Commuting v. Salary
Author
Discussion

Merlot

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

239 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
I earn about the average UK wage and work 6 miles from home, the 10 minute commute is a fantastic road with great panoramas over the English channel. It is a genuine delight to drive to work in the morning but I recognise that I don't get paid a great deal.

I have the opportunity to apply for an almost identical job with a 50% increase in advertised salary. It is, however, a 150 mile round trip in the car or 1.5 hours each way on the train at a cost of £250/month for a season ticket.

The extra money would be welcome (even after the season ticket), but not needed. I am in a final salary scheme too which would apply to both roles. My girlfriend commutes (not as far) so I'd not miss 'home time' with her much as we'd be back at the same time although I'd have to leave a bit earlier in the morning.

However, I fear that 3-4 hours a day on the train would get me down and it wouldn't be worth it for the quite small financial gain. I have never commuted before, always living close to work.

Comments from those who have been in this situation before? I don't like applying for jobs unless I am totally committed to wanting the job.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
Usual choice of money vs time.

If you need the money, consider going for it.

If you could see things to do with the money, balance that against something like six hours a day spent in your car. Unless you are doing the 300 miles purely on a motorway like the M69 which is little used, you will get stuck. Often and for a long time.

If you don't need the money, but would like a challenge, talk to your management, and get something arranged with them.

Good salary increase, but that's a monster commute.

RacingPete

9,210 posts

235 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
I would base it on quality of commute!

if I was commuting hour and a half on a train and could guarantee a seat and somewhere to plonk a laptop every time (ie you are at the start of the line etc), then I would see commuting and the extra money as a massive bonus and I could do lots of the mundane home stuff (bills, sorting out stuff) while on the train. As well as watch TV or films that I may do at home, thus improving the quality time I have at home to do things as a couple without missing out on man time!

Just my opinion of course smile

Merlot

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

239 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
randlemarcus said:
Usual choice of money vs time.

If you need the money, consider going for it.

If you could see things to do with the money, balance that against something like six hours a day spent in your car. Unless you are doing the 300 miles purely on a motorway like the M69 which is little used, you will get stuck. Often and for a long time.

If you don't need the money, but would like a challenge, talk to your management, and get something arranged with them.

Good salary increase, but that's a monster commute.
Ta.

Don't need the money, although as always any extra is nice - more of a recognition than anything else, my current job is undervalued in a salary sense.

It is 150 mile round trip ie 75 miles each way OR 2 hours each way on the train.

No chance of a raise in my current job, it is the public sector! I've offered to take on extra responsibility for no extra money but typical public sector mentality says "well, we see you have the education, experience and knowledge to take on more but as you're not in that pay band we couldn't possibly give it to you".



Merlot

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

239 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
RacingPete said:
if I was commuting hour and a half on a train and could guarantee a seat and somewhere to plonk a laptop every time (ie you are at the start of the line etc), then I would see commuting and the extra money as a massive bonus and I could do lots of the mundane home stuff (bills, sorting out stuff) while on the train. As well as watch TV or films that I may do at home, thus improving the quality time I have at home to do things as a couple without missing out on man time!
Interesting viewpoint, I like it.

Tadite

560 posts

215 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
I've been in a similar situation. When I was first starting out the only work I could get was 100 miles from home. That's 200 miles a day... every single day. Later I got a bit more at another place that turned the commute into 240 miles.

I did it because I needed the money but more importantly I needed to get a start. Opportunity is rare and I didn't want to be sitting around in a few years wondering how it all went wrong.

Whatever you do make sure it's by train. Driving this amount of miles is draining. It's expensive but more importantly it's mentally exhausting. I'd get home and then just collapse. This isn't a situation that you work then go home to your life. It's you work, drive, sleep and then do the same thing tomorrow. Life just disappears.

