Where have all the WOMDs gone? (long time passing)
Discussion
Is it just me who's a little confused about the complete lack of WOMDs (Weapons Of Mass Distraction) in Iraq?
Given that we had to endure Bush and Bliar ramming this 'threat' down our throats as justification for starting a war, I feel a bit let down by the apprarent total lack of any such devices?
I know that there's a lot of Iraq to search, but it doesn't strike me that it's that easy to hide a chemical weapons factory?
Also, Saddam's fighting force must have been on an intensive David Blane/David Copperfield course in illusion and disappearing as they're nowhere to be fonud (unless you go to Syria or course).
Hands up who thinks Bush and Bliar will now start banging on about Syria having WOMDs.
Oh, they already have :rolleyes
Given that we had to endure Bush and Bliar ramming this 'threat' down our throats as justification for starting a war, I feel a bit let down by the apprarent total lack of any such devices?
I know that there's a lot of Iraq to search, but it doesn't strike me that it's that easy to hide a chemical weapons factory?
Also, Saddam's fighting force must have been on an intensive David Blane/David Copperfield course in illusion and disappearing as they're nowhere to be fonud (unless you go to Syria or course).
Hands up who thinks Bush and Bliar will now start banging on about Syria having WOMDs.
Oh, they already have :rolleyes
Good question.
Reading this report www.globalsecurity.org/org/news/2003/030415-syria01.htm
It could be that they have all been shipped into Syria.
On the other hand it still could be burried in on of the many miles of tunnels there is in Iraq
Reading this report www.globalsecurity.org/org/news/2003/030415-syria01.htm
It could be that they have all been shipped into Syria.
On the other hand it still could be burried in on of the many miles of tunnels there is in Iraq
Its not too far fetched to believe that Saddy Hussein shipped all his goodies out to Syria or other regimes that have taken a stance with Iraq, mainly in opposition to the US.
What's the problem with attacking Syria anyway. Its a dictatorship where power is maintained by force of arms like all dictatorships.
As the saying goes "live by the sword-die by the sword". The US will just be acting in accordance with the rules of the dictator.
Its a bit rich for a dictator to start moaning that the US have no right to start waving the guns about when that is exactly what dictators have to do to maintian power.
What's the problem with attacking Syria anyway. Its a dictatorship where power is maintained by force of arms like all dictatorships.
As the saying goes "live by the sword-die by the sword". The US will just be acting in accordance with the rules of the dictator.
Its a bit rich for a dictator to start moaning that the US have no right to start waving the guns about when that is exactly what dictators have to do to maintian power.
I think in almost every definition of the term we can say that the liberation (see invasion) of Iraq failed its primary objective which was to find and destroy Saddams WOMD.
Sure the Iraqi people have an subjectively speaking better quality of life but as far as the justification to spend all this money on a war that no one really wanted well there is none.
Make no mistake this is a world tour and Bush will drag us through the mire until he has his way. Which will be the hub to a grandiose wheel of capitolism spanning the globe. They will only be truly happy once they have converted China I am sure...
Matt.
Sure the Iraqi people have an subjectively speaking better quality of life but as far as the justification to spend all this money on a war that no one really wanted well there is none.
Make no mistake this is a world tour and Bush will drag us through the mire until he has his way. Which will be the hub to a grandiose wheel of capitolism spanning the globe. They will only be truly happy once they have converted China I am sure...
Matt.
Indeed, the Iraqi people do now have a better quality of life.
Well, at least they've got some nice furniture, hospital incubators, generators and suchlike littering their homes now
I know it's the minority that are looting, but how stupid can you get?
Not to mention the bunfight that's going to ensue now that they're trying to install a new authority to run the country. I gather that a leading muslim party have already boycotted the talks as the Americans are running them.
Out of one regime, into another.
Well, at least they've got some nice furniture, hospital incubators, generators and suchlike littering their homes now
I know it's the minority that are looting, but how stupid can you get?
Not to mention the bunfight that's going to ensue now that they're trying to install a new authority to run the country. I gather that a leading muslim party have already boycotted the talks as the Americans are running them.
Out of one regime, into another.
Also, Saddam's fighting force must have been on an intensive David Blane/David Copperfield course in illusion and disappearing as they're nowhere to be fonud (unless you go to Syria or course).
