Crime Conundrum

Author
Discussion

TwigtheWonderkid

Original Poster:

46,207 posts

165 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
So this question was posed to me the other day.

You are suddenly granted a superpower, whereby you can put a stop forever to any crime of your choosing. Name the crime you want to stop, and you can stop it. But......in order to put a stop to it, you have to commit the crime.

So that kind of rules out stuff like genocide, because you'll have to commit it to stop it in the future. It's the kind of lateral thinking question you might get is some executive interview.

There's no right answer as such, if you want to end drink driving, get yourself over the limit, drive 10 yards down the road, park up, hopefully don't get caught, and drink driving is over forever. I was eventually given what I guess is the most sensible answer, which I thought was quite clever. Let's see if anyone comes up with it. Or something better perhaps.

Over to you guys.

Crusoe

4,091 posts

246 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Turn someone's life support off committing murder the turn it back on.

TwigtheWonderkid

Original Poster:

46,207 posts

165 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Crusoe said:
Turn someone's life support off committing murder the turn it back on.
Do you wait for them to die before turning it back on? If not, you haven't committed murder. If so, you have. They might have recovered. Are you comfortable doing that? I wouldn't be.

SteveScooby

825 posts

192 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Perjury? Nobody can ever lie in court again.

greygoose

8,996 posts

210 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Middle Lane Morons on the motorway, I shall free up the roads!

leigh1050

2,413 posts

180 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Starting sentences with "So"

ReallyReallyGood

1,639 posts

145 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Fraud, multi million pound fraud.

ShredderXLE

694 posts

174 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Littering

I'd drop something small and easily biodegradeable.

In my ideal world there would be on the spot roadside executions for people who drop litter but this isnt my thread.

HJG

530 posts

122 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Drugs. Because the knock on effect would be a massive reduction in many other crimes.


TwigtheWonderkid

Original Poster:

46,207 posts

165 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
SteveScooby said:
Perjury? Nobody can ever lie in court again.
That's the one. Commit a minor offence, speeding, refuse the NIP, go to court, lie and say the equipment must be faulty. Lose the case, take the increased fine and the points, and change the world. No one can ever lie in court again. No need for juries, the guilty will admit it and those pleading not guilty must be innocent.

ReallyReallyGood

1,639 posts

145 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
Rather than lie you could just say no comment?

r44flyer

493 posts

231 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
ReallyReallyGood said:
Rather than lie you could just say no comment?
Yeah, we can get rid that nonsense straight away. You answer the questions and if you're guilty we'll know it. You wouldn't even have to prove it.

"Did you do it?"
"Yes."
"Send him down!"

byebye

105.4

4,214 posts

86 months

Sunday 28th January 2024
quotequote all
r44flyer said:
ReallyReallyGood said:
Rather than lie you could just say no comment?
Yeah, we can get rid that nonsense straight away. You answer the questions and if you're guilty we'll know it. You wouldn't even have to prove it.

"Did you do it?"
"Yes."
"Send him down!"

byebye
nono

The Police don’t pay you to incriminate yourself, just as you don’t pay them to come and do your job for you. An assumption of innocence must be upheld at all times until guilt can be proven beyond reasonable doubt.


To answer the OPs question, I’d become a MP, lie to parliament, lie to the press, lie to my constituents, ignore the will of the people whom I pretend to represent, all while lining my own pockets through greed, vice and corruption, and dangerously meddle in the affairs of other countries in the hope of starting wars, just to appease my wealthy backers, big business, the arms industries and the banks.


Put a stop to all of the above and you really would change the world for the better !

TwigtheWonderkid

Original Poster:

46,207 posts

165 months

Monday 29th January 2024
quotequote all
105.4 said:
nono

The Police don’t pay you to incriminate yourself, just as you don’t pay them to come and do your job for you. An assumption of innocence must be upheld at all times until guilt can be proven beyond reasonable doubt.


To answer the OPs question, I’d become a MP, lie to parliament, lie to the press, lie to my constituents, ignore the will of the people whom I pretend to represent, all while lining my own pockets through greed, vice and corruption, and dangerously meddle in the affairs of other countries in the hope of starting wars, just to appease my wealthy backers, big business, the arms industries and the banks.


Put a stop to all of the above and you really would change the world for the better !
But most of those aren't criminal offences. It's not illegal for an MP to lie to parliament, lie to the press, lie to my constituents, ignore the will of the people whom they pretend to represent, all while lining their own pockets through greed and dangerously meddle in the affairs of other countries in the hope of starting wars, just to appease their wealthy backers, big business, the arms industries and the banks.

So that won't work.

105.4

4,214 posts

86 months

Monday 29th January 2024
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
105.4 said:
nono

The Police don’t pay you to incriminate yourself, just as you don’t pay them to come and do your job for you. An assumption of innocence must be upheld at all times until guilt can be proven beyond reasonable doubt.


To answer the OPs question, I’d become a MP, lie to parliament, lie to the press, lie to my constituents, ignore the will of the people whom I pretend to represent, all while lining my own pockets through greed, vice and corruption, and dangerously meddle in the affairs of other countries in the hope of starting wars, just to appease my wealthy backers, big business, the arms industries and the banks.


Put a stop to all of the above and you really would change the world for the better !
But most of those aren't criminal offences. It's not illegal for an MP to lie to parliament, lie to the press, lie to my constituents, ignore the will of the people whom they pretend to represent, all while lining their own pockets through greed and dangerously meddle in the affairs of other countries in the hope of starting wars, just to appease their wealthy backers, big business, the arms industries and the banks.

So that won't work.
Perhaps my post highlights the fact that was is immoral isn’t always illegal, and what is illegal isn’t always immoral.

QJumper

3,238 posts

41 months

Monday 29th January 2024
quotequote all
105.4 said:
Perhaps my post highlights the fact that was is immoral isn’t always illegal, and what is illegal isn’t always immoral.
And that's the real conundrum.

shirt

24,324 posts

216 months

Monday 29th January 2024
quotequote all
Depends on how specific you’re being.

Theft or mugging for example. If I steal something, is theft in all forms eradicated? If so that removes a massive portion of crimes, the cause of crime, and makes life in general safer for everyone.

jgrewal

948 posts

62 months

Tuesday 30th January 2024
quotequote all
ReallyReallyGood said:
Fraud, multi million pound fraud.
This and I must keep the money because of the kind act I committed to ensure nobody suffers again.

JuanCarlosFandango

8,890 posts

86 months

Wednesday 21st February 2024
quotequote all
What was the sensible answer that you were given OP?

Murder would be a bit like the run run away train problem.

Flashing?

wildoliver

9,158 posts

231 months

Wednesday 21st February 2024
quotequote all
Killing the guy from the go compare advert.

Kill him once. Then no one can ever kill him again.

Am I doing this right?