The One
Author
Discussion

ferrisbueller

Original Poster:

30,343 posts

258 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
Most people would acknowledge that the theory that there is only one person who is an ideal match is rather flawed.

Many different people could meet the criteria and the number swells significantly as you factor in more and more compromise.

Now, one would never admit to one's other half that they're a compromise, at least not in those words. However, the chances are that you've traded a bit of mental for some added randiness, or a bit of intellect for a bit less. That kind of thing. What level of compromise should be acceptable? (Bearing in mind that realism has to kick in, too I.e. Cheryl Cole isn't going to be a feasible option, for example).

Is it realistic to subscribe to the idea that your other half should occupy your mind 24/7, be the only person you want to be with, be the most perfect person in the world in your eyes etc? Or are notions like that best left to people who read romantic novels.


Mobile Chicane

22,029 posts

243 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
ferrisbueller said:
Most people would acknowledge that the theory that there is only one person who is an ideal match is rather flawed.

Many different people could meet the criteria and the number swells significantly as you factor in more and more compromise.

Now, one would never admit to one's other half that they're a compromise, at least not in those words. However, the chances are that you've traded a bit of mental for some added randiness, or a bit of intellect for a bit less. That kind of thing. What level of compromise should be acceptable? (Bearing in mind that realism has to kick in, too I.e. Cheryl Cole isn't going to be a feasible option, for example).

Is it realistic to subscribe to the idea that your other half should occupy your mind 24/7, be the only person you want to be with, be the most perfect person in the world in your eyes etc? Or are notions like that best left to people who read romantic novels.


I think the answer is to be open-minded: someone who might not tick all your boxes can make such a positive impact in one or two, that the rest doesn't matter.

An observation over the years: those who hold out for Mr / Miss 'Perfect' (whatever that means to you) end up embittered and alone.

Allowing (or expecting) someone else to occupy your mind 24/7 however? That's clingy and sad.

EmmaP

11,758 posts

270 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
ferrisbueller said:
Is it realistic to subscribe to the idea that your other half should occupy your mind 24/7, be the only person you want to be with, be the most perfect person in the world in your eyes etc? Or are notions like that best left to people who read romantic novels.
No because that would make you obsessive and doubtless controlling and needy. All in all a very bad combination. I find these notions not in the least bit romantic. Romance for me is something entirely different.

Z4monster

1,442 posts

291 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
It varies over time to be honest. When I first met my partner, he was all I thought about every day. He was perfect and nothing he did could possibly annoy me.

Now 19 years ago I am still in love with him and still have strong feelings for him but the relationship is not all heat and passion any longer. That's not to say it's totally gone, far from it. Things change with time and so do people. There are things he does which piss me off royally and i'm sure the same applies in reverse.

However, that is what being a couple is about. You learn to love the person on a different level than when you first meet. It goes deeper than you could ever think. I couldn't imagine being without him now and the thought that some time in the future I will be without him makes me sad.

No one is perfect and if you only want Mr or Mrs Perfect then you will be old sad and lonely long before you die.

A mate of mine is in exactly like that and now in his late 40's. He'll undoubtably be single until he dies which I think is mightily sad.

There is at least one person for everyone but you might never meet the Perfect One. Sometimes you just have to accept that 98% is the best match you will ever get and so you ignore the 2% which isn't perfect.

Johnny13

94 posts

196 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
IMO..... I moved into a house 5 years ago, having left my very ex wife. Next door there was this utter fab woman, who I considered to be out of my league. We chatted, she thought I was pretty ok as I rode a bike and was at least not fat...............(I'm ok looking really lol) and the chatting got too.......... well............4 years on we are still together and I have found ''the one''

So it doesnt answer your question but does say you just never know...........(out of interest my now wife can also say she has the one......i ASKED LOL)

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
Nobody is perfect... Nobody. You can go into a relationship with those expectations, but if you do, then you are simply going to be disappointed. Every relationship is a compromise, and things will go swimmingly if it is an equal compromise. Not so well if it isn't. I think most people realise their flaws, even if they don;t admit it to themselves, or anyone else. For them to dismiss these in a relationship would be foolhardly.

Johnny13

94 posts

196 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
Z4monster said:
It varies over time to be honest. When I first met my partner, he was all I thought about every day. He was perfect and nothing he did could possibly annoy me.

Now 19 years ago I am still in love with him and still have strong feelings for him but the relationship is not all heat and passion any longer. That's not to say it's totally gone, far from it. Things change with time and so do people. There are things he does which piss me off royally and i'm sure the same applies in reverse.

However, that is what being a couple is about. You learn to love the person on a different level than when you first meet. It goes deeper than you could ever think. I couldn't imagine being without him now and the thought that some time in the future I will be without him makes me sad.

No one is perfect and if you only want Mr or Mrs Perfect then you will be old sad and lonely long before you die.

