RAF sued for noise nuisance
RAF sued for noise nuisance
Author
Discussion

mad jock

Original Poster:

1,272 posts

293 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
A judge has awarded £950,000 to a Lincolnshire farmer in compensation for the noise from RAF Harriers which operate from a nearby airbase. The only justice in this case is that they only got £950,000 instaed of the £9 million that they wanted.
How long have they lived there, and were they not aware that jet fighters might be a little noisy near an airbase?
They claim that it prevented them from having shooting parties and fashion shoots, and upset their enjoyment of their property, and affected the market value. I suppose that they got it cheap in the first place, then?
Where are the Yanks and some "friendly fire" when you need it?

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Yet another example of country, hell, handbasket.

Matt.

FourWheelDrift

92,401 posts

315 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all

A judge has awarded £950,000 to a Lincolnshire farmer in compensation for the noise from RAF Harriers which operate from a nearby airbase. The only justice in this case is that they only got £950,000 instaed of the £9 million that they wanted.
How long have they lived there, and were they not aware that jet fighters might be a little noisy near an airbase?
They claim that it prevented them from having shooting parties and fashion shoots, and upset their enjoyment of their property, and affected the market value. I suppose that they got it cheap in the first place, then?
Where are the Yanks and some "friendly fire" when you need it?


They sound like "Nouveau fermiers" probably bought the land after selling their 4 bed London townhouse for 50 times what they paid for it, expecting to become Landed Gentry...!!!! I mean "Shooting parties" and Fashion shoots" FFS Have Edina & Patsy moved in here!

Harriers should use their property for target practice, or whoops I seem to have accidentily dropped my ordanance on their house

>> Edited by FourWheelDrift on Wednesday 16th April 13:36

swilly

9,699 posts

305 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
I wonder what RAF pilots returning from the Gulf will think of this.

Regular midnight low-level fly-by's are in order i think.

eric mc

125,939 posts

296 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Maybe an "accidently" dropped munition might be in order.

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all

Nah this story has more to it. They've owned the place for generations, and the usage of the base radically changed IIRC.

Think they probably deserved this one...

ehasler

8,579 posts

314 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Didn't the guy move there in 1963? I think the gist of the case is that the noise prevents them from hosting events at the building, and it's this loss of income that they are suing for (about £2million a year apparently)

agent006

12,058 posts

295 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Yes, for once i agree with the judgement. Fair enough if it was an 80s semi, but the house outdates the aeroplane let a lone the harrier.

fish

4,064 posts

313 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
True story:

A certain Mr Jones in north wales painted piss off biggles in 15" letters on the roof of his barn as the constant passing of Hawk jets was annoying him. They mainly used the building as a visual ref point when returning to Valley.

So now everyone used it to see the writing. It eventually made it into the unoffical familtrip route.


Needless to say eventually he painted it out due to the increased noise etc.

Mad Jock

Original Poster:

1,272 posts

293 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
I'm sorry, but this judgement opens up a whole can of worms. The whole of Islington could complain about 747's etc flying over them when landing. And Islington was around before Heathrow was an airport. I have friends who own a huge estate just to the west of Edinburgh Airport, about 400m off the flight path. They still have shooting parties and other corporate days, and it never crossed their minds to sue BAA. And Edinburgh Airport is not used "in the interests of national security" at all. Well, perhaps a little bit. I know of farmers around Leuchars in Fife, Lossiemouth, and I'm sure that the rest of you know of others. Not a peep out of them. If he can make as much as £2 million a year from his endeavours, I am sure that a move would have seemed profitable.
Jesus, no Grouse moore in Scotland is safe from low flying Tornados and Harriers and Jaguars, not to mention the very noisy F15's that occasionally dash themselves to pieces on the mountainside. I've yet to hear of a single Laird bitching about it, or the Ghillies.
If his family have lived there for "generations", I'll bet his Grandad was one of the people complaining about the Dam Busters practicing for their mission.
I would also like to see any piece of property in Lincolnshire with a value of £13 million, let alone one next to a noisy RAF base.
If they did move there in 1963, then he was next to an operational airbase even then. I hope the RAF appeal.

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
I used to live by an active airbase and i actually reallly miss the noise of jets flying over

Also Santa Pod raceway is just up the road from my paretns place, i love going back at the weekends and hearing the dragsters flying up the strip, fantastic noise!!

Do get a bit of jonathan palmer every now and agin which is ok, but not a patch on those nitrous v8!!

CraigAlsop

1,991 posts

299 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
I have friends who manage a large estate up North West Scotland - they get lots of fast jets flying low level over them & still manage to host shooting/fishing parties.
They tend to think the jets are "cool"

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
The worst thing that ever happened in my home town was when Hatfield aerodrome was closed. The free yearly airshows were fantastic.

tvradict

3,829 posts

305 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
FFS!!

The base won't have changed that much in the last 40 years! Before the Harrier the RAF were using the Hunter and that is a noisy bugger!

It's this Americanised-sue-for-shutting-your-finger-in-the-car-ddor-because-the-manufacturer-didn't-warn-you-it-could-happen mentality and it pisses me right off!

And since when did an AIRBORNE Harrier effect a FUCKING Fashion shoot?!?!?!

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
More to the point, what self respecting tweed wearing, welly boot kitted out, string holding up the trousers type farmer be doing holding a fashion show for in the first place???

Unless of course it was for cattle and then should this type of activity be reported in a family newspaper..?

mrsd

1,502 posts

284 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
F me ! Losing £2m income a year ! Lucky if our land turns over £2m a year nowadays Maybe it's time to get into fashion shoots 'sweetie, darling look out for that sheep sh1t'. Oops, too late

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all

fish said: A certain Mr Jones in north wales painted piss off biggles in 15" letters on the roof of his barn as the constant passing of Hawk jets was annoying him.
Indeed - I remember reading about this.. similarly, when I lived in south-east London, I got so sick of the police helicopters and their search lights (attic flat, velux windows) that with the help of a DTP package and about half a ream of paper, erected a sign on the roof saying "Fcuk off pigs - Let the people sleep!!"

Perhaps not clever in hindsight, but I'd been lead to believe that this was routine patrol rather than some kind of hot pursuit, so I kicked off by letter and got no response. Helicopters soon became a more rarified sight though. I gather one of the last to pass by belonged to a media outlet.

MoJocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
What airbase is it??

The base won't have changed that much in the last 40 years! Before the Harrier the RAF were using the Hunter and that is a noisy bugger!

If it's wittering then NO WAY it's always been harriers BUT if it's cottesmore then fair enough. The problem isn't the actual noise level but the fact that the harrier takes so much more time to clear the local area thus seems to make more noise overall.
They had the same problem at laarbruch when it went from tornadoes (NOT QUIET) to harriers.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
It's Wittering.

So's the complainant....................

FourWheelDrift

92,401 posts

315 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
A Konb from the UK Noise Abatement Society has just been on the news, he was introduced as someone who has brought cases against a number of airports (so a troublemaker then!)

He suggested that if the RAF do not change their flight plans and number of flights they should think about relocating the airfield !!!! FFS

How about a cruise down to the HQ of the Noise Abatement society (de-catted cars only).