Thing is.... after 6 years of this I got a much better job that I only got because of my extensive experience. In the long-run it was worth it but you had better know the reality before you get in.



ludicrous speed

959 posts

225 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
Merlot said:
RacingPete said:
if I was commuting hour and a half on a train and could guarantee a seat and somewhere to plonk a laptop every time (ie you are at the start of the line etc), then I would see commuting and the extra money as a massive bonus and I could do lots of the mundane home stuff (bills, sorting out stuff) while on the train. As well as watch TV or films that I may do at home, thus improving the quality time I have at home to do things as a couple without missing out on man time!
Interesting viewpoint, I like it.
Reality is though that you can't guarantee a seat, and even if you can, the chances of some fat smelly wker sitting next to you at some point in your journey is extremely high. You will also have to put your laptop away to protect it from the spray of the cheese roll he's eating whilst talking on his mobile.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
don't forget getting to and from the station at either end and having to put up with delays etc

it'll be 4-5 hours travelling every day

fk that for a game of soldiers

johnvthe2nd

1,292 posts

228 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
Tadite said:
I've been in a similar situation. When I was first starting out the only work I could get was 100 miles from home. That's 200 miles a day... every single day. Later I got a bit more at another place that turned the commute into 240 miles.

I did it because I needed the money but more importantly I needed to get a start. Opportunity is rare and I didn't want to be sitting around in a few years wondering how it all went wrong.

Whatever you do make sure it's by train. Driving this amount of miles is draining. It's expensive but more importantly it's mentally exhausting. I'd get home and then just collapse. This isn't a situation that you work then go home to your life. It's you work, drive, sleep and then do the same thing tomorrow. Life just disappears.

Thing is.... after 6 years of this I got a much better job that I only got because of my extensive experience. In the long-run it was worth it but you had better know the reality before you get in.
This. Only do it if there's an end game. (good post!)

Merlot

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

239 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
don't forget getting to and from the station at either end and having to put up with delays etc

it'll be 4-5 hours travelling every day

fk that for a game of soldiers
I live 2 mins from my local station and the station is 2 mins walk from this place of work...

It' 2 hours each way, 2 changes with a good enough gap to soak up some delays at each point.

It is though a daunting commute.


robsti

12,241 posts

237 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
Money is not the be all and end all!

redtwin

7,518 posts

213 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
With the right car and the right roads, I would welcome a 150 mile daily commute for a %50 increase in salary.

I wouldn't be interested if it required being on a train for as long as you say with that many stops etc. Nothing beats being in your own space, comfortable and as warm or cool as you like.

ApexJimi

27,801 posts

274 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
In the described situation, I'd definitely stick with the status quo.

150 mile round trip? To work? No chance.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
A 1.5 hour rail commute for only £250 per month?

Has to be railway bargain of the moment!

kentmotorcompany

2,471 posts

241 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
You say girlfriend and don't mention kids. I take this to mean you are young enough, that this may not be your last job change. I'd say go for the extra money while you can, in a few years you may find a similar job closer to home.

By that time you might have children, and the time at home will be much more important than it is now.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
No chance, unless it was big money i.e £50k plus and I got a travel allowance.

Simbu

1,919 posts

205 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
Have you consudered how important the salary increase is from a career point of view? If you go up by 50% in salary (which is a substantial raise) then if you want to move on again in 'x' many years time then having that salary as a starting point may be a useful positon to have higher up the ladder compared to your current job.

Then again this might not be an important factor for you, but it's something to consider.

MonkeyBusiness

4,264 posts

218 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
robsti said:
Money is not the be all and end all!
This.
I am lucky enough to have a 10 minute trip to work (and a parking space which you could argue is another bonus). I can't put a value on how much my commute makes to my quality of life.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
robsti said:
Money is not the be all and end all!
Easy to say when you've got plenty.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
I'd be more happy in a £25k job I love rather than a boring £40k job I loath. You can still have a decent lifestyle on a lower wage with nice cars nice toys etc. It comes down to living in moderation.