Dont know if I agree with that. You see people do change and so does their ideals on relationships, however keeping the relationship you have got interesting is the key rather than letting it get boring. If my wife fancies firemen, then hell, i'd be one, at least in costume anyways, as I lovve my wife and want HER to feel special...............

A mate of mine is in exactly like that and now in his late 40's. He'll undoubtably be single until he dies which I think is mightily sad.

There is at least one person for everyone but you might never meet the Perfect One. Sometimes you just have to accept that 98% is the best match you will ever get and so you ignore the 2% which isn't perfect.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
I don't think there's any formula to answer it. In fact I think it is a funny question, and "compromise" is definitely the wrong term.

If you go out with a specification set and look for someone who "ticks all the boxes" then you will only be disappointed.

My girlfriend is absolutely crackers, and I love her for it. I couldn't design her, no matter how much I had drunk. It's the surprises and the things I can not control that make her special. I know it sounds corny but I really have learned to love her idiosyncracies much more than I would love perfection in any predefined criteria.

As for thinking about her 24/7 then no - I still like a perv at other women now and again. That's just natural.

Bill

58,925 posts

286 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
ferrisbueller said:
(Bearing in mind that realism has to kick in, too I.e. Cheryl Cole isn't going to be a feasible option, for example).
Ironic that you've chosen an unrealistic example whose only redeeming feature is being quite decorative. If she didn't have that she'd rank with Jade Goody IMO.

JFReturns

3,834 posts

202 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
You ain't perfect sport, and chances are neither is this girl. Its whether you are perfect for each other that counts.






Ten points for whoever names the film I ripped that from smile

jonlk

215 posts

201 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
JFReturns said:
You ain't perfect sport, and chances are neither is this girl. Its whether you are perfect for each other that counts.






Ten points for whoever names the film I ripped that from smile
It's not Cocktail is it?

Georgiegirl

869 posts

240 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
The trouble is most people are sixes looking for tens.

Granville

983 posts

202 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
No one is perfect. I guess that as long as they're the perfect match for you and they make you happy then that is all that counts.

And yes some partners can make it known that you're second best and not their ideal, and it's these folk that aren't worth the air they breathe

Pints

18,451 posts

225 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
I found a woman, in Mrs Pints, who challenges me.
It's a challenge not to throw myself in front of moving traffic...

But I love her and she's mine and (most importantly) she puts up with my many, many flaws.

crofty1984

17,064 posts

235 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
JFReturns said:
You ain't perfect sport, and chances are neither is this girl. Its whether you are perfect for each other that counts.






Ten points for whoever names the film I ripped that from smile
Good Will Hunting.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
I've just come out of a relationship where I thought she was 'the one'. I've come around now to the understanding that she wasn't and isn't.

What clouded the thinking in my mind, was that we'd been through some pretty traumatic experiences together and she stuck by me, through thick and thin. Reality is we were most likely both being unrealistic and without those traumatic experiences, maybe the relationship would never have lasted, anyway?

As most of us probably do, I know a few people still looking for that perfect woman (whatever that is), and I'm strongly of the belief that the thing doesn't exist. If anything, it's loving the parts that are good in someone that allow you to forgive the flaws. If the good outweighs the flaws, then you're onto a winner. Over time, that balance can change, and that's when the relationship has to end or it become destructive to one or both of you.

It's taken 9 weeks or so, but I'm beginning to kick myself up the arse for being so clouded in my thinking since the break up. Here I was, pretending we had the most perfect thing in the world and all I want is to have it back, when the truth is I hadn't been happy for ages and the interaction between her and me was a big part of that.

Until I made that distinction, I wasn't able to even contemplate moving on.

blowy84

564 posts

237 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
ferrisbueller said:
Most people would acknowledge that the theory that there is only one person who is an ideal match is rather flawed.

Many different people could meet the criteria and the number swells significantly as you factor in more and more compromise.

Now, one would never admit to one's other half that they're a compromise, at least not in those words. However, the chances are that you've traded a bit of mental for some added randiness, or a bit of intellect for a bit less. That kind of thing. What level of compromise should be acceptable? (Bearing in mind that realism has to kick in, too I.e. Cheryl Cole isn't going to be a feasible option, for example).

Is it realistic to subscribe to the idea that your other half should occupy your mind 24/7, be the only person you want to be with, be the most perfect person in the world in your eyes etc? Or are notions like that best left to people who read romantic novels.
Thinking of pulling a pig? Trying to justify it?

stimps

109 posts

198 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
Cheryl Cole is entirely feasible for me, i mean i only missed out on Katy Perry by a few moments.

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
Bill said:
ferrisbueller said:
(Bearing in mind that realism has to kick in, too I.e. Cheryl Cole isn't going to be a feasible option, for example).
Ironic that you've chosen an unrealistic example whose only redeeming feature is being quite decorative. If she didn't have that she'd rank with Jade Goody IMO.
yes

Vacuous.


Liamsaid

48 posts

203 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
I think Tim Minchin explains this one much better than I can:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yStxUTHHUrg