Where do I stand ?????
Author
Discussion

rlk500

Original Poster:

917 posts

283 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
I recently purchased an E46 Touring. The car has surpassed my expectations. I had it delivered to my house by the dealer. It was filthy when it arrived as it had sat on the back of a transporter from Scotland. I signed the delivery note and the transporter driver disappeared.

Only after did I notice that there was paint damage to the roof rails and a small scratch on the roof, which was not apparent until I washed the car, 4 days later.

I had informed the dealer of the roof rail damage and then made another phone call when I discovered the roof scratch.

I had noticed when the car was on the transporter that the roof/rails were quite close to the upper level of the transporter. However, you assume these people now how to load cars and I left the chap to unload the car as it was pouring with rain.

Now I realise I made a rookie error in not making a thorough exam of the car before the delivery driver left but he was in a hurry and didn't want to hang around. Even if I had, I doubt I would have spottted the roof scratch as this was not evident until I washed the car.

The upshot of all this is that the dealer has washed their hands of it as have the transport company. The repairs are minor to say the least and I will sort them myself but I am very dissapointed, basically they are intimating that I damaged the car and am trying to pull a fast one.

I am pretty sure that the delivery note is not a legally binding indication that you have examined the car unless you are given sufficient time to do so.

Anyone got any wisdom on the situation. I am certainly going to persue this through the dealer, BMW GB and my Solicitor.

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
What you have there is a case of transporter rash. Its quite common believe it or not and can be caused by the tie straps rubbing whilst in transit which is not something thats easy to spot at load time.

You signed the delivery note which was an indication of satisfaction with the condition of the vehicle as delivered (I assume there was one of them flattened out car things on the manifest?), if there was no damage indicated on there then as far as the dealer is concerned there was no damage.

The only possible mitigating circumstances are that you were rushed by the driver and the weather was incliment.

A stern letter to BMW GB should coax them into instructing their dealer network to rectify this FOC as a goodwill gesture I would have thought.

Matt.

dozeville

124 posts

287 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Send E-Mail to BMW Munich.....amazing how fast things move then. Had problems with my Beemer motorcycle and after no joy with the only BMW Dealership in London for days and then weeks and who sold me the bike got full joy and compensation inside one hour together with apologies etc.... Maybe worth a try.