Heartless scumbag burocrats.....,, happens again!!
Heartless scumbag burocrats.....,, happens again!!
Author
Discussion

JMGS4

Original Poster:

8,936 posts

301 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
A quote from todays sky news.......... And I thought the fiascos after the Falklands had at least got rid of some of these heartless bastards!!!!






Devastated: Lianne Seymour


WAR WIDOW DEMAND ANGER

The widow of a British soldier killed in the Iraq war was ordered to leave their Forces' home and repay some of his wages - just three days after he died.

Royal Marine Ian Seymour's wife, Lianne, was mortified when a Ministry of Defence official visited her home and made the demands.


He ordered her to hand back a £400 "overpayment" in the 28-year-old serviceman's wages.

She and her three-year-old son, Beck, were also informed she could only stay at her home in Poole, Dorset, for six months, plus a further three months if she asked.

'Robbed of everything'

Lianne, 27 - whose husband was killed in a helicopter crash in Kuwait on March 21 - wrote a letter to the Prime Minister.

Tony Blair then ordered a probe into the MoD's handling of the issue - after sending Lianne a hand-written note dealing with her "concerns".

Lianne sobbed: "I feel like I've been robbed of everything and just for the sake of 10 days' pay, they're telling me I have to make a repayment."

Mr Seymour, 28, an operator mechanic with 3 Commando Brigade, was one of eight British servicemen killed when a US helicopter crashed south of the Kuwait border.

Apology

He was given full military honours at his funeral on April 9.

A MoD spokesman said: "There is certainly no notice for Mrs Seymour to leave her house and any request for her to reimburse money was an administrative error."

He added that Mrs Seymour would be visited by officials "as soon as possible" and would be sent an apology.



CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
It's amazing that a civilised human being can walk into the woman's house and make this demand. I mean, what kind of braindead android gimp do you have to be to be able to do this?

Evidently it was a procedural cock up but the prick in the first instance somehow lacked the nouse to consider this possibility. Blinded by the beurocracy, cruising thru career on autopilot until retirement in Eastbourne.

WAKE UP YOU TWAT!!!!

Fcuking civil servants. Sack him, take his pension and beat his children.

I feel much better now.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
It was obviously a mistake but of a kind that shouldn't, ever, be made.

Blair will undoubtedly be sanctimonious and try to get kudos out of it for his sympathy. :wringhandssincerefaceon: Lets not forget though that it was he that announced that British soldiers had been "executed by the Iraqis" when the military said they had died in battle.

The jobsworth responsible should be uprooted from the seat where they have spent the war and issued with rations and gun and booked a seat on the first flight out to the next point of conflict, whrerever that may be.

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
This is nothing short of an absolute fcuking sham.

Matt.

NickD

417 posts

293 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
This was reported on the radio this morning and they had some Army spokeperson justifying it saying that they can't let the widows live there indefinitely - they have to move out within 90 days and so it was only fair to let them know as soon as possible.

mrs fish

30,018 posts

289 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
I heard this on the news last night it's Fing shocking. It makes me so hearing things like this.

granville

18,764 posts

292 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
Petit Napoleans to a man.

A disgrace of the most damned variety.

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
What will this woman get in the way of compensation/pensions?

I understand they can't just give her a fully funded house, but all the same, surely her husbands life was insured and underwritten by MOD?

>> Edited by CarZee (moderator) on Tuesday 15th April 09:57

madasahatter

374 posts

298 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
So. Our hard earned cash can be taxed in order to fund Speed Cameras, and so that some scrote can go to the Bahamas with his/her careworker for rehabilitation, but we cannot throw a few bob towards a Widow, whose husband died for his country to give her sometime to get over her great loss.

What sort of state is this fing country coming to.

NickD

417 posts

293 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all

CarZee said: What will this woman get in the way of compensation/pensions?

I understand they can't just give her a fully funded house, but all the same, surely her husbands life was insured and underwritten by MOD?



They said that a widow gets £30k whereas in the US the compensation is around £150k. The spokesperson commented that you can't do a comparison as although they are fighting in the same war, they are returning to different countries.

granville

18,764 posts

292 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all

madasahatter said: So. Our hard earned cash can be taxed in order to fund Speed Cameras, and so that some scrote can go to the Bahamas with his/her careworker for rehabilitation, but we cannot throw a few bob towards a Widow, whose husband died for his country to give her sometime to get over her great loss.

What sort of state is this fing country coming to.


B I N G O !!!

eric mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
Apparently this is absolute standard procedure. The widow is allowed stay at the Army/Navy/Air Force accomodation for AT LEAST six months. In reality, they are given as much time as is needed to find new accommodation - usually with MOD assistance.

I think that there is more to this story than is being revealed. I would hazard a guess that all the bereaved families received similar letters (although perhaps better worded) setting out the timetable of what will be happening.

