hi fi Speakers repair / replace ?
hi fi Speakers repair / replace ?
Author
Discussion

Farmer

Original Poster:

1,287 posts

305 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
On re-vamping the decor in our lounge recently Mrs Farmer decided to remove the punched metal Grilles on my beloved Gale GS 301's and attack 15 years of dust with a Dyson ....result , Dyson 1 - Gale 0. the Vac tore a big chunk out of the delicate foam edge that joins the cone to the frame of the main driver
my question is , do I replace the driver ( if so where do i source the driver cheaply )? do I leave it alone and probably never notice the difference ? Bodge it up with PVA and gaffer tape ? junk them and get some new speakers cus they are cheaper nowadays ? Junk the wife (probably not the cheapest option )?

julianhj

8,871 posts

293 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Get yerself some B&W's - they beat the competition into the dust! Prices start from £200...

wedg1e

27,044 posts

296 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
I use B&W DM4's... made in 1974 and still going strong! They are a bit bass-light by modern standards but they can handle power well in excess of thir rating. Built like brick-outhouses too.

Ian

Marshy

2,751 posts

315 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
I'd agree that B&Ws seem good. A few years back I was in the market for some floorstanders, and the DM305s, to my ears, were the most rounded speaker at that price when compared to most other well known brands.

I've got some much older standmount B&Ws at the rear for surround sound... and I find that I really don't have a major need for a sub. Which isn't to say that I wouldn't mind one...

jmorgan

36,010 posts

315 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Not familiar with this make but having had the currant pair for 20 years and happy. Tried the maker for a replacement or am I teaching granny etc?

mrsd

1,502 posts

284 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
At risk of stating the obvious, why not try Gale and see how much a repair would be ? IIRC Richer Sounds are the UK distributor.

5ltr-chim

635 posts

288 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all

The way to do a repair on a speaker cone is paint the tear with nail varnish believe it or not - and unless you've got v.good hearing and listen mainly to classical you'd probably not notice the degredation in quality.

DennisTheMenace

15,605 posts

299 months

Wednesday 16th April 2003
quotequote all
Ive got a set of Cerwin Vegas on my bedroom stereo and they thump big style , the heighbours love them down stairs ive got a sony amp and cd deck running through a set of floorstanding mordaunt shorts and they sound amazing very clear the tv rdvd etc runs through a sony 5 .1 channel decoder and a misson 5.1 system 5 little speakers for surround centre channel and a nice 10" boxed sub hiding in the corner

Farmer

Original Poster:

1,287 posts

305 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all

mrsd said: At risk of stating the obvious, why not try Gale and see how much a repair would be ? IIRC Richer Sounds are the UK distributor.




I understand that the Gale that Richer sell is actualy thier own brand, as Gale went out of buisness several years ago but I will try them.

Thanks one and all , at least it looks like I'm keeping the missus

rjo

879 posts

302 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Hi-Fi is one of my interests and I have several pairs of speakers in my house (Klipsch, Tannoy, Sonab, Leak).
If you find that it is impossible or expensive to replace the speaker then look for speaker repairers in you phone book. They can replace the suspension and it should be as good as new if done properly. You will probably find that the suspension is ready to go in the other speaker as well and if you do one, then you might have to do both at the same time. That may be the case if it comes to repairing them, as it will probably be hard to match the suspension material exactly. Though sometimes the suspension or cone may fail in only one driver, usually due to something such as having a speaker place in sunlight or next to a heater.
I could be wrong, I don't know the situation in the UK, but it is worth considering.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
As much as you might love them... technology has moved on... buy something reasonable and you'll probably get a better sound...

icamm

2,153 posts

291 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
I agree with Podie. I would also say DO NOT listen to anyone else's opinion. Hi-Fi sound is very subjective and very much a personal taste thing. Also as manufacturers upgrade models they can lose the sound that people with older version of their kit like.

Pick a budget and goto a good Hi-Fi store with listening rooms. Book a session telling them what you want, ie to listen to speakers that cost no more than £XXX. The, if possible, arrange to take your CD player and amp (unless yours are new then I doubt they will have anything that sounds similar) and test the speakers with your favourite CD's.

The reason to take your own kit is that how a speaker sounds very much depends on what it is given. One amp may match something like B&W and another might match better with Mission. The last thing you want is to spend time testing speakers to find they sound different, and possibly awful, on your system when you get home.

NB: If you pick the right price point, and live fairly close, the shop might well lend you several sets to test at home.

>> Edited by icamm on Thursday 17th April 12:32

cammers

396 posts

299 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
My current set-up includes B&W CDM NT speakers and Musical Fidelity A3 series CD and Amplifier.
Although in my opinion an excellent system, I'll soon be putting the whole lot on E-Bay, to put towards my craving for a Meridian DVD player!
The speakers, if anyone's interested, are- B&W CDM 7NT fronts, CDM SNT surrounds, a CDM CNT centre and a REL sub!