How to upset all of the people all of the time.
How to upset all of the people all of the time.
Author
Discussion

PatHeald

Original Poster:

8,058 posts

283 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
TVRs have great engines and crap handling.

Lotuses have great handling and crap engines.

Discuss....

Crimson King 500

553 posts

289 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
Boy oh boy are you are asking for trouble posting this?
All depends on tyres and the nut that holds the steering wheel I was always told.

andytk

1,558 posts

293 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all

TVRs have great engines and crap handling.



Of course to really upset folk you could say that modern TVR's have crap engines and great handling

Andy
:goingforhisfirstbinnedpost:

alan_driver

1,281 posts

284 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
Advice- delete post asap.

dazren

22,612 posts

288 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
Advice - change the thread to "Is this true?"

Then duck for cover.

DAZ

ErnestM

11,621 posts

294 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
Nothing wrong with the modern Lotus V8 except that it has to be managed electronically so that the driver doesn't FUBAR the half shafts, synchros, etc...

...so in conclusion - engine great, handling great, transmission needs a look at but is strong enough if you don't drive like an arse...

ErnestM

PS: As proof of the engine info above - do you know how to get over 400 hp out of a Lotus V8? - easy: buy the Race ECU from Lotus and plug it in - the potential is already there

williamp

20,282 posts

300 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
Oh how about the 944 has a great engine and handles great. The end...

BTW, It is possible to buy an esprit V8 without the huge rear spoiler??? Personally I think it spoils the looks. I love the look of the earlier Esprits. Theres a guy who drives an early Turbo (white with red graphics) round near where I live and I think it looks great, in an 1980's sort of way...

AJLintern

4,372 posts

290 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
I quite agree Will - but it could still do with a bit more power and a V8 soundtrack Remember when that was discussed on the titanic mailing list? :sacrilege:

manek

2,978 posts

311 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all
Wouldn't disagree that engines used to get more attention than handling at the TVR design studios... :wink:

>> Edited by manek on Saturday 18th January 23:01

corozin

2,680 posts

298 months

Saturday 18th January 2003
quotequote all

ErnestM said:PS: As proof of the engine info above - do you know how to get over 400 hp out of a Lotus V8? - easy: buy the Race ECU from Lotus and plug it in - the potential is already there

I did a factory visit to Hethel last year, and the Lotus guys will tell you that the protoype Esprit V8 was so powerful that it ran at well over 200mph in testing, hence the production ECU "gags" it to about 175mph.

Don

28,378 posts

311 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all


TVRs have great engines and crap handling.



Well. Some models. Other models handle well too by repute. I can't wait to try a Tamora - once the wife and I start looking to upgrade her Chimaera for real. BUT. Even our Chimaera has handling that is significantly better than most cars on the road. Coupled with its enormous power that's a fine combination. The problem (if there was one) I'd say is that the Chimaera has greater power than handling capability and relies on the driver to use the power wisely.

Personally I can live with that - but it does lead to a few "moments" in early ownership.

So handling isn't crap. You've just got to remember its dealing with speeds and acceleration that is matched with, to quote the handbook, "An unusually high level of in-gear performance!"



Lotuses have great handling and crap engines.
Discuss....


Can't really comment. I have hooned an Elise around Silverstone and Thruxton and I thought they were GREAT little cars. I'd love one - but only as an additional car not as a replacement. Sure - it ran out of acceleration up above 80mph BUT - once again in comparison to most cars on the road it goes like stink.



Porsches not only look great they go well too.



Well of course!

williamp

20,282 posts

300 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all

AJLintern said: I quite agree Will - but it could still do with a bit more power and a V8 soundtrack Remember when that was discussed on the titanic mailing list? :sacrilege:


Ohhh. A V8 in my 944. Ja, bitter!!!

Simonelite501

1,440 posts

295 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all

williamp said: Oh how about the 944 has a great engine and handles great. The end....



looks like a bag 'O horse poo!....

(coatonandrunningforthefireescape)

AJLintern

4,372 posts

290 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all
Oi - Don't lets start that again! He who drives a Dutton Pheaton...

Simonelite501

1,440 posts

295 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all

AJLintern said: Oi - Don't lets start that again! He who drives a Dutton Pheaton...


Dutton = Miss World
944 = Waynetta Slob!
Oh its PhAeton by the way

Edited to add that the Dutton goes like stink, with its little old ford lump (due to it being slightly heavier than a not very heavy thing) and handles like a go kart. Shed loads more fun than my old Lotus, which would have far out handled a 944 and cost half the price of even a rough one. My 907 Lotus engine was always as good as gold over 4500rpm which is where the power is but the main flaw with Lotuses from the 70's and 80's was the extremely fragile gearboxes and final drives. As for TVR's not handling well I cannot comment but I always thought there biggest problem was build quality.

>> Edited by Simonelite501 on Sunday 19th January 20:52

madcop

6,649 posts

290 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all
Depends what TVR you are talking about. My experience is they all handle reasonably well. Tuscan and Cerb are much better (as you would expect) than the Chimaera or the older models.

Lotus are smaller (generally) and less weight.

They both have a tendancy to break at times as you are all well aware.

The confidence, knowledge and skill of the particular driver also has a good deal to do with it!

Difficult to say which is the better out of the two,
I suppose horses for courses

AJLintern

4,372 posts

290 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all

Simonelite501 said:

Oh its PhAeton by the way




Well you'd better change how its spelt in your profile, because thats where I got the spelling from...


Simonelite501

1,440 posts

295 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all
Done!
P,S you've got to go on this Dorset Dawdle, it sound like its going to be a giggle! And anyway, the title suits the 944 to a tee!



>> Edited by Simonelite501 on Sunday 19th January 22:36

AJLintern

4,372 posts

290 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all
Pah! I'd like to see your kitcar get 150mph from its weedy Cortina engine
Zer ist no substitute vor ze cubic inches mine friend...

ATG

23,561 posts

299 months

Sunday 19th January 2003
quotequote all

manek said: ... at the TVR design studios...


eh? what that?