Euro car parts selling old batteries?
Euro car parts selling old batteries?
Author
Discussion

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,254 posts

99 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
Having just ordered a new Bosch car battery from Europarts, I turned up at the Barnsley branch to collect it, The battery was behind the counter and looked anything but new, and when I examined it (something the assistant seemed reluctant for me to do)I I could see that the label was dated 2018. As it is now 6th September it is likely that the battery is at least 9 months old. I am aware of what extended discharge periods can do to a battery so I refused to accept it. They produced another battery (from which the same label had mysteriously been removed). When I buy a battery I want a relatively new battery, I'm funny like that. I wanted to buy it from Eurocarparts for simplicity of returning it in the event of a fault, but mu trust in them has been severely dented. It's an 04 27 with 4 year warranty

rainmakerraw

1,246 posts

157 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
As it is now 6th September it is likely that the battery is at least 9 months old.
Can you PM me next week's Euromillions numbers?

Pintofbest

906 posts

141 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
Having just ordered a new Bosch car battery from Europarts, I turned up at the Barnsley branch to collect it, The battery was behind the counter and looked anything but new, and when I examined it (something the assistant seemed reluctant for me to do)I I could see that the label was dated 2018. As it is now 6th September it is likely that the battery is at least 9 months old. I am aware of what extended discharge periods can do to a battery so I refused to accept it. They produced another battery (from which the same label had mysteriously been removed). When I buy a battery I want a relatively new battery, I'm funny like that. I wanted to buy it from Eurocarparts for simplicity of returning it in the event of a fault, but mu trust in them has been severely dented. It's an 04 27 with 4 year warranty
As long as it has had a voltage check it should be fine. I've worked in aftermarket for OE and now independent - OE have charging regimes and checks and the engineers dictated shelf life requirements similar to those needed in manufacturing. In independent aftermarket those conditions generally aren't there with no real adverse impacts.

DanielSan

20,081 posts

198 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
I can't see the issue here? It's got a 4 year warranty, the warranty won't start until you buy it. The batteries aren't made to order and sent straight to ECP, they'll sit with the supplier for however long it takes to shift the stock that was there before it.

rallycross

13,758 posts

268 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
If buying from ECP avoid their Lion brand batteries they are rubbish and don’t last long.

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,254 posts

99 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
A voltage check confirms nothing. My current battery is shot and does not hold a charge but a voltage check immediately after charging shows plenty of voltage, even though it won't start my car.

It's true that the four year warranty is in place, but I'm told by a couple of very knowledgeable chaps that discharging a battery beyond a certain point, especially for long periods, will kill it. If my battery dies, it will cause hassle and inconvenience, how much hassle depending on where I am and what I'm doing.

I can't see Euro Car Parts charging their batteries in a well organised cycle. From what I've read, most employees seem to hate the place and morale is very low.. A few months I could understand, but nine months, and possibly much more is simply too long in my opinion.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
A voltage check confirms nothing. My current battery is shot and does not hold a charge but a voltage check immediately after charging shows plenty of voltage, even though it won't start my car.

It's true that the four year warranty is in place, but I'm told by a couple of very knowledgeable chaps that discharging a battery beyond a certain point, especially for long periods, will kill it. If my battery dies, it will cause hassle and inconvenience, how much hassle depending on where I am and what I'm doing.

I can't see Euro Car Parts charging their batteries in a well organised cycle. From what I've read, most employees seem to hate the place and morale is very low.. A few months I could understand, but nine months, and possibly much more is simply too long in my opinion.
For unused batteries the voltage check is quite relevant. If they are 12.6v or close great. If not. Run. (if they are less than full you have to ask why. LA batteries naturally self-drain over time)

Once a battery has been used a bit then the voltage check tells you nothing about the battery's performance.

Once drained below 11ish volts, LA batteries suphate and it buggers them, particularly if left like that. Your mate is right.

LA batteries store well. But they need maintenance charging (topping up) They also have a finite number of uses (charge / discharge).

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
A voltage check confirms nothing.
That's not right. You're doing it wrong - by charging the battery and then immediately measuring the voltage.

