Tackling the " Polluter Elite"..report
Tackling the " Polluter Elite"..report
Author
Discussion

RDMcG

Original Poster:

20,849 posts

236 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
https://www.rapidtransition.org/resources/cambridg...

- this is getting a bit of press. I would not be surprised for it to show up as justification for a variety of policies.


Well, I would think the "polluter elite' ,means the majority of people here.


Time to cancel my flights, dump the cars, sell the house, build a solar powered hermetically sealed bothy of some kind ( not large though).

Glad I am 72.

csd19

2,344 posts

146 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Until "the world" manages to make China and the USA stop polluting as much as they do, anything else is just pointless bks. Has the UK not already slashed its CO2 output the most out of the European countries?

As you say it'll be used to introduce more unwanted taxation under the guise of being green, we'll just overlook how the electricity is produced, or the damage done to the environment around the rare earth metal mines extracting raw materials for the batteries.

Just like every other green bullst tax we've had.

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

202 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
It's the first time I've heard a tirade against SUVs in a while.

I like the fact they include EV SUVs, that'll upset some Model X owners.

GliderRider

2,924 posts

110 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Funnily enough, I was thinking about this today, when reading about the proposed Boom XB-1 supersonic airliner/business jet. When we are supposed to be focusing on our carbon footprints, do we really need this? If it were going to be hydrogen powered, fair enough, but pumping more carbon dioxide into the bottom of the ozone layer? Really? Do these guys have their heads in the sand?



The oligarchs constantly searching for bigger and better yachts, what is the carbon footprint of building those things, let alone running them?



Only by having a carbon tax on every manufactured product, to reflect the carbon dioxide generated by its production and transport, will we ever get any change. Those carbon taxes should be going into replanting deserts to make them carbon absorbers they used to be. Some serious First World support in making the Great Green Wall a success, would be a good start.



Edited by GliderRider on Tuesday 13th April 17:42

Uggers

2,224 posts

240 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
RDMcG said:
https://www.rapidtransition.org/resources/cambridg...

- this is getting a bit of press. I would not be surprised for it to show up as justification for a variety of policies.


Well, I would think the "polluter elite' ,means the majority of people here.


Time to cancel my flights, dump the cars, sell the house, build a solar powered hermetically sealed bothy of some kind ( not large though).

Glad I am 72.
I'm 41 and I do worry that the green powers that be would just like us off this planet full stop.

Except them of course, they are green and don't drive massive SUVs or go on holidays or anything like that.
They just stay in their house doing zoom meetings, eating cress and cycling to the local park for days out.

I jest, but I do find it Interesting that one of the most vociferous greenies I know has 5 kids and changes his car every 3 years. I have the one child yet it doesn't stop him bringing up my thirsty 19 year old iceberg melting RS6 anytime he can.



GliderRider

2,924 posts

110 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Uggers said:
I jest, but I do find it Interesting that one of the most vociferous greenies I know has 5 kids and changes his car every 3 years. I have the one child yet it doesn't stop him bringing up my thirsty 19 year old iceberg melting RS6 anytime he can.
Uggers, employ a 'first strike' strategy. Mention the 56.6 tonnes of carbon dioxide/sprog/annum, before he can get his mouth open.

Carbon Footprint of a First World Child

..and his new car at 5.6 tonnes of CO2, or 8.8 tonnes if it is electric.

Carbon footprint - manufacturing a car

trickywoo

14,149 posts

259 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Population control is the best way to tackle this but nobody ever mentions it. I find it really strange.

Uggers

2,224 posts

240 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
GliderRider said:
Uggers, employ a 'first strike' strategy. Mention the 56.6 tonnes of carbon dioxide/sprog/annum, before he can get his mouth open.

Carbon Footprint of a First World Child

..and his new car at 5.6 tonnes of CO2, or 8.8 tonnes if it is electric.

Carbon footprint - manufacturing a car
Thanks I have mentioned it many times the situation he finds himself in.
That when we talk about it we are on a hulking great big drilling ship working together means nothing either!

Jim1064

456 posts

234 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
RDMcG said:
https://www.rapidtransition.org/resources/cambridg...

- this is getting a bit of press. I would not be surprised for it to show up as justification for a variety of policies.


Well, I would think the "polluter elite' ,means the majority of people here.


Time to cancel my flights, dump the cars, sell the house, build a solar powered hermetically sealed bothy of some kind ( not large though).

Glad I am 72.
There's a bit of hype there.

The claim is that half of the growth in emissions from 1990 - 2015 comes from the richest 5%. Total emissions in 2015 were 35 billion tonnes, up from 23 billion in 1990 (https://ourworldindata.org/co2-and-other-greenhouse-gas-emissions).

