tazer video
Author
Discussion

tim_s

Original Poster:

299 posts

285 months

Dick Dastardly

8,326 posts

294 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Ha ha. Would be good for keeping the scallies/jehovahs away from my house. Do you reckon I'll be able to pick one of these up from a Police auction anytime soon?

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
I can see how having one of these for what the Americans call "Home Defence" could save lives. After all - if the alternative is let loose with your shotgun these things are significantly less lethal.

They're also a lot less effective. Looked to me like the bugger could have got up again pretty quick. And after that he'll be angry....

Use a real gun and he won't be anything. Anymore. Ever.

madcop

6,649 posts

294 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
I have just done my taser training. It is a very useful and effective peice of kit. It has plenty of safegaurds against misuse, including a memory of activation which can be downloaded by the relevant software programmes. There has also been a huge cash investment in the safety of the device. The British police service has not taken the USA Police policy and guidance for use themselves but have added extra safeguards on its use.

I have seen it demonstrated for real. It works and leaves the target uninjured apart from two small dart holes where the taser strikes (which are ultimately much better than two 9mm holes which is the alternative). Whilst the taser darts are in contact with the subject the charge is activated immediately but can be manually stopped before it has delivered the full 5 seconds of 50,000 volts.

If the subject still fails to comply with instructions or removes the darts him/herself then the device can be re-activated from 20 feet back giving another blast of 50,000 volts if it is still attached or alternatively the subject is shot again with a cartridge that is taken from the underside of the pistol grip of the weapon and attached to the front firing point of the taser when the original cartridge has been discarded.

There is no lasting injury other than the two holes from the darts which are two number eight barbed fishing hooks straightened out. The darts are removed by a Police surgeon once the subject is at the custody station (in the USA the Police officer firing the darts removes them at the scene).

Any use of force against someone who is non compliant and dangerous regardless of what that method is has some degree of risk attached to it to both the subject and the officer. So far, this device has shown to have the least record of injury to either the subject or the Police officers invovled in the incident. In my view it is the way forward and will certainly result in instances of offenders with chair legs in bags being spared their lives!

DennisTheMenace

15,605 posts

299 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Can you jump start cars with it

FourWheelDrift

92,400 posts

315 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
start here www.iairguns.com/airtaserstungun/ to find your local friendly armourment supplier.

nmlowe

1,666 posts

298 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
What sort of person volunteers for the demonstration of these things?(double-'ard, me thinks) I noticed that the bloke in the clip didn't seem to be carrying out any criminal activity (carrying chair-legs etc)?
Did he agree to be tested, or was he just someone who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time?
In which case, that'll teach him for not being at work!

madcop

6,649 posts

294 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all

nmlowe said: What sort of person volunteers for the demonstration of these things?(double-'ard, me thinks)



A couple of our firearms instructors have had the dose from Taser. They say it is not nice when it hits but afterwards there is a feeling of calmness which overcomes the body
Rodney King (the LAPD punch bag was shot with Taser before he got his beasting but only with the 7 Watt version which was not powerful enough to do the deed. The new version is 26 watt and certainly is )

ATG

23,872 posts

303 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
looks like a great idea to me. Amnesty International were reported as saying the thing wasn't necessarily safe. Is this just the Press trying to stir? Can't believe Amnesty would really be whining about Tazers when the alternative is being shot.

JMGS4

8,936 posts

301 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
The Tazer was tried by various police forces on the continent (D, NL, F, CH). It is lethal (the 25watt version) to anyone who may have a heart condition, definitely lethal for anyone with a pacemaker, and can be a killer for anyone whose heartbeat is "in anomaly" especially through use of drugs (can't remember the name but the one which gives them "superhuman" strength!) It is BANNED in Europe by an EU parliament comittee due to its expected lethality!!! so expect the Police to be subject of an ECHR case if they try to