Hypothetical question re bomb disposal...
Hypothetical question re bomb disposal...
Author
Discussion

Brother D

Original Poster:

4,452 posts

207 months

Tuesday 23rd November 2010
quotequote all
So... You're stuck in a room with a bomb and the clock is ticking, (as per every movie).

Why not just pull the detonator out of the explosive without the worry of cutting the wong wire?

Surely not having the detonator embedded in the explosive would reduce the chance of if setting off the main charge?

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd November 2010
quotequote all
shout Bruce - your thread has arrived.

SC7

1,882 posts

212 months

Tuesday 23rd November 2010
quotequote all
Well, I'm no bomb disposal expert but I'm pretty fking sure they'd be wired to go off if you remove the detonator.

I'm also pretty sure that bomb disposal has a little more to it than cutting the right coloured wire.

ellroy

7,858 posts

256 months

Tuesday 23rd November 2010
quotequote all
Quite. Cut any wire between the det and the power source, or remove the det from the charge, and the job's a good 'un.

Sadly, most of those dastardly terrorist types, and those trained in Her Majesty's dark arts, will have fitted some type of anti-handling device.

Hence, Bruce and his mates typically disrupt, rather than defuse, the device if the option is there.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd November 2010
quotequote all
SC7 said:
Well, I'm no bomb disposal expert but I'm pretty fking sure they'd be wired to go off if you remove the detonator.

I'm also pretty sure that bomb disposal has a little more to it than cutting the right coloured wire.
essentially yes, some bomb makers put a device on the bomb that can detect movement, think its a mercury switch, so pull the detonator, and good bye bomb disposal expert

ellroy

7,858 posts

256 months

Tuesday 23rd November 2010
quotequote all
You're correct Snowy. A favoured switch is indeed the mercury tilt switch. Enough movement causes the mercury to move and a circuit to be made to the det, bang.

Back in the day PIRA used to rob them out of fruit machines/pinball machines where they operate the anti-tilt stuff.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd November 2010
quotequote all
ellroy said:
You're correct Snowy. A favoured switch is indeed the mercury tilt switch. Enough movement causes the mercury to move and a circuit to be made to the det, bang.

Back in the day PIRA used to rob them out of fruit machines/pinball machines where they operate the anti-tilt stuff.
Thought so. I read it somewhere, cant remember where, but it was about bomb construction and this was one of the things they covered

BruceV8

3,325 posts

278 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
V8mate said:
shout Bruce - your thread has arrived.
bowtie

In answer to the OP's question, cutting wires or removing dets remain options in an emergency, but in Northern Ireland we lost 17 operators, most of whom were attempting to do just that.

Therefore, these days, the preferred option is to use something like this:



which fires water at extremely high velocity into a device, breaking it up before it has a chance to function. Ideally we would use it mounted on one of these, which is called a Wheelbarrow:



Which has no next of kin. It does this:





If the device does function, we pick up its pieces and not those of a bloke.



Sometimes you can't use a remote vehicle so a manual approach must be made first. Even if the Wheelbarrow is used a manual must still be made. In most cases the operator would wear one of these fetching numbers:



Naturally, there's rather a lot more to it than that but I thought pictures would be best for PH. smile

Bill

58,939 posts

286 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
Brilliant. They have bombs, we have a robot with water pistol hehe

Jonny671

29,904 posts

220 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
I'm sure they done this on "Hurt Locker"? When he was pulling the dets out of the bombs?

FasterFreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
BruceV8 said:
Are they radio/mobile phone jammers?

BruceV8

3,325 posts

278 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
FasterFreddy said:
BruceV8 said:
Are they radio/mobile phone jammers?
yes But I can't tell you any more about them than that.

Mainly because, as far as I'm concerned, they operate using witchcraft

Taffer

2,371 posts

228 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
BruceV8 said:

smile
Probably the cheapest and most useful tracked vehicle the British Army has - with a manipulator arm fitted, is it capable of getting beers from a fridge (hypothetically; obviously you professionals wouldn't dream of trying it out)?

TUS 373

5,243 posts

312 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
FasterFreddy said:
BruceV8 said:
Are they radio/mobile phone jammers?
Do you get special underpants to go with that outfit too? Always wondered.hehe


Mr Trophy

6,811 posts

234 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
TUS 373 said:
FasterFreddy said:
BruceV8 said:
Are they radio/mobile phone jammers?
Do you get special underpants to go with that outfit too? Always wondered.hehe
I'd be wanting metal pants!

hehe

lawrence567

7,507 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
Ok i confess to knowing nothing about bombs apart from generally they go bang & cause pain & destruction.
But, if you know there's a bomb in the ground, say an IED for example, why bother defusing it?
Why not just throw a 'nade in the whole & blow it up?

911motorsport

7,251 posts

264 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
Sorry for slightly O.T. question, but is that someone about 8 feet tall stood in the group? hehe


Major Fallout

5,278 posts

262 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
BruceV8 said:
Which fires water at extremely high velocity into a device, breaking it up before it has a chance to function.
Wow that really does look high velocity! Is it a pump sort of thing or a shot or water?

Wow that really does look high velocity! Is it a pump sort of thing or a shot or water?

Oh and how tall is that police man! Reminds me of the ladybird book.


Bugger beaten to it

Edited by Major Fallout on Wednesday 24th November 13:10


Edited by Major Fallout on Wednesday 24th November 13:13

Fume troll

4,389 posts

243 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
Bruce, how much good would the lego space man suit do? Could you survive say, a hand grenade going off in your face?

Cheers,

FT.

smack

9,777 posts

222 months

Wednesday 24th November 2010
quotequote all
Bruce, as always that is very interesting. Cheers.