Aftermarket From EuroCarParts - Schaeffler vs Airtex

[Ravnut]

Hi All,

Just seeking some general advice.
I recently bought a waterpump (to fit a Vauxhall Zaf Tourer) from EuroCarParts.

As often happens, ECP had a choice of aftermarket manufacturers to choose from. I went with the most expensive, an Airtex brand at £85.
When I collected the pump the one I've been handed is a Schaeffler INA pump.

The Schaeffler pump wasn't an option on the ECP's website.

I understand that manufacturers often have multiple sub-brands but I can't find a relationship between Schaeffler and Airtex.
I'm also not sure which is considered the better quality, so I don't know if ECP are pulling a fast one (and I need to hold out for the Airtex brand I ordered) or I've actually gotten the better end of the deal?

Anyone able to shed any light on this or offer 1st hand experience?

Thanks in advance!

[PhillipM]

I don't really know much about Airtex but I certainly wouldn't be unhappy with a Schaeffler either way - they've a great reputation in the engineering world for their bearings and seals.

[Belle427]

I always thought Airtex were a quality product but they seem to get mixed reviews these days.
If ECP sell them they are probably junk now.
INA stuff is very good.

[stevemcs]

I’d happily take the ina over the Airtek pump.

[cnprior]

Schaeffler is decent stuff.....

[kambites]

Belle427 said:

If ECP sell them they are probably junk now.

Not sure that really holds. ECP sell some very good stuff... they just also sell some complete junk.