Hypnosis; is it real or BS?
Hypnosis; is it real or BS?
Author
Discussion

dpbird90

Original Poster:

5,535 posts

219 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Just been thinking about it after watching Paul McKenna hypnotise Hammond on an old TG on Dave. Conveniently they couldn't show you how he did it, and I for one am not convinced about hypnosis in general.
Over to you guys.

AB

20,453 posts

224 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Been hypnotised.

It does work.

I was told an onion was the juiciest apple I had ever seen - had the taste in my mouth for weeks.

I was also told that when I woke up I would be the only one with clothes on. Everyone else in the pub was naked. Apparently I stared at some girl for ages, but trying to make it not look obvious, at the time I didn't think I was hypnotised and I didnt realise everyone was looking at me.

Gedon

3,097 posts

205 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Mucked around with it at uni with some books I got in a library sale.

It works allright..... Super rapid induction may have had some prior treatment.

Induction takes a while, even if you know what you're doing.

It's a normal feature of humans.

dpbird90

Original Poster:

5,535 posts

219 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Ah right, so how do they do it?

BrabusMog

21,774 posts

215 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
I too watched that Top Gear yesterday. Hammonds face seemed to be holding back laughter so I wasn't convinced. Highly entertaining though.

hondafanatic

4,969 posts

230 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
dpbird90 said:
Ah right, so how do they do it?
Try using google or youtube or wikipedia. There are hundreds of pages on the subject.

lazyitus

19,931 posts

295 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
dpbird90 said:
Conveniently they couldn't show you how he did it
I believe this is due to the fact that TV viewers could become hypnotised through the television.

Can you imagine homes all over the UK with people sat there for weeks on end, monged on the setee because McKenna didn't undo them ?

Gedon

3,097 posts

205 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
lazyitus said:
dpbird90 said:
Conveniently they couldn't show you how he did it
I believe this is due to the fact that TV viewers could become hypnotised through the television.

Can you imagine homes all over the UK with people sat there for weeks on end, monged on the setee because McKenna didn't undo them ?
It is possible to hypnotise people through the TV and they are probably in the right circumstance to be receptive. Relaxed, focused, eyes tired....

There is legislation relating to it.

People laugh as they are scared by it. A decent hypnotist will get anyone under.....they have to be talked into it more. It's more "feeling safe and trusting a confident person".....everyone can do that.

You need an environment where you can get people to relax. Where you can maintain someone's attention. Hence low lights, trancey music, etc.

drivin_me_nuts

17,949 posts

240 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
lazyitus said:
dpbird90 said:
Conveniently they couldn't show you how he did it
I believe this is due to the fact that TV viewers could become hypnotised through the television.

Can you imagine homes all over the UK with people sat there for weeks on end, monged on the setee because McKenna didn't undo them ?
... I must kill Papsmmear G ...

... I must kill Papsmmear Go ...

... I must kill Papsmmear Gor ...

... I must kill Papsmmear Gord ...

... I must kill Papsmmear Gordo ...

... I must kill Papsmmear Gordon ...

... I must kill Papsmmear Gordon B...

TheCarpetCleaner

7,294 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Having studied stage hypnosis and clinical hypnotherapy for several years - here are the points that you are probably looking for in order to make your mind up

- Hypnosis only works if you believe it is going to work. Having a presence like Paul Mckenna helps as he is known to be able to do it, as people see it and believe it. If I were to approach you and say "I can hypnotise you" - it probably wouldn't work.

- If you are one of those people that say "I can never be hypnotised, it doesn't work" - then you are right, it wont. It is more a guided meditation more than anything else (clinical), or the want to be hypnotised in front of others (stage)

- If you go to a stage hypnosis show, they will do what is called a susceptibility test. This is where they ask all the audience members to do a simple task, for example, they tell you to clasp your hands together and say "Your hands are now locked together, and you cannot unclasp them". Some audience members (usually most as they are they because they believe it) will not be able to unclasp their hands, some will. Guess which ones will be picked to go on stage...

- Clinical hypnosis works on the same basis, as you go to a clinical hypnotist wanting to lose weight / give up smoking / to become a carpet cleaner. Therefore you are guided to what you deep down already want, so it has massive effect on some people, limited on others. If you dont really want to achieve the goal, or are not really that committed, it won't work.