[BillHicks]
...But we were yet to meet the ELITE REPUBLICAN GUARD
After 2 weeks of continuous carpet bombing, they became known as the REPUBLICAN GUARD - not quite so elite afterall.
After a further 2 weeks of Carpet bombing they became known as the "Who made this s
t up about there being Republican Guards anyway?" [/BillHicks]
Edited to fake URL Tags
>> Edited by madasahatter on Tuesday 15th April 11:01
There could be lots on the 3-6 Iraqi tankers that have been sailing international waters for the last umpteen months without going anywhere.
Our governments still don't really know what to do about 'em - if they really do have WOMD, then storming them is likely to cause the crew to either try to use 'em or dump 'em. (Both bad things)
Also means that sinking them out of hand is out of the question....
Our governments still don't really know what to do about 'em - if they really do have WOMD, then storming them is likely to cause the crew to either try to use 'em or dump 'em. (Both bad things)
Also means that sinking them out of hand is out of the question....
Nice call on the Bill Hicks quote.. I could spend all day postulating on what the great man would have made of the present conflict....
one other thing regarding the whereabouts of WMDs... whatever happened regarding those three dubious frieght vessels loitering in the Persian gulf - did we ever find out whose those were and what they had on board?
one other thing regarding the whereabouts of WMDs... whatever happened regarding those three dubious frieght vessels loitering in the Persian gulf - did we ever find out whose those were and what they had on board?
CraigAlsop said: There could be lots on the 3-6 Iraqi tankers that have been sailing international waters for the last umpteen months without going anywhere.
Our governments still don't really know what to do about 'em - if they really do have WOMD, then storming them is likely to cause the crew to either try to use 'em or dump 'em. (Both bad things)
Also means that sinking them out of hand is out of the question....
I think the US dolphins are keeping an eye on them.
Our forces still believe there is a fair chance that they contain WOMD.
CarZee said: one other thing regarding the whereabouts of WMDs... whatever happened regarding those three dubious freight vessels loitering in the Persian gulf - did we ever find out whose those were and what they had on board?
Mind you, this is from a source that predicted the Gulf war would start a month earlier than it did (to the day), so your mileage may vary...
CarZee said: Nice call on the Bill Hicks quote.. I could spend all day postulating on what the great man would have made of the present conflict....
one other thing regarding the whereabouts of WMDs... whatever happened regarding those three dubious frieght vessels loitering in the Persian gulf - did we ever find out whose those were and what they had on board?
You've just reminded me of another of Hicks' quotes...."The Persian Gulf distraction" LMAO.
Votes Flagging? Popularity Dwindling? Have a war instead.....
How refreshing to find a thread on PH that isn't of the 'Kill an Argie - Win a metro' school of politics. Some of us said from the very beginning that there was no justification for this war other than the toppling of an oppressive regime. I'm betting that they do 'find' some WOMD, but don't look too closely at the 'Made in...' stickers. Oh, and from the start, Tony told us that there were very good reasons which he couldn't tell us why we needed to go to war. Now we've won, any chance of letting us in on the secret?
The thing that worries me most is not that Saddam is gone - good riddance - but that it was George W Bush Junior who decided to do it, on what seems to have been a whim. Who else doesn't he like? The French. Will he invade? We can only hope...
The thing that worries me most is not that Saddam is gone - good riddance - but that it was George W Bush Junior who decided to do it, on what seems to have been a whim. Who else doesn't he like? The French. Will he invade? We can only hope...
WOMD or not. Who cares? Bush/Blair used WOMD as a political tool, didn't work so they changed tack to another ie moral reasons. Just as the French and other opposers to the war used the old anti-war political tool. They are all tools. All politicians are liars.Period.
So far the actions of the US/UK have been as they said they would. Minimal civilian casualties, and military casualties for that matter.
The measure of this campaign will now be determined by their forthcoming actions, particularly how long it takes to get law and order back in place and a hand over to civilian democratic leadership.
It does sound like some of the anti-war supporters are a bit miffed things have gone so well considering its war, and are looking for criticism where there shouldn't be any.
So far the actions of the US/UK have been as they said they would. Minimal civilian casualties, and military casualties for that matter.
