Reading and comprehension
Reading and comprehension
Author
Discussion

ali_kat

Original Poster:

32,157 posts

252 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
is this still taught?

Because I really cannot believe the number of people that read something and then ask the most STUPID of questions, ie ones that are answered in what they have just read!

EG - Hansel takes a slice of bread and leaves a trail of bread crumbs to follow home. However, after they are once again abandoned, the children find that birds have eaten the crumbs and they are lost in the woods. After days of wandering, they discover a large cottage built of gingerbread and cakes with window panes of clear sugar. Hungry and tired, the children begin to eat the rooftop of the candy house, when the door opens. An old woman emerges and lures them inside with the promise of soft beds and delicious food. Unaware that their hostess is a witch who waylays children to cook and eat them, the children enter the house.

Why didn't they go home?

Who is the old woman?

Edited by ali_kat on Wednesday 17th June 13:37

fathomfive

11,259 posts

221 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
How did they get up to the roof?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Is anything still taught?

Going by the teaching abilities when I was at school, which back then meant any teacher under 40 couldn't teach & didn't know their subject. I'd be surprised if any teachers these days could actually do their job.


Anyway, did they get an ASBO for criminal damage?

RizzoTheRat

29,148 posts

223 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
To be fair the teachers despair about what they have to teach sometimes, my Mrs is a maths teacher and regularly complains that hey have to teach kids methods to answer particular types of questions, but give most of them a question they're unfamiliar with and they're completely stumped and unable to break the question down in to the bits that can be solved with the methods they know.

krisdelta

4,673 posts

232 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
I think with the longer posts - people scan for keywords then post an ill considered response.

227bhp

10,203 posts

159 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
ali_kat said:
is this still taught?

Because I really cannot believe the number of people that read something and then ask the most STUPID of questions, ie ones that are answered in what they have just read!

EG - Hansel takes a slice of bread and leaves a trail of bread crumbs to follow home. However, after they are once again abandoned, the children find that birds have eaten the crumbs and they are lost in the woods. After days of wandering, they discover a large cottage built of gingerbread and cakes with window panes of clear sugar. Hungry and tired, the children begin to eat the rooftop of the candy house, when the door opens. An old woman emerges and lures them inside with the promise of soft beds and delicious food. Unaware that their hostess is a witch who waylays children to cook and eat them, the children enter the house.

Why didn't they go home?

Who is the old woman?

Edited by ali_kat on Wednesday 17th June 13:37
We aren't told who she is, we are told what she is, she isn't given a name.

We aren't told why they don't go home, are they being held against their wishes? Have they been eaten? They may be free to go at any time, we aren't told if this is or not.

smile

Timmy40

13,014 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Given the storey is about child abuse and attempted infanticide I think the more is left out the better.

Ali.....are you reading this book to an adult? Or a child? I think daft questions are to be expected if the latter, if it's the former it's just a bit weird.

ali_kat

Original Poster:

32,157 posts

252 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
It was just an example laugh I cannot put the actual details here because it's work & I can't discuss that biggrin

Timmy40

13,014 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
ali_kat said:
It was just an example laugh I cannot put the actual details here because it's work & I can't discuss that biggrin
Ah, I thought maybe you were into some role play or something. Bedtime stories etc. Carry on.

motco

17,669 posts

277 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Well, the bread was mouldy and made the birds hallucinate. One of the birds, in a state of altered consciousness, fell from the sky into Hansel's gaping maw. He swallowed it and got some of the hallucinogen from the bird's gut. He saw this house (in his mind) and convinced his silly sister that it was real. She sussed him, and bashed him over the head with a bit of seaside rock broken off the imaginary house. They didn't go home because their babyminder was from the Rolf Harris school of child care, and the old woman was a figment of their imagination. Clear? If not, wait a moment and the three bears currently asleep in the imaginary house will explain all - if the trolls under the bridge don't get them obviously.

IvanSTi

635 posts

150 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Where did they get water from so they could wander around for days? Who abandoned them in the first place?

This is child cruelty and whoever abandoned them should be prosecuted.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
RizzoTheRat said:
To be fair the teachers despair about what they have to teach sometimes, my Mrs is a maths teacher and regularly complains that hey have to teach kids methods to answer particular types of questions, but give most of them a question they're unfamiliar with and they're completely stumped and unable to break the question down in to the bits that can be solved with the methods they know.
TBH, the second part of your answer would have applied perfectly to the vast majority of teachers I ever had. That's what I mean by no knowledge of the subject they are meant to teach.

