Repetitive AI and manipulated images - what's the point?
Repetitive AI and manipulated images - what's the point?
Author
Discussion

Pistom

Original Poster:

6,137 posts

179 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
What's the point of the non-stop barrage of manipulated videos and images which are portraying things which seem to follow a similar theme but are ridiculous, with little aim other than to show the capabilities of the software but we all know it can do this so why keep doing them?

Videos of cats at the side of the road in pouring rain with a passing motorist stopping to save them. Dogs jumping on their owner, saving them from some catastrophic event etc.

I guess people must still be watching them so there lies my answer but are people not getting fed up with the repetitiveness? It seems I know the answer to that too.


Defcon5

6,455 posts

211 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
Never seen one of these, as I don’t use apps with a ‘feed’ like FB/insta/tiktok.

I’m convinced it’s all a campaign of subterfuge by the Chinese and Russians designed to rot the brain cells of the western youth to weaken us in the future

p1stonhead

28,144 posts

187 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
Pistom said:
What's the point of the non-stop barrage of manipulated videos and images which are portraying things which seem to follow a similar theme but are ridiculous, with little aim other than to show the capabilities of the software but we all know it can do this so why keep doing them?

Videos of cats at the side of the road in pouring rain with a passing motorist stopping to save them. Dogs jumping on their owner, saving them from some catastrophic event etc.

I guess people must still be watching them so there lies my answer but are people not getting fed up with the repetitiveness? It seems I know the answer to that too.
They’re surrounded by adverts either side. The people advertising don’t care why people are coming across ai slop while also coming across their ads.

Spare tyre

11,912 posts

150 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
Clickbait clicks I guess

Its a matter of time before people start doing stuff maliciously on facebook etc

GAjon

3,969 posts

233 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
Are you telling me the video of the toddler being rescued from the zoo lion enclosure by the family Spaniel isn’t real?

StevieBee

14,616 posts

275 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
There's three explanations.

The first is that gen-Ai gives people the freedom and opportunity to make stuff that they hadn't previously been able to. So they make stuff and post it. Some of it's rubbish, some is clever, some is weird. There's no purpose other than a bit of fun - whether it is or not is down to the viewer to decide. Either way, there is no ulterior motive and this represents the vast majority of this type of content.

The second is to illicit a response that leads to commercial gain by the publisher (clickbait)

And the third, similar to the second, is the platforms that enable the video to be created posting stuff themselves to encourage others to subscribe and do the same.

vixen1700

27,209 posts

290 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
I've said it before on here, pretty soon it'll be hard to know what's real and what's AI generated.

Listening to stuff on Youtube last night and the algorithm chucked this at me into the mix of stuff (real music by humans) I was listening to. Old and obscure album I'd never heard of ? No AI.


Hoofy

79,114 posts

302 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
It takes a few seconds to stop, watch, and then react emotionally or realise it's AI (and react emotionally), many will comment because it elicits emotion, and the algo sees people are watching so shows it to more people, the creator gets ad revenue. It's as simple as that.

Warhavernet

543 posts

7 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
I notice this a lot on true crime you tube videos, they are basically monologues, dependent on the crime being featured real images and photos are difficult to source, so it helps visualise what the narrative is describing.

Davie_GLA

6,802 posts

219 months

Sunday 2nd November
quotequote all
What gets me are the AI texture videos. Glass pickles being spread on toast for example. Admittedly it’s pretty cool and I found myself watching more.

Each of the videos are attractions gems of millions of views on what I assume are monetised platforms. One assumes then that this is almost zero effort to get a fair return? Pretty sure they aren’t millionaires but certainly beer money territory?

Funkmachine7

80 posts

124 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
Davie_GLA said:
What gets me are the AI texture videos. Glass pickles being spread on toast for example. Admittedly it s pretty cool and I found myself watching more.

Each of the videos are attractions gems of millions of views on what I assume are monetised platforms. One assumes then that this is almost zero effort to get a fair return? Pretty sure they aren t millionaires but certainly beer money territory?
AI's not cheap to run once you start in video.
its also by its nature spitting back out what went in, thats why its repetaive.

Davie_GLA

6,802 posts

219 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
Funkmachine7 said:
AI's not cheap to run once you start in video.
its also by its nature spitting back out what went in, thats why its repetaive.
But my point starts? If it costs me say, £100 a month to create 20 videos and those videos each attract 20m views (stratosphere I know) then if they generate as little as £30 per month then I’m in profit by £500 a month (not counting your time).

Reason I ask is that the whole internet is flooded by these faceless vids and it feels like they aren’t part of the modern “stack high, sell cheap, profit”

Otispunkmeyer

13,483 posts

175 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
To be fair, the ones of the Queen doing WWE are pretty good.

Puggit

49,323 posts

268 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
The number of social media users who don't spot AI is terrifying.

gotoPzero

19,523 posts

209 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
I m convinced it s all a campaign of subterfuge by the Chinese and Russians designed to rot the brain cells of the western youth to weaken us in the future
+1

bloomen

8,910 posts

179 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
vixen1700 said:
I've said it before on here, pretty soon it'll be hard to know what's real and what's AI generated.

Listening to stuff on Youtube last night and the algorithm chucked this at me into the mix of stuff (real music by humans) I was listening to. Old and obscure album I'd never heard of ? No AI.
Some of that's impressive indeed.

I find most AI content nightmarish and the double nightmare is that it'll enable the 100% talentless to pump out untold amounts of content.

I don't have any social media feeds, but no doubt it'll seep in from all angles. I may set cutoff date for all media that I'm exposed to and stick to it.

Phunk

2,075 posts

191 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
If you’re seeing lots of them it’s because the algorithm thinks you’re interested in them. Stop watching them and you’ll see far less

ChocolateFrog

34,025 posts

193 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
Puggit said:
The number of social media users who don't spot AI is terrifying.
What's more terrifying is none of us will be able to spot them in a year.

dundarach

5,875 posts

248 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
Trouble is, I quite like r/gentlemsnboners however even this is being spammed by bots pasting the same old names and AI images.

The only hope is printed copies of razzle, as at least you'll get some variation, if only we kept all our printed copies!


bloomen

8,910 posts

179 months

Monday 3rd November
quotequote all
ChocolateFrog said:
What's more terrifying is none of us will be able to spot them in a year.
At least we'll know it's out there and ignore every single thing that isn't in front of our actual eyes.

If I were an (more) evil autocrat/ tech bro I'd invent it and not tell anyone.