- You can NEVER by hypnotised to do what you do not want to do. I could not hypnotise you, regardless of your belief, to hand over all the money in your bank account, and the deeds to your house. Or I could not hypnotise you to murder your parents, unless of course you actually really wanted to. It was experimented with during WWII alongside chemical stimulants but was generally a failure.

So the short answer is, yes it does work. If you believe it, and if you want to be hypnotised. The level in which it works depends on you, your belief in the hypnotist, and the environment that it is carried out in.


Anyway back to carpet cleaning... wink

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

255 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Gedon said:
There is legislation relating to it.
OK, you've piqued my curiosity.

Do tell.

joe_90

4,206 posts

260 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Having studied stage hypnosis and clinical hypnotherapy for several years - here are the points that you are probably looking for in order to make your mind up

- Hypnosis only works if you believe it is going to work. Having a presence like Paul Mckenna helps as he is known to be able to do it, as people see it and believe it. If I were to approach you and say "I can hypnotise you" - it probably wouldn't work.

- If you are one of those people that say "I can never be hypnotised, it doesn't work" - then you are right, it wont. It is more a guided meditation more than anything else (clinical), or the want to be hypnotised in front of others (stage)

- If you go to a stage hypnosis show, they will do what is called a susceptibility test. This is where they ask all the audience members to do a simple task, for example, they tell you to clasp your hands together and say "Your hands are now locked together, and you cannot unclasp them". Some audience members (usually most as they are they because they believe it) will not be able to unclasp their hands, some will. Guess which ones will be picked to go on stage...

- Clinical hypnosis works on the same basis, as you go to a clinical hypnotist wanting to lose weight / give up smoking / to become a carpet cleaner. Therefore you are guided to what you deep down already want, so it has massive effect on some people, limited on others. If you dont really want to achieve the goal, or are not really that committed, it won't work.

- You can NEVER by hypnotised to do what you do not want to do. I could not hypnotise you, regardless of your belief, to hand over all the money in your bank account, and the deeds to your house. Or I could not hypnotise you to murder your parents, unless of course you actually really wanted to. It was experimented with during WWII alongside chemical stimulants but was generally a failure.

So the short answer is, yes it does work. If you believe it, and if you want to be hypnotised. The level in which it works depends on you, your belief in the hypnotist, and the environment that it is carried out in.


Anyway back to carpet cleaning... wink
The key question is..
can you make women give you sexual favours.

911motorsport

7,251 posts

262 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Having studied stage hypnosis and clinical hypnotherapy for several years - here are the points that you are probably looking for in order to make your mind up

- Hypnosis only works if you believe it is going to work. Having a presence like Paul Mckenna helps as he is known to be able to do it, as people see it and believe it. If I were to approach you and say "I can hypnotise you" - it probably wouldn't work.

- If you are one of those people that say "I can never be hypnotised, it doesn't work" - then you are right, it wont. It is more a guided meditation more than anything else (clinical), or the want to be hypnotised in front of others (stage)

- If you go to a stage hypnosis show, they will do what is called a susceptibility test. This is where they ask all the audience members to do a simple task, for example, they tell you to clasp your hands together and say "Your hands are now locked together, and you cannot unclasp them". Some audience members (usually most as they are they because they believe it) will not be able to unclasp their hands, some will. Guess which ones will be picked to go on stage...

- Clinical hypnosis works on the same basis, as you go to a clinical hypnotist wanting to lose weight / give up smoking / to become a carpet cleaner. Therefore you are guided to what you deep down already want, so it has massive effect on some people, limited on others. If you dont really want to achieve the goal, or are not really that committed, it won't work.

- You can NEVER by hypnotised to do what you do not want to do. I could not hypnotise you, regardless of your belief, to hand over all the money in your bank account, and the deeds to your house. Or I could not hypnotise you to murder your parents, unless of course you actually really wanted to. It was experimented with during WWII alongside chemical stimulants but was generally a failure.

So the short answer is, yes it does work. If you believe it, and if you want to be hypnotised. The level in which it works depends on you, your belief in the hypnotist, and the environment that it is carried out in.


Anyway back to carpet cleaning... wink
nerd blimey! I'd never guess all that was going on in the head of someone shampooing my rug.

suthol

3,961 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Gedon said:
You need an environment where you can get people to relax. Where you can maintain someone's attention. Hence low lights, trancey music, etc.
Once in a situation like this on a management course.

The facilitator had us all lie on the floor with the lights dimmed and got us to go tighten and relax specific groups of muscles and the leave that group relaxed and move on.

