absence of evidence to their satisfaction means the OP isn't telling the truth
  • Finds fault with the level of detail, spelling, grammar, description, or anything else and starts a personal attack on the OP, opening the door for other posters to follow.
  • Constructively mis-interprets what has been written and takes umbrage at a meaning that wasn't originally there.
  • Adopts a contrarian position, purely to be a contrarian.
There will then be a trip down a futile and irrelevant dead-end alley involving name calling, custard, bizarre comparisons and other stty behaviour. The longer this lasts, the more posters commit to their position, and the less relevant the thread is to the original issue.



Is PH primarily for people who like cars, or for people who like getting angry and feeling offended?
I am a relatively new member.

I enjoy many of the threads.

I don't think I have indulged in any of the activities indicated by the astericks. However, I have criticised or commented on threads where I have genuinely disagreed with a poster.

Where posters have used the word 'scam', if I feel that it isn't a scam within the dictionary definition of the word, I have said so.

I have criticised posters who swear. I think you have lost the argument if you can't express yourself without swearing.

Am I an offender?

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
The Mad Monk said:
Am I an offender?
Not at all, I think debate is good.

spitsfire

Original Poster:

1,061 posts

166 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
The Mad Monk said:
Am I an offender?
Not at all, I think debate is good.
Seconded! I actually like finding people who disagree with me, provided they're reasonable and their argument coherent.

On another note, I've just noticed this thread has moved from GG to The Lounge... anybody know why?

jeremyc

28,404 posts

315 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
spitsfire said:
On another note, I've just noticed this thread has moved from GG to The Lounge... anybody know why?
Because it has nothing to do with cars or motoring. readit

Adenauer

18,982 posts

267 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
The Mad Monk said:
Am I an offender?
Not at all, I think debate is good.
Yes he is.

MrBarry123

6,109 posts

152 months

Thursday 30th April 2015
quotequote all
You do need a few nutters though - keeps it entertaining.