Discussion
Ok, first post in the lounge. You lot seem pretty normal
so thought I'd ask a serious question that's been puzzling me recently.
The wife and I have had a joint bank account for as long as I can remember. I'm not a high earner but the ratio is over 10:1 (my salary vs hers). The fact that we have such a large ratio doesn't bother me in the slightest (we have kids so she works PT) and we both have full access to all that we bring into the house.
Anyway I was having a conversation with her the other day (we do this occasionally LOL) and she was explaining how many of her friends receive allowances from their husbands and the rest have his/hers accounts. In some ways I can understand the his/hers thing but what is going on with the allowance thing
Does anyone else do this and what's the rationale ?
Do any women on here get an allowance and how do you feel about it ?
I'm not judging anyone (it's not my place to) but am genuinely interested in why you would want to operate your finances like this.
Many thanks
so thought I'd ask a serious question that's been puzzling me recently.The wife and I have had a joint bank account for as long as I can remember. I'm not a high earner but the ratio is over 10:1 (my salary vs hers). The fact that we have such a large ratio doesn't bother me in the slightest (we have kids so she works PT) and we both have full access to all that we bring into the house.
Anyway I was having a conversation with her the other day (we do this occasionally LOL) and she was explaining how many of her friends receive allowances from their husbands and the rest have his/hers accounts. In some ways I can understand the his/hers thing but what is going on with the allowance thing

Does anyone else do this and what's the rationale ?
Do any women on here get an allowance and how do you feel about it ?
I'm not judging anyone (it's not my place to) but am genuinely interested in why you would want to operate your finances like this.
Many thanks
Edited by Fatman2 on Tuesday 26th October 13:30
I know what would happen with my wife - there would be arguments over what comes out of her allowance and what she spends from the joint account.
I'd also expect that if I gave her, say, £500/mth, then she'd spend £500/mth.
We just pool everything and if she wants/needs something then she buys it. It does irk me that quite a lot of cash get withdrawn and spent but then I've got no idea of how much most things cost.
I'd also expect that if I gave her, say, £500/mth, then she'd spend £500/mth.
We just pool everything and if she wants/needs something then she buys it. It does irk me that quite a lot of cash get withdrawn and spent but then I've got no idea of how much most things cost.
I think that it can be good for both parties in a relationship to have a certain amount of personal money each month, which can be spent completely guilt free on anything you want without having to justify it (whether that is excessively expensive handbags and shoes or coke and hookers).
I do think it should be done equally though, the idea of one person having an allowance and the other being able to spend as much as they want just seems odd to me.
I do think it should be done equally though, the idea of one person having an allowance and the other being able to spend as much as they want just seems odd to me.
Mr Will said:
I think that it can be good for both parties in a relationship to have a certain amount of personal money each month, which can be spent completely guilt free on anything you want without having to justify it (whether that is excessively expensive handbags and shoes or coke and hookers).
I do think it should be done equally though, the idea of one person having an allowance and the other being able to spend as much as they want just seems odd to me.
+1 - We do that and works really well I do think it should be done equally though, the idea of one person having an allowance and the other being able to spend as much as they want just seems odd to me.
From what I've seen (1 couple!) its a control thing. He gets to dictate what is and isn't spent, and he keeps his assumed position as 'head of house' intact.
When we meet up, the topic can crop up and I get the feeling she feels genuinely de-meaned by it always making a point of the fact she works too and does majority of child care yet has the least to spend...
He'll then go on to say that they've never argued...ever... but they're still together so something must work...
I on the other hand, I shared everything with my wife (joint account) who thanks to disability had only benefits as an income... she didn't share and it turned out she kept the details of how much from me....we divorced 2 years after I found out (after 14 years marriage and a myriad of other reasons
)
When we meet up, the topic can crop up and I get the feeling she feels genuinely de-meaned by it always making a point of the fact she works too and does majority of child care yet has the least to spend...
He'll then go on to say that they've never argued...ever... but they're still together so something must work...
I on the other hand, I shared everything with my wife (joint account) who thanks to disability had only benefits as an income... she didn't share and it turned out she kept the details of how much from me....we divorced 2 years after I found out (after 14 years marriage and a myriad of other reasons
)We have our salaries paid into our own accounts, then a ratioed amount is paid by each of us into the joint account for rent/bills etc
Then the rest of our money is our to do what we want with, we split things like tickets for gigs and paying for holidays but it always comes out of our own money, just seems to work tbh
Then the rest of our money is our to do what we want with, we split things like tickets for gigs and paying for holidays but it always comes out of our own money, just seems to work tbh
I earn a fair whack more than the OH and we've got an individual account each and then the joint account for household bills.
As a result, I pay the rent and council tax, while she pays the electric, water and shopping.
Money left over is then our own to be put into savings, pay personal bills (cards/phones) and fuel or generally to piss up against the wall.
It seems to work and allows both parties a sense trust and freedom.
As a result, I pay the rent and council tax, while she pays the electric, water and shopping.
Money left over is then our own to be put into savings, pay personal bills (cards/phones) and fuel or generally to piss up against the wall.
It seems to work and allows both parties a sense trust and freedom.
Mr Will said:
I think that it can be good for both parties in a relationship to have a certain amount of personal money each month, which can be spent completely guilt free on anything you want without having to justify it (whether that is excessively expensive handbags and shoes or coke and hookers).
I do think it should be done equally though, the idea of one person having an allowance and the other being able to spend as much as they want just seems odd to me.
Although not in the situation of sharing money with another half, this is what I thought I would do when it happens. Have a joint account (so people are less likely to be lying etc, and so you know the amount you have between you for holidays etc) but also have a set amount going to both of you to pay for personal interests so there's no arguing over "shared" money.I do think it should be done equally though, the idea of one person having an allowance and the other being able to spend as much as they want just seems odd to me.
Salary parity here, plus joint account and no rules. We just talk to each other if we have out of the ordinary expenditure coming up.
However, I haven't told her about the bike-related kit I've just ordered off the interweb, nor the pair of trousers I have just ordered. Hope they're delivered before she gets back from visiting her parents at the end of the week.
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