The measure of this campaign will now be determined by their forthcoming actions, particularly how long it takes to get law and order back in place and a hand over to civilian democratic leadership.
It does sound like some of the anti-war supporters are a bit miffed things have gone so well considering its war, and are looking for criticism where there shouldn't be any.
Worth bearing in mind that chemical weapons are extremely simple bits of kit to assemble. No reason to suppose you'd have a wearhouse of ready-to-go weapons sitting around waiting for an arms inspector to stroll in and find. If chemical weapons are going to be found, I suspect it will be in the form of a cache of oil drums in one place, some odd looking artillery shells somewhere else, maybe some empty missile warheads.
It is too early to expect anyone to have found any evidence yet either one way or the other. As happened under the UN inspections programmes, this kind of materiel is only likely to be found when Iraqis lead the coalition or UN to it.
I think it is pretty clear that the US engineered an ultimatum that would allow them to depose Saddam Hussein. As such the precise timing of this war was arbitrary as was the pretext. But that itsn't the same thing as saying it was on a whim or was unnecessary. The preceding "containment" policy could not go on forever, as it was only containing SH partially and at the expense of the considerable suffering of the Iraqi population, it was forcing the US and UK to maintain the no-fly zones, and the interim Kurdish "state" in the north was becoming more an more deeply established which was scaring the pants off the Turkish army.
Given that Saddam Hussein was never going to become a reformed character and that it is extremely unlikely that he could ever have been deposed by the Iraqis themselves, some form of drastic international intervention at some point in the future was inevitable.
It really then comes down to an arguement about timing, backing and expected consequences. The protestors on the streets are primarily concerned about shortterm civilan death which is obviously a legitimate concern. I doubt though that the French, German or Russian governments are significantly more concerned about that than the US or British governments. The intergovernmental arguement has primarily been about the likely implication for the development of the Middle East. Does this action make it more or less likely that fundamentalist revolution occurs in other countries and that we manage to conjour up a real strategic threat, not the kind of Mickey Mouse threat that Iraq currently posed?
It seems fairly clear that the anti-war governments think the US is opening a can of worms it can't control. The US view is that the Middle East already is an open can of worms and that without some intervention the region is already on course to go to hell. They are gambling that their intervention will be swallowed in the short-term by the region, and will then become an example of a new form of Arab government that will destabilise the existing regimes, but will do so positively as the Solidarity movement in Poland did, acting as the catalyst for a chain reaction throughout Eastern Europe.
Well, the die is cast. Let us hope they don't arse up post-war Iraq and that they remember to press the Israelis and Palestinians to a settlement in spite of the US political cycle.
It is too early to expect anyone to have found any evidence yet either one way or the other. As happened under the UN inspections programmes, this kind of materiel is only likely to be found when Iraqis lead the coalition or UN to it.
I think it is pretty clear that the US engineered an ultimatum that would allow them to depose Saddam Hussein. As such the precise timing of this war was arbitrary as was the pretext. But that itsn't the same thing as saying it was on a whim or was unnecessary. The preceding "containment" policy could not go on forever, as it was only containing SH partially and at the expense of the considerable suffering of the Iraqi population, it was forcing the US and UK to maintain the no-fly zones, and the interim Kurdish "state" in the north was becoming more an more deeply established which was scaring the pants off the Turkish army.
Given that Saddam Hussein was never going to become a reformed character and that it is extremely unlikely that he could ever have been deposed by the Iraqis themselves, some form of drastic international intervention at some point in the future was inevitable.
It really then comes down to an arguement about timing, backing and expected consequences. The protestors on the streets are primarily concerned about shortterm civilan death which is obviously a legitimate concern. I doubt though that the French, German or Russian governments are significantly more concerned about that than the US or British governments. The intergovernmental arguement has primarily been about the likely implication for the development of the Middle East. Does this action make it more or less likely that fundamentalist revolution occurs in other countries and that we manage to conjour up a real strategic threat, not the kind of Mickey Mouse threat that Iraq currently posed?
It seems fairly clear that the anti-war governments think the US is opening a can of worms it can't control. The US view is that the Middle East already is an open can of worms and that without some intervention the region is already on course to go to hell. They are gambling that their intervention will be swallowed in the short-term by the region, and will then become an example of a new form of Arab government that will destabilise the existing regimes, but will do so positively as the Solidarity movement in Poland did, acting as the catalyst for a chain reaction throughout Eastern Europe.