You know the story, fists & relax, forearms & relax, etc then on through the leg groups, the on to the head and moving down through the body core becoming more and more relaxed.

The last group was the buttocks which clenched up nicely but rejoiced with a truly monumental fart upon being relaxed.

Fair to say it killed the occasion completely biggrin

lazyitus

19,931 posts

295 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
CommanderJameson said:
Gedon said:
There is legislation relating to it.
OK, you've piqued my curiosity.

Do tell.
British TV watchdog Ofcom: said:





Rule 2.9 Hypnosis





Elements of the hypnotist’s routine may be broadcast to set the scene. However, it is important not to broadcast the routine in its entirety, nor to broadcast elements that may cause a member of the audience to believe they are being influenced in some way.






This is because it is perfectly possible to be hypnotised through the TV, or indeed through the radio.





The most important thing to know about hypnosis is that people vary in their hypnotisability and this is the single most important thing that determines whether suggestions will have an effect.
SEE HERE

Edited by lazyitus on Thursday 10th September 12:30

TheCarpetCleaner

7,294 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
911motorsport said:
TheCarpetCleaner said:
stuff
nerd blimey! I'd never guess all that was going on in the head of someone shampooing my rug.
Sometimes we need to use extreme psychological methods to encourage dirt out the carpets yes

rev-erend

21,619 posts

313 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
joe_90 said:
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Having studied stage hypnosis and clinical hypnotherapy for several years - here are the points that you are probably looking for in order to make your mind up

- Hypnosis only works if you believe it is going to work. Having a presence like Paul Mckenna helps as he is known to be able to do it, as people see it and believe it. If I were to approach you and say "I can hypnotise you" - it probably wouldn't work.

- If you are one of those people that say "I can never be hypnotised, it doesn't work" - then you are right, it wont. It is more a guided meditation more than anything else (clinical), or the want to be hypnotised in front of others (stage)

- If you go to a stage hypnosis show, they will do what is called a susceptibility test. This is where they ask all the audience members to do a simple task, for example, they tell you to clasp your hands together and say "Your hands are now locked together, and you cannot unclasp them". Some audience members (usually most as they are they because they believe it) will not be able to unclasp their hands, some will. Guess which ones will be picked to go on stage...

- Clinical hypnosis works on the same basis, as you go to a clinical hypnotist wanting to lose weight / give up smoking / to become a carpet cleaner. Therefore you are guided to what you deep down already want, so it has massive effect on some people, limited on others. If you dont really want to achieve the goal, or are not really that committed, it won't work.

- You can NEVER by hypnotised to do what you do not want to do. I could not hypnotise you, regardless of your belief, to hand over all the money in your bank account, and the deeds to your house. Or I could not hypnotise you to murder your parents, unless of course you actually really wanted to. It was experimented with during WWII alongside chemical stimulants but was generally a failure.

So the short answer is, yes it does work. If you believe it, and if you want to be hypnotised. The level in which it works depends on you, your belief in the hypnotist, and the environment that it is carried out in.


Anyway back to carpet cleaning... wink
The key question is..
can you make women give you sexual favours.
You need alchol or Rohipnol wink

911motorsport

7,251 posts

262 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
TheCarpetCleaner said:
911motorsport said:
TheCarpetCleaner said:
stuff
nerd blimey! I'd never guess all that was going on in the head of someone shampooing my rug.
Sometimes we need to use extreme psychological methods to encourage dirt out the carpets yes
Ah yes; subliminal thinking (known in the trade as underlay)

youngsyr

14,742 posts

221 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
My only experience of it is indirect through my girlfriend, she was petrified of spiders (and I mean petrified literally - when she saw one she froze and couldn't do anything but scream for someone to come and help her).

She went to a course at London Zoo which as far as I can tell was a mixture of cognitive behavioural therapy and hypnosis and was fine with spiders (to the extent of being able to sleep in a room with one on the ceiling) until recently, when her old phobia has started to reappear.

So, from that I conclude that either CBT or hypnosis works and possibly both.

TheCarpetCleaner

7,294 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
youngsyr said:
...when her old phobia has started to reappear.
For something as deep seated as a proper phobia, especially one as severe as the reaction you have described, she would need multiple sessions about 3-4 weeks apart in order for her to subconsciously not be bothered by spiders any more.

The fact it did work proves that she wants to be rid of her phobia, and I would honestly ask her to look around for a trusted recommended hypnotherapist to continue with it.