Regarding the "repayment" of the salary. This is also standard - it's just the same in civilian life. Once an individual dies, they can no longer earn a wage, can they? Unlike civilians, however, the war widow's pension should kick in and at least make up some of the shortfall.

I am always sceptical of stories such as this. There is often a hidden adgenda behind the report, whether it be political or financial.

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all

NickD said:They said that a widow gets £30k whereas in the US the compensation is around £150k. The spokesperson commented that you can't do a comparison as although they are fighting in the same war, they are returning to different countries.
tossers.. what he meant is, "In the UK, we don't have any respect for, or pride in, our armed forces, unlike the Americans."

£30k is fcuk all really though - can a soldier actually get his own life assurance policy that will pay out if he's killed in service?

I suspect our dead guys have left behind a lot of significantly disadvantaged single parent families, many of whose lives will be knackered now. One way or another, we'll all pick up the tab - I'd rather stump up a respectable amount in the first place to allow these families a decent chance to start with - or do we have to spend it on repairing these familiy units when they start to disintegrate due to deprivation induced alcoholism, abusive/short-term partners, kids get fcuked up, turn to crack & crime.. brilliant. that way we get to fund the criminal justice system, the women's unit, the NHS and our motor and home insurers.

So, do we wannt give these families the thick end of £150k now or do we want to give them 4 quid and a book of stamps now and end up indirectly picking up the tab for their entire lives?

Cheers then HM Gov!

JMGS4

Original Poster:

8,936 posts

301 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all

NickD said: This was reported on the radio this morning and they had some Army spokeperson justifying it saying that they can't let the widows live there indefinitely - they have to move out within 90 days and so it was only fair to let them know as soon as possible.

Nick it was probably some civilian employee! even the thickest plank, woodentop, skate, remf, or whosit in uniform would have more sense and sensitivity than that. I bet the guys CO or his base team were not informed!!!! Fcuking useless burocrats, should shoot the 'kin lot of them!!!!


Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all


They said that a widow gets £30k whereas in the US the compensation is around £150k. The spokesperson commented that you can't do a comparison as although they are fighting in the same war, they are returning to different countries.


Yeah and the cost of living here is much higher than the US :baghead:

eric mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
I wonder what the family of dead Iraqi soldiers get.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all

eric mc said: I wonder what the family of dead Iraqi soldiers get.


Freedom?

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
I don't mean to sound like an asshole but it will probably come out like that anyway - id agree it sucks but...

An army person joins the army - they aren't levered into it anymore like in the days of Sharpe, even the scrotes get good pay in peacetime and better pay in war time. They also get food and meals etc at a fraction of the cost that normal job bloke on civvy street gets.

If they die on active duty, their spouse gets compensation - i agree the amount seems pretty low, but surely the benefits they get during their life is part of that..?

When my (civvy) dad died last year my mother got nothing, she doesn't even get a widows pension anymore because the government have changed the rules and they no longer exist. WTF did my dad spend 38 of his 55 year life paying national insurance into a state pension, for his wife to be robbed of HIS money?? All my mum got was the house - ok this lady is not going to get the house, but while her husband was alive she was living at a cost far below the rest of us...

I'm torn between agreeing this is shite because it is, but also saying its hard cheese, because they are so many other women (and blokes) going through this that will still get nothing at the end of the day, and thses are still just normal families too. The same month my mum had her pension book ripped up in front of her face (literally) - which was the day after the govenrment brought in the widows pension change, the government also announced an extra something billion pounds aid to assylum seekers - now you try explaining that to a woman who's just lost her husband...!

i would like to know the full story behind this... sometimes a few details are left out whih makes it sound far worse than it need to - did this woman expect to live there for ever? They actually sign a contract that states all this before they move in, its not exactly a surprise.... Maybne the guy that told them this was an insensitive igiot and it came across all wrong.

I know when someone dies you get angry, this woman more so because she perhaps didnt even think her husband should be there, and therefore could have taken a lot of this the wrong way, but really its just standard procedure. Good luck to her anyway

Buffalo

eric mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
Freedom? I think we'll have to wait and see how this pans out.

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Tuesday 15th April 2003
quotequote all
Buffalo, if you have a corporate employer and you're in their pension scheme, you'll find that your life is insured for something like 4x annual salary..

If you have a private pension, I'm not sure but I rather suspect that most of these pay out a not dissimilar figure on death (dependant on contribs etc.).

Yes, soem people get fcuk all, but that doesn't mean that these people should.

I wonder how much life assurance a civil srvant gets as part of their employment & pension package - I bet it's worth a shitload more than 30k.

As regards your point about benefits - well see my previous point - do we want a family which is destroyed from the outset, due to which we'll all pay significant contributions in housing benefit, dole, rehab, prison, borstel etc.. or do we want them to be given a half decent chance?

If you want to be made sick, have a look at the staggering amount of compensation many of the American 11th Septmeber families got - then cross reference that against how much they made from bitching to the media about how $400,000 won't go very far..

>> Edited by CarZee (moderator) on Tuesday 15th April 11:45