Medical bill from a French hospital visit!
Medical bill from a French hospital visit!
Author
Discussion

Chilli

Original Poster:

17,320 posts

265 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Sorry mods, no idea where to put this!

I had a brief stay in a French hospital earlier in the year, overnight I think!. Anyways, I've just received what looks like a 170 euro bill. I thought the E111 card (or whatever it is) negated the need to pay such things. I guess I was wrong.
Do I need to pay it? Anyone had similar?
Cheers.

Rach*

8,824 posts

245 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Will they catch you up in NZ? tongue out

Driller

8,310 posts

307 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Chilli said:
Sorry mods, no idea where to put this!

I had a brief stay in a French hospital earlier in the year, overnight I think!. Anyways, I've just received what looks like a 170 euro bill. I thought the E111 card (or whatever it is) negated the need to pay such things. I guess I was wrong.
Do I need to pay it? Anyone had similar?
Cheers.
What do you mean "overnight, I think!"? Did you bang your head? hehe

Apparently an E111 gives you "reduced cost or sometimes free" healthcare, whatever that means. Did you present the card to them at the time?

Bill

58,637 posts

284 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
What's it for? A friend of mine was in for a few days and they charged him bed and board, plus crutches, bandages and medication. I don't know whether he claimed it back from his insurance or the NHS, although I expect claiming off the NHS would be like getting blood from a stonehehe

ETA and they wouldn't give him any painkillers before they had a credit card despite his badly broken legfurious

Edited by Bill on Friday 25th September 19:32

tvrolet

4,748 posts

311 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
When I had some metalwork added in Sallanches (nr Chamonix) the EU cover only paid for the treatment...and only then after months of phone calls! There was other stuff that I had to pay and get back off travel insurance. On the day I was discharged they actually wheeled me to the hospital cashier/accounts office and wouldn't let me out until I'd settled all the 'extras'. IIRC this included ambulance, tranfer to airport, food, meds for jouney home etc.

Mutley

3,178 posts

288 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Driller said:
...Apparently an E111 gives you "reduced cost or sometimes free" healthcare, whatever that means. Did you present the card to them at the time?
Quite right, all the E111 will do is provide the basics, like the NHS will do, any additional bills are still payable. Just forward them onto your travel insurance people, (presuming they're aware) and you'll be covered.

Chilli

Original Poster:

17,320 posts

265 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Cool, cheers!
I'd had a couple of beers, and trying to find my way home decided to climb the fence surrounding the Le mans circuit.... I made it halfway, then gravity took over.
Woke up in a bed, with a drip etc...and a mate picked me up a few hours later.

Rach, I doubt it...but I'd rather not be arrested for it in 10 years time, and have to spend the next month at the mercy of mr big and his wedding proposals!

ctallchris

1,266 posts

208 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
They might not count accommodation as free I think that comes from travel insurance. the healthcare (doctor's time / treatments etc may be free)

Rach*

8,824 posts

245 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Chilli said:
Cool, cheers!
I'd had a couple of beers, and trying to find my way home decided to climb the fence surrounding the Le mans circuit.... I made it halfway, then gravity took over.
Woke up in a bed, with a drip etc...and a mate picked me up a few hours later.

Rach, I doubt it...but I'd rather not be arrested for it in 10 years time, and have to spend the next month at the mercy of mr big and his wedding proposals!
You could send Mr Big my way! hehe

El Guapo

2,787 posts

219 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all

smack

9,773 posts

220 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Once again, you should have listened to Oggs and myself.... Nest time you better!

catso

16,414 posts

296 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Mutley said:
Driller said:
...Apparently an E111 gives you "reduced cost or sometimes free" healthcare, whatever that means. Did you present the card to them at the time?
Quite right, all the E111 will do is provide the basics, like the NHS will do, any additional bills are still payable. Just forward them onto your travel insurance people, (presuming they're aware) and you'll be covered.
My Dad had a fall in Spain earlier this year, broke his hip too badly for 'normal' repair so they did a hip replacement on the next day, spent a couple of weeks in Hospital etc but they didn't charge him anything - although he is a pensioner if this makes any difference?

750turbo

6,164 posts

253 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
I wonder what would happen in the event of Mr or Mrs Foreigner having a similar predicament over here?

Does the NHS have an Accts Clerk to collect oustanding bills at their point of departure I wonder?

scratchchin

Marcellus

7,204 posts

248 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
I think that they will keep "reminding" you until the debt is settled.

The big difference between France and UK is that all the medical practitioners here are private and charge for everything.

If you are a french resident (or hold a carte vitale) you get 60% of the standard fee back.

So a trip to a GP will cost you c€28. the standard fee is €25..... of which you get €15.. so the trip costs you €13.

YOu can buy "Mutual" which tops up the balance as a percentage of the standard fee ranging from 100% to 400%.. so if you buy the basic then this €28 trip would only cost you €3...... if you buy the 400% you could go and see a very expensive GP and get it back!!!

So the people pursuing you for payment aren't actually the French NHS as it doesn't exist it's effectively a private company... the ambulance isn't an ambulance per say it's more of a taxi company.....


HTH

Chilli

Original Poster:

17,320 posts

265 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Cheers for the replies. I just thought that this E111 card meant I didn't have to pay it. However, if I should, I will, it's not an issue.

Cheers.

Simpo Two

92,708 posts

294 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Do French nationals get billed by the NHS for treatment here?

Big Time Charlie

461 posts

221 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Be thankful it wasn't Switzerland. I had an overnight stay and a few scans after a car accident. Bill for just over 12 hours? 5 grand sterling. Lucikly my health insurance picked it up but it took a long time to go through.

horton

804 posts

281 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
obviously don't pay.

they are French, surely that is enough of a reason to get one over on them.

raf_gti

4,253 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
Big Time Charlie said:
Be thankful it wasn't Switzerland. I had an overnight stay and a few scans after a car accident. Bill for just over 12 hours? 5 grand sterling. Lucikly my health insurance picked it up but it took a long time to go through.
What happens if you can't afford the treatment?

And as a more general question for other parts of the world, do doctors have a legal duty of care in that they HAVE tp provide treatment, even if it is very very basic if the patient can't afford anything else?

Adam B

29,715 posts

283 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
Marcellus said:
If you are a french resident (or hold a carte vitale) you get 60% of the standard fee back.

So a trip to a GP will cost you c€28. the standard fee is €25..... of which you get €15.. so the trip costs you €13.
like this idea for UK, and reduce income tax - would stop all the timewasters bothering doctors over a sore throat