Make a request for information on FOI
Make a request for information on FOI
Author
Discussion

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,426 posts

292 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all

All,

Short story

I'd like my son to go to school by bus, we have been turned down for a place, we have appealed and lost.

I can appeal further but only if I have additional information pertinent to the case. Essentially this is that other families iin the village - some in fact further from the school than us, have a bus place.

Our appeal failed because there is another school closer to us than the one we choose. If that is true for us then it must be true for others too.

Therefore I want to make a FOI request for disclosure of who has been awarded a place on the bus and lives further away than us. Any (helpful) suggestions?

Thanks


Stevenj214

4,941 posts

259 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
Scratch my original question.

Are you appealing to get into the school or onto the bus only?

Edited by Stevenj214 on Thursday 28th October 16:32

Bill

58,919 posts

286 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
You also need to know whether they chose the more distant school or whether the were forced due to numbers etc. IYSWIM

killsta

1,845 posts

259 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
I think this request may be declined unless you word it 'appropriately'..

944fan

4,962 posts

216 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
Who controls who gets the places? You need to identify the body responsible. I assume the local council.

Then write a letter addressed to the chief executive, the security will no doubt open it and it will get passed to the relevant bod to deal with. You have to state what info you want, you don't have to mention the FOI act but it wouldn't hurt. It helps to be fairly descriptive of what you want, you don't need to explain why you want it. Then just give your contact details.

Given that you are asking for the names of children (or the familes) who use a particlular bus service I suspect you might be told to bcensoredr off.

They have to reply within a month with either the info or the reasons as to why you can't have it.

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
That was great, back when we were kids and the summers were piping hot and lasted all year long...... hehe


911motorsport

7,251 posts

264 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
I would want to know that data too, as it sounds like you are being victimised.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,426 posts

292 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
This is Junior school so he is only 7 years old - bit soon for that


Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,426 posts

292 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
Stevenj214 said:
Scratch my original question.

Are you appealing to get into the school or onto the bus only?

Edited by Stevenj214 on Thursday 28th October 16:32
No he is in the school, so the bus stops in the village, but he isn't allowed on it as we have a closer school. Which must be true for most of the village

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
I'd ask for the policy documents to start with. You need to know what exceptions may apply.

They wont give you anything that identifies another child so ask for details of the distances from the children's homes to the schools. Both the nearest school and the attended school.

I'd also talk to your county councillor. If that fails then the local newspaper.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,426 posts

292 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
TooLateForAName said:
I'd ask for the policy documents to start with. You need to know what exceptions may apply.

They wont give you anything that identifies another child so ask for details of the distances from the children's homes to the schools. Both the nearest school and the attended school.

I'd also talk to your county councillor. If that fails then the local newspaper.
Not sure I'd want it in the papers, however I have written to my MP for advice


Bill

58,919 posts

286 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
So they're his school mates getting on the bus? Why not ask them, or their parents how they wangled it?

I suspect it's the choosing a school that's further away that's scuppered your chances.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,426 posts

292 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
Bill said:
So they're his school mates getting on the bus? Why not ask them, or their parents how they wangled it?

I suspect it's the choosing a school that's further away that's scuppered your chances.
whats the point of parental choice if the transport that already comes to the village is then not available. We are talking about a matter of a few hundred yards.

If I understood it I wouldn't need to ask. The bus stops 200 yards from my house, other parents in the same village have bus places....we don't. It's a little odd.

Stevenj214

4,941 posts

259 months

Thursday 28th October 2010
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
Stevenj214 said:
Scratch my original question.

Are you appealing to get into the school or onto the bus only?

Edited by Stevenj214 on Thursday 28th October 16:32
No he is in the school, so the bus stops in the village, but he isn't allowed on it as we have a closer school. Which must be true for most of the village
Ok. And you're going to appeal on the basis that some kids who live further away have a space but your son does not? Isn't that how it should work? Kid further away allocated spaces until all spaces are gone.

Bill

58,919 posts

286 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
whats the point of parental choice if the transport that already comes to the village is then not available.


You don't think you're actually meant to exercise that choice do you? wink

Gargamel said:
We are talking about a matter of a few hundred yards.


Between the two schools, or between you and the schools?

Gargamel said:
If I understood it I wouldn't need to ask.


I realise that, but the FOI request might be refused because you're asking details about kids.

Gargamel said:
The bus stops 200 yards from my house, other parents in the same village have bus places....we don't.
That's my point, which school are their kids going to? Do they even run a bus between the village and your school? And if so, and the other kids are going to the more distant school are there other factors at work? Quite possibly they didn't choose the more distant school, but had the decision foisted on them.

Gargamel said:
It's a little odd.
It may well be, or it may (in the context of council service provision, so by definition a bit odd) make perfect sense.

Either way, IMO, you're more likely to get results talking to the pther parents in the village.

Bod0fBritain

1,341 posts

215 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
As previously mentioned, I think how you word it is key here. When you make an FOI request about yourself (eg - Info they hold on you), I believe the request is then handled under the data protection act and not FOI. Because of this, I'd imagine if you asked for names etc, the request would be refused on the grounds of data protection. If this were the case, you could ask how many pupils live further away from the school than you and use that bus service. This would give you some ammo to use in your appeal

Stevenj214

4,941 posts

259 months

Friday 29th October 2010
quotequote all
Bod0fBritain said:
you could ask how many pupils live further away from the school than you and use that bus service. This would give you some ammo to use in your appeal
I really think I'm missing something (obvious?) here.

All of the kids have been accepted to a school which has limited bus places. The bus places seem to have been allocated to the kids who live furthest away. The allocation ran out before it got to the OP's distance from the school.

Surely that's the way it should be? How can it be grounds for appeal?