Timmy40

13,014 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
IvanSTi said:
Where did they get water from so they could wander around for days? Who abandoned them in the first place?

This is child cruelty and whoever abandoned them should be prosecuted.
Their Father abandoned them, the step mother ( a SWT ) persuaded him too. In the end it all turns out OK as they return home. We are told simply that the SWT has gone, whether social services have caught up with her and she's in prison or whether Dads got a hastily made new patio we aren't told.

Don't get me started on Rapunzel, basically the moral there is it's fine to break into old ladies gardens and steal their vegetables because you're hungry. My question WTF didn't Rapunzels father grow his own vegetables? Eh? And why is the witch wicked? Her father agreed to give him Rapunzel, a deals a deal, he then "forgets" about it.

Edited by Timmy40 on Wednesday 17th June 14:38

Cotty

42,281 posts

315 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Timmy40 said:
Don't get me started on Rapunzel, basically the moral there is it's fine to break into old ladies gardens and steal their vegetables because you're hungry. My question WTF didn't Rapunzels father grow his own vegetables? Eh? And why is the witch wicked? Her father agreed to give him Rapunzel, a deals a deal, he then "forgets" about it.
What about Rumpelstiltskin, kidnap, extortion, blackmail

Impasse

15,099 posts

272 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Planning Permission and Building Control have come a long way since days of yore.

Timmy40

13,014 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Impasse said:
Planning Permission and Building Control have come a long way since days of yore.
yes

True, although oddly enough building houses out of straw is very much in. Less danger of Wolves blowing them down these day I guess.

IvanSTi

635 posts

150 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Timmy40 said:
IvanSTi said:
Where did they get water from so they could wander around for days? Who abandoned them in the first place?

This is child cruelty and whoever abandoned them should be prosecuted.
Their Father abandoned them, the step mother ( a SWT ) persuaded him too. In the end it all turns out OK as they return home. We are told simply that the SWT has gone, whether social services have caught up with her and she's in prison or whether Dads got a hastily made new patio we aren't told.
Don't you start with your casual sexism or there'll be toys everywhere and you'll be hanged by your testes. Fancy coming around here and giving women you've never even met, bad names. You absolute swine.

Hackney

7,442 posts

239 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
ali_kat said:
is this still taught?

Because I really cannot believe the number of people that read something and then ask the most STUPID of questions, ie ones that are answered in what they have just read!

EG - Hansel takes a slice of bread and leaves a trail of bread crumbs to follow home. However, after they are once again abandoned, the children find that birds have eaten the crumbs and they are lost in the woods. After days of wandering, they discover a large cottage built of gingerbread and cakes with window panes of clear sugar. Hungry and tired, the children begin to eat the rooftop of the candy house, when the door opens. An old woman emerges and lures them inside with the promise of soft beds and delicious food. Unaware that their hostess is a witch who waylays children to cook and eat them, the children enter the house.

Why didn't they go home?

Who is the old woman?

Edited by ali_kat on Wednesday 17th June 13:37
The answer to your second question is not in the text. Unless the answer is "she is an old woman is (presumably) the owner / tenant of the cottage"

55palfers

6,396 posts

195 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Hackney said:
ali_kat said:
is this still taught?

Because I really cannot believe the number of people that read something and then ask the most STUPID of questions, ie ones that are answered in what they have just read!

EG - Hansel takes a slice of bread and leaves a trail of bread crumbs to follow home. However, after they are once again abandoned, the children find that birds have eaten the crumbs and they are lost in the woods. After days of wandering, they discover a large cottage built of gingerbread and cakes with window panes of clear sugar. Hungry and tired, the children begin to eat the rooftop of the candy house, when the door opens. An old woman emerges and lures them inside with the promise of soft beds and delicious food. Unaware that their hostess is a witch who waylays children to cook and eat them, the children enter the house.

Why didn't they go home?

Who is the old woman?

Edited by ali_kat on Wednesday 17th June 13:37
The answer to your second question is not in the text. Unless the answer is "she is an old woman is (presumably) the owner / tenant of the cottage"
Yes it is

"Unaware that their hostess is a witch "

Ginetta G15 Girl

3,220 posts

215 months

Thursday 18th June 2015
quotequote all
Given that you Ali, have signally failed to either, read or comprehend, anything I have written recently in threads to which you have responded, I would say that you are (especially in view of this thread) a bloody hypocrite.