Calling an academic!
Calling an academic!
Author
Discussion

matt21

Original Poster:

4,404 posts

235 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
Not sure exactly where I should post this, but here goes!

I am having to write my first essay for my MSc for a long long time. Obviously anything I mention that is not my own work should be reference.

If I reference Person A's work I would obviously make a proper note of this.

However, if Person A referenced Person B and I read A's work and liked B's comment whos work would I reference.

Would I simply skip A and reference B (as it was his/her work).

Appreciate this is dull as dish water and over complicated but very grateful if an academic could be of assistance!

tank slapper

7,949 posts

314 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
You should reference both. Something like "Smith (2001) citing Jones (1985)".

Here is a handy guide for referencing.

MrChips

3,299 posts

241 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
If it's clear that A has referenced B, and you're quoting only what B has said, then just reference B.
Otherwise quote A as thats effectively where you've read it.

Can you not simply use an acknowledgements for all general references, and then only when you're actually quoting the original work, do you need to be specific?

God i've made myself go to sleep with that reply sleep

rustbuster

64 posts

216 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
MrChips said:
If it's clear that A has referenced B, and you're quoting only what B has said, then just reference B.
Otherwise quote A as thats effectively where you've read it.
^this^ however when you read B you might find they have quoted C... etc. great fun, Not.

-Pete-

2,914 posts

207 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
Try "Tank Slapper (2010) proposing Smith (2001) citing Jones (1985)"

tank slapper

7,949 posts

314 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
rustbuster said:
MrChips said:
If it's clear that A has referenced B, and you're quoting only what B has said, then just reference B.
Otherwise quote A as thats effectively where you've read it.
^this^ however when you read B you might find they have quoted C... etc. great fun, Not.
You have to be a bit careful, referencing B if in fact you have read A quoting B, as you are assuming that the quote is correct. You then need to go and find B to make sure and read that, which takes more time and effort than just referencing it as it is quoted. Unless it is a key point and you will benefit from the wider context, it may not be worth the extra time.

matt12023

485 posts

227 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
I you were to talk about Mr B’s work that is referenced in Mr A’s this would be secondary referencing which is to be avoided. If Mr B’s stuff is that good/relevant then you should track it down from the reference in Mr A’s and read it yourself. You can then reference to your heart’s content

wendyg

2,071 posts

274 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
There are several different styles of referencing, which have their own conventions. A couple of the commonest are the Oxford and the Harvard. Find out from your College/School/Uni which style they want and they can give you detailed guidelines. This will include 'references to other work' HTH