Half of that growth is 6 billion, so you could say that from the total emissions today, approx 17% is produced by the top 5% percent of the population. That's still skewed but at least it gives a more readily understandable metric, and a much less dramatic headline.

If that claim is true, that is. The report claims Oxfam (!) as source but fails to quote a reference (or at least I can't find it).

Hmmmmm....

Anyway, I've been good the last year - not been on a plane for a year, hasn't happended since 1984 biggrin

RDMcG

Original Poster:

20,849 posts

236 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Jim1064 said:
Anyway, I've been good the last year - not been on a plane for a year, hasn't happended since 1984 biggrin
Yep..I get the Greta Thunberg infrequent flyer pass...last flight Feb 13 2020 and probably drove about 2000 miles.
Normal 100,000 air miles and 50,000 road miles.
Doing my best for the planet.

Megaflow

11,498 posts

254 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
csd19 said:
Until "the world" manages to make China and the USA stop polluting as much as they do, anything else is just pointless bks. Has the UK not already slashed its CO2 output the most out of the European countries?

As you say it'll be used to introduce more unwanted taxation under the guise of being green, we'll just overlook how the electricity is produced, or the damage done to the environment around the rare earth metal mines extracting raw materials for the batteries.

Just like every other green bullst tax we've had.
What he said. A saw a video on YouTube of a steel mill in China, the length of train bringing the coal in beggared belief, it was so big they actually invert whole carriages, while still coupled together, to empty them faster.

Anything the uk does is like trying to fight an overflowing swimming pool by taking from the shallow and and putting it in the deep end.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

215 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
I haven't visited the link, but I bet "polluter elite" could be easily extended to mean "most taxpayers".

MiseryStreak

2,929 posts

236 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Uggers said:
I jest, but I do find it Interesting that one of the most vociferous greenies I know has 5 kids and changes his car every 3 years. I have the one child yet it doesn't stop him bringing up my thirsty 19 year old iceberg melting RS6 anytime he can.
I’ve got nothing against people having as many children as they like, as long as they can care for them properly. But if you have 5 kids you shouldn’t be preaching to anybody about anything remotely to do with sustainability, you should shut the fk up and be incredibly humble.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

262 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Johnnytheboy said:
I haven't visited the link, but I bet "polluter elite" could be easily extended to mean "most taxpayers".
What do you mean "extended"? You didn't think this was going to start with the billionaires did you?

anonymous-user

83 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
trickywoo said:
Population control is the best way to tackle this but nobody ever mentions it. I find it really strange.
Yes but people don't like dying or any move to shorten their lives.

3454.5

424 posts

118 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Isn't this really a topic for NPE? It concerns much of what is debated there.

GliderRider

2,924 posts

110 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Megaflow said:
csd19 said:
Until "the world" manages to make China and the USA stop polluting as much as they do, anything else is just pointless bks. Has the UK not already slashed its CO2 output the most out of the European countries?

As you say it'll be used to introduce more unwanted taxation under the guise of being green, we'll just overlook how the electricity is produced, or the damage done to the environment around the rare earth metal mines extracting raw materials for the batteries.

Just like every other green bullst tax we've had.
What he said. A saw a video on YouTube of a steel mill in China, the length of train bringing the coal in beggared belief, it was so big they actually invert whole carriages, while still coupled together, to empty them faster.

Anything the uk does is like trying to fight an overflowing swimming pool by taking from the shallow and and putting it in the deep end.
Criticizing China for being the worst polluter is a bit like the other rooms in a house blaming the kitchen for being the most energy hungry. Since China produces so much of the world's raw materials and finished goods, its hardly surprising that their energy consumption is high. Its a fair bet that the household energy consumption per head is still a heck of a lot lower than the same in First World countries.

irocfan

48,995 posts

219 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
I'm just waiting for them to introduce swinging tax hikes on anything larger than about 900cc regardless of how often it's driven - all in the name of being 'green' natch.

Watermelons are taking over the world

Wolfmanjack

153 posts

66 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
trickywoo said:
Population control is the best way to tackle this but nobody ever mentions it. I find it really strange.
I’m sure it’s not a fact that’s gone unnoticed,

Especially with Stanley Johnson being a fan of depopulation and BGs dad being a big cheerleader for eugenics

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

202 months

Tuesday 13th April 2021
quotequote all
Johnnytheboy said:
I haven't visited the link, but I bet "polluter elite" could be easily extended to mean "most taxpayers".
It basically includes 90% of the first world.