If you charge the battery at room temperature and then leave it to stand overnight at room temperature you will get a voltage reading next morning that gives a good indication of the battery's condition.

A perfect battery will give around 12.65 volts. At the simplest, anything under 12.4 volts is "knackered" and anything under 12 volts is "long dead".

Having said that, a high drain drop test at your local battery specialist is the best way to check a battery.

Coilspring

577 posts

94 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
It's a battery. Go elsewhere.

Euro's are not the best or the only supplier.

Use your local independant factor.

V8 TEJ

375 posts

192 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
RogerDodger said:
For unused batteries the voltage check is quite relevant. If they are 12.6v or close great. If not. Run. (if they are less than full you have to ask why. LA batteries naturally self-drain over time)

Once a battery has been used a bit then the voltage check tells you nothing about the battery's performance.

Once drained below 11ish volts, LA batteries suphate and it buggers them, particularly if left like that. Your mate is right.

LA batteries store well. But they need maintenance charging (topping up) They also have a finite number of uses (charge / discharge).
yes

I work at Bosch, and batteries are one of the products I am responsible for. What you say is correct.

There is also 13 digit code on the top of the battery that determines it's manufacturing date. I am assuming the 2018 sticker was put on my ECP as they don't leave the factory (to my knowledge) with any actual date printed on them smile

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,254 posts

99 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
the code on the side of the batteries are as follows:
570 412 063
0 092 s40 260
There is a 13 digit code on the barcode which is 4 047023479730

I can't easily decipher a date from that, assuming it's the right code?

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,254 posts

99 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
V8 TEJ said:
RogerDodger said:
For unused batteries the voltage check is quite relevant. If they are 12.6v or close great. If not. Run. (if they are less than full you have to ask why. LA batteries naturally self-drain over time)

Once a battery has been used a bit then the voltage check tells you nothing about the battery's performance.

Once drained below 11ish volts, LA batteries suphate and it buggers them, particularly if left like that. Your mate is right.

LA batteries store well. But they need maintenance charging (topping up) They also have a finite number of uses (charge / discharge).
yes

I work at Bosch, and batteries are one of the products I am responsible for. What you say is correct.

There is also 13 digit code on the top of the battery that determines it's manufacturing date. I am assuming the 2018 sticker was put on my ECP as they don't leave the factory (to my knowledge) with any actual date printed on them smile
I was told by the chap in the shop ( I asked for the manager but he couldn't be arsed to come out and talk to me), that the date on the label represented the date that Bosch charged the battery before shipping.

V8 TEJ

375 posts

192 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
the code on the side of the batteries are as follows:
570 412 063
0 092 s40 260
There is a 13 digit code on the barcode which is 4 047023479730

I can't easily decipher a date from that, assuming it's the right code?
Apologies for the crap image, but the code in question will be like the one on the left below. It will start with a letter, number, letter, and then a series of numbers.


alangla

6,815 posts

212 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
Slightly off-topic, but related - is it true that Varta & Bosch batteries are actually identical apart from the labels? Varta ones with the same warranty/CCA/Ah seem to be cheaper than the equivalent Bosch & physically they appear identical.

V8 TEJ

375 posts

192 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
That's a discussion for another time smile

Jimmy Recard

17,551 posts

210 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
rallycross said:
If buying from ECP avoid their Lion brand batteries they are rubbish and don’t last long.
I disagree. I have them in several cars.

I have a Corsa that I put one into in September 2017. It sat until it went for MOT in April 2018. It then sat until its MOT in April 2019 (two miles between MOTs - test centre and back))

Then my brother collected it from me to use daily. He’s still using it with the same battery working fine.

They come with a three year warranty too

Feirny

2,951 posts

178 months

Tuesday 6th August 2019
quotequote all
V8 TEJ said:
yes

I work at Bosch, and batteries are one of the products I am responsible for. What you say is correct.

There is also 13 digit code on the top of the battery that determines it's manufacturing date. I am assuming the 2018 sticker was put on my ECP as they don't leave the factory (to my knowledge) with any actual date printed on them smile
ECP don't add a date either, just the corresponding P/N.