Advice please... which estate?
Advice please... which estate?
Author
Discussion

loudpedal

Original Poster:

3,945 posts

297 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
about to buy a diesel estate for around the £19k mark for work.

choices so far are:

Skoda octavia
VW Passat
MG ZT-T
Ford Mondeo

Any thoughts chaps? Also, other suggestions welcome. Gotta be brand new and fairly large (eg: golf too small).

Many thanks

Jake

Mad Dave

7,158 posts

291 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Nah, sod any of those - you want one of these babies:

www.qv500.com/adstaylor456ven.htm

loudpedal

Original Poster:

3,945 posts

297 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Yep. you're right... unfortunately, I have to live in this thing called reality... means I have to spend the next 5 years doing 20,000 miles per annum in a diesel. I know its a dull choice to have to make, but that's kind of the reason I'm asking on here... cant be @rsed deciding myself!

sparks

1,217 posts

307 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Audi A4
Subaru impreza 5 door/forester/legacy
pug 406

saab 9-3 hatch/estate (if available) 9-5 may be too much

Sparks

edited to add, missed the diseasel bit so scrap the subaru suggestion!


>> Edited by sparks on Wednesday 26th February 15:33

Mad Dave

7,158 posts

291 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
hehe, yeah, reality's a bugger - scuppers all of my interesting plans

Sorry i couldnt be of more help!

danhay

7,550 posts

284 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Have you considered a Dual Fuel conversion as an alternative to diesel?

You'll be exempt from Congestion Charge too.

RichB

56,057 posts

312 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Chatsworth ?

CarZee

13,382 posts

295 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all

RichB said: Chatsworth ?

Pah - Aim higher - think Balmoral

tvrslag

1,198 posts

283 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
What about.....
Alfa romeo 156 JTS or JTD sportswagon
3 series touring (only a crappy 1.6 for just over 20K i'm afraid).
Citroen C5 2.0 HDI estate (absolutely huge, and loaded and costs next to nothing).
Mazda 6 estate meant to be very good handling with some rave reviews recently.
Renault Laguna sport tourer (estate to you and me).
Volvo V40.
Some very good and fancy cars there to choose from, all available for well under 19k so opportunity to add a few extras.
My choice, Alfa if space isn't prime concern but style and pace is, C5 if space is the main consideration.

cpearson

149 posts

283 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
mad dave thats just wrong!!!!! enzo would be turning in his grave if he saw that!!!!!

sparks

1,217 posts

307 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
tvrslag,

I specifically didn't mention the Alfa, as it isn't any bigger than a golf (whatever alfa romeo believes).

The boot of the sportwagen with the load cover in place, is the same as my 306 hatch!

Good car crap company (IMHO)

Sparks

>> Edited by sparks on Wednesday 26th February 15:55

SBD

462 posts

299 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Loudpedal - bought a Focus TDCI a year ago for similar reasons and really very pleased with it. The boot capacity is actually only just smaller than the Mondeo (half a cubic foot IIRC) and the engine is a little beauty particularly when hoofed on the M'way
Have done 3-4 hour jaunts with 2 adults in the back with no complaints at all. Sure it's not a sports car but that's not why I bought it but then not many sportscars can get 50 mpg! At the time Ford were trying to promote it so got a whole host of goodies like disks on the rear, 6 disk cd, metallic etc.
I think that Van Aaken do a plug in black box that bumps up the hp nicely and the torque (more important if you ask me) rockets.
Have a test drive see what you think and all for 14k. Marvellous.

tvrslag

1,198 posts

283 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
sparks.
I agree, drove one a few years back and the JTD engine was good, nice interior but boot was pretty poor. My wifes golf est Company Car was bigger.
But if space isn't the biggest priority it could be a consideration, IMHO if space is the seller then you can't beat a C5, they are HUGE!! Well kitted out and pretty cheap, also I think Citroen extended their VAT back scheme, but even if its not running anymore there are always handsome discounts to be had at Citroen dealers. (Not that I'm pro Citroen or anything).

alfa dave

967 posts

312 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
From your list I'd go for the Mondeo 130PS TDCi. Great mid range torque. I've got a V40 at present - ok but wouldn't have another. Interested to see what the V50 is like though...

jondokic

385 posts

295 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Ye gods ! That 456 GTA estate's horrendous, Citroen XM rear door glass is a particularly nice touch. Still, good to know its designer found work afterwards:
www.pistonheads.com/news/images/2863-02_small.jpg

Edited repeatedly to try and make the above image show. But it doesn't.

>> Edited by jondokic on Wednesday 26th February 16:21

>> Edited by jondokic on Wednesday 26th February 16:21

Mark Benson

8,264 posts

297 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
The other half has a diesel Passat Estate as a company car at the moment.

Avoid.

Spoonman

1,085 posts

289 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
Considered an Omega? Yes, yes, it's a Vauxhall – but it's a big bugger and it's rear-wheel drive. New Vectra estate should be an option too.

I'd go for the Mondeo estate, though. Oh, hang on, I already have one.

Fatboy

8,267 posts

300 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all
What about an Omygod?

loudpedal

Original Poster:

3,945 posts

297 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all

Mark Benson said: The other half has a diesel Passat Estate as a company car at the moment.

Avoid.


pray tell, why's that?

loudpedal

Original Poster:

3,945 posts

297 months

Wednesday 26th February 2003
quotequote all

Spoonman said: Considered an Omega? Yes, yes, it's a Vauxhall – but it's a big bugger and it's rear-wheel drive. New Vectra estate should be an option too.

I'd go for the Mondeo estate, though. Oh, hang on, I already have one.


I think Omegas are out of the price bracket tho... start at 22k or thereabouts...