Well, the die is cast. Let us hope they don't arse up post-war Iraq and that they remember to press the Israelis and Palestinians to a settlement in spite of the US political cycle.
Could it be that there were no WMD's left at all? After all, Scott Ritter (former head of UNSCOM inspectors) has said on many occasions that he believed the Iraqi threat was now non existant and all their WMD programs had been destroyed/stopped. Added to that, on the first morning of the war when those missiles struck Kuwait, there was an interview with some resonably high ranking military personnel catagorically stating that they werent Scuds but Al-Samoods, strangley that interview never resurfaced. Could it be that they didn't have any Scuds left at all? Surely the first thing he would have done would be to fire them at Israel in a 1991 Gulf War stylee.
If coalition forces had taken out Scud missiles/launchers etc, why wasnt it used for some great media/propaganda exersise to point out that they were in Breach of UN resolutions?
Dont get me wrong, Saddam Hussiens regime had to go, I just think the resons for doing it were highly suspicious if you ask me. Nothing to do with oil guvnor, or the Bush-Cheney oil and gas junta.
If coalition forces had taken out Scud missiles/launchers etc, why wasnt it used for some great media/propaganda exersise to point out that they were in Breach of UN resolutions?
Dont get me wrong, Saddam Hussiens regime had to go, I just think the resons for doing it were highly suspicious if you ask me. Nothing to do with oil guvnor, or the Bush-Cheney oil and gas junta.
Wow, the anti-war crowd is so scared they will be shown wrong, they are already creating the excuses. We attacked Iraq only weeks ago, and already we hear the harping about no WMDs yet. They're there and they'll find them. But the fighting in the major cities only ended yesterday.
Nor are these things easy to find. Saddam's had twelve years to perfect the art of concealment. Give it time.
Not that it'll matter anyways, you anti-war folks are already insinuating that if any WMD are found, they will be planted by the US. Do you think the US would ever even risk being caught by a foreign intel srvice (such as the Russians) moving WMD from here to Iraq?
Anyways, the anti-war crowd, who accused us supporters of blindly following like lemmings, are now showing true colors by sowing the seeds of doubt.
Mike
Nor are these things easy to find. Saddam's had twelve years to perfect the art of concealment. Give it time.
Not that it'll matter anyways, you anti-war folks are already insinuating that if any WMD are found, they will be planted by the US. Do you think the US would ever even risk being caught by a foreign intel srvice (such as the Russians) moving WMD from here to Iraq?
Anyways, the anti-war crowd, who accused us supporters of blindly following like lemmings, are now showing true colors by sowing the seeds of doubt.
Mike
>you anti-war folks are already insinuating that if any WMD are found, they will be planted by the US.<
Mind you, the British government did fraudulently produce several documents about countries who were alledgedy involved with Iraq for nuclear weapons purposes, even the UN turned round and said they'd been faked.
I wouldn't put it past ANY government to plant/fake things to their own ends, not just the US/UK administrations, Although I'd be first to admit it does seem somewhat far fetched to suggest it would happen. Just not immposible! All I'm really saying is thats theres far more to the whole situation than meets the eye. It's been sold to the public as 'George and Tonys' big day out in Baghdad' to free the Iraqis but I just don't believe this is the reason for them doing it, thats all!
I'm certainly not a US bashing anti-war campaigner. I happen to like americans, just not the administration, mind you, I'm from the UK and I have equal contempt for the Bliar government.....
Mind you, the British government did fraudulently produce several documents about countries who were alledgedy involved with Iraq for nuclear weapons purposes, even the UN turned round and said they'd been faked.
I wouldn't put it past ANY government to plant/fake things to their own ends, not just the US/UK administrations, Although I'd be first to admit it does seem somewhat far fetched to suggest it would happen. Just not immposible! All I'm really saying is thats theres far more to the whole situation than meets the eye. It's been sold to the public as 'George and Tonys' big day out in Baghdad' to free the Iraqis but I just don't believe this is the reason for them doing it, thats all!
I'm certainly not a US bashing anti-war campaigner. I happen to like americans, just not the administration, mind you, I'm from the UK and I have equal contempt for the Bliar government.....
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



