Private health insurance - talk to me
Private health insurance - talk to me
Author
Discussion

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

300 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
What are your views on private health insurance? Worth it? If so, which instance schemes are any good? Any to avoid?

Nickbrapp

5,277 posts

159 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Interested aswell, currently paying for bupa mainly for the future risk of cancer and their top care they can provide and to shop the waiting list on the NHS.

Not used it yet but their customer service has been a bit naff over a complaint on how they set up the policy

anonymous-user

83 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Translated my wife's corporate cover to private when she took early retirement.

Using AXA PPP.

You can significantly reduced the cost if you restrict how many hospitals you can pick from.

Not used them since but used them for a back operation when she still had the corporate cover and had no complaints

Lemming Train

5,567 posts

101 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
You get treated by the same NHS staff/doctor/surgeons you'd get for free if you weren't private. The main difference is your money sees you jump the waiting list queue and if you need to be admitted you might get a private room to yourself and a rib-eye for your tea instead of bangers and mash that all the NHS scrubs get.

Mr Pointy

13,357 posts

188 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Lemming Train said:
You get treated by the same NHS staff/doctor/surgeons you'd get for free if you weren't private. The main difference is your money sees you jump the waiting list queue and if you need to be admitted you might get a private room to yourself and a rib-eye for your tea instead of bangers and mash that all the NHS scrubs get.
You can access to treatments the NHS doesn't provide. It's not just about waiting times.

Lemming Train

5,567 posts

101 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Mr Pointy said:
ou can access to treatments the NHS doesn't provide. It's not just about waiting times.
Well of course you can, seeing as you're paying for it, but that wasn't asked by the OP.

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

300 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Whilst that wasn’t my original question, what sorts of treatment are covered by private health that aren’t available on the NHS? Anything important (e.g. cancer drugs)?

Lemming Train

5,567 posts

101 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Anything you want as you're paying for it. The range of treatments is only limited by how much money you have.

KeithE

110 posts

199 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
What you get with private medical insurance (PMI) depends on the cover you buy, like most insurance products. You can get very comprehensive cover that will pay for just about any treatment required in just about any hospital or you can buy a restricted cover. Restrictions can include a limited choice of hospitals (if you can do without the main London hospitals it can make a BIG difference to the premium), limited or no out patient cover, no cover for certain conditions etc. Standard exclusions for most PMI include treatment for conditions you had before the cover started, cosmetic treatments, experimental treatments, chronic conditions (i.e. ongoing conditions for which there is no cure like diabetes)
The premiums tend not to be cheap but whether they are good value is a matter of opinion. Some medical treatments, including cancer, can cost tens of thousands a year so if you are unlucky enough to need to claim for one of those you would probably think you had good value. Equally, if you have a condition for which there is a long NHS list immediate private treatment can save a lot of pain and worry.
With PMI you will invariably get a private room, but that is less of a benefit nowadays as many newer NHS hospitals offer private rooms. Visiting times at private hospitals tend to be unlimited and the food and attention you get is generally an improvement over the NHS however, as another poster said, the treating doctors will probably be exactly the same as those you would have got treatment from under the NHS.
As you can probably tell, I’m in the industry so if you have any specific questions fire away and I’ll do my best to answer

Mr Pointy

13,357 posts

188 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Lemming Train said:
Anything you want as you're paying for it. The range of treatments is only limited by how much money you have.
Wrong, as usual. All PMI policies have limits & exclusions. If you want unlimited treatement it will be paid in cash outside of the insurance.

Mr Pointy

13,357 posts

188 months

Saturday 11th May 2019
quotequote all
Lemming Train said:
Mr Pointy said:
ou can access to treatments the NHS doesn't provide. It's not just about waiting times.
Well of course you can, seeing as you're paying for it, but that wasn't asked by the OP.
He didn't ask if it would be different doctors either but you decided to indicate that they would be the same - which is also incorrect as you can elect to use specialists outside of your area if they are on the insurers list.

Lemming Train

5,567 posts

101 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
Mr Pointy said:
Lemming Train said:
Anything you want as you're paying for it. The range of treatments is only limited by how much money you have.
Wrong, as usual. All PMI policies have limits & exclusions. If you want unlimited treatement it will be paid in cash outside of the insurance.
You're splitting hairs just to be argumentative, as usual. It boils down to the same thing. If you wave enough money at them you can have whatever treatment you want. If you don't have limitless money then obviously there are going to be limits on the treatment available as that's how insurance policies work. That only needs spelling out to complete dummies because it's obvious to anyone else with a functioning brain.

SVS

Original Poster:

3,824 posts

300 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
KeithE said:
What you get with private medical insurance (PMI) depends on the cover you buy, like most insurance products. You can get very comprehensive cover that will pay for just about any treatment required in just about any hospital or you can buy a restricted cover.
Thanks Keith. Does anyone know of a good way to compare different insurers’ policies?

I’ve seen that Moneysupermarket does comparisons, but it looks fairly superficial. Is there a better way of comparing private health insurers?

Peter3442

450 posts

97 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
What's the advantage of insurance over paying yourself (obviously after putting money aside over the years)?

Cooper2

143 posts

107 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
SVS said:
Thanks Keith. Does anyone know of a good way to compare different insurers’ policies?

I’ve seen that Moneysupermarket does comparisons, but it looks fairly superficial. Is there a better way of comparing private health insurers?
I use https://usaycompare.co.uk/
They will contact you at renewal to check if you are happy or not with the increase in premiums and offer, if available, a more competitive price with another provider.

croyde

26,349 posts

259 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
My ex wife started cover at £120 a month which seemed reasonable. She was later diagnosed with aggressive breast cancer and the treatment she received was amazing, including drugs that would not have been available on the NHS according to our GP.

5 years on and after a lot of aggressive therapy and operations and she's currently clear.

But, her monthly payments are now £900 and she is uninsurable by anyone else.

She has had to stop the insurance.

So it did her good for actually being ill but the premiums sky rocket.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,040 posts

179 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
Peter3442 said:
What's the advantage of insurance over paying yourself (obviously after putting money aside over the years)?
That's the same for any non compulsory insurance. What if you need treatment before you've had a change to put the money aside? What if the claim is so large it exceeds the money you have put aside.

KeithE

110 posts

199 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
I think the usual comparison sights are as good as you’ll get. I haven’t looked recently at the comparison sights but I wouldn’t expect them to have any real detail. If you know what kind of cover you’re looking for I’d be inclined to look at some of the providers websites or give them a call and discuss. Only thing I would say, PMI is quite a specialist cover and some of the household names use the bigger providers like AXA and Bupa (who between them hold over 2/3rds of the market). Nothing wrong with that but it does mean that you have more people trying to take a profit from your premium.
For obvious reasons I don’t want to talk openly about who I am with but if you want to PM me I can be more open

oceanview

1,631 posts

160 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
I am 47 now but, i know when i looked into it when i was in my twenties it was bloody expensive ( i think about £50 a month then, so god knows what it would be now!), so decided it would be cheaper in the long run to just pay out private if and when i needed anything!
I paid for a private ultra sound scan in 2000, that cost about £200, and seen a couple of private consultants since (£120 each) which didn't need any further investigations/actions, so for me, it was just cheaper to pay out when i needed it!

KeithE

110 posts

199 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
Croyde, I’m intrigued that your wife’s premiums went up like that. Generally PMI premiums aren’t directly affected by individual claims (unless there was a no claim discount involved). Intrigued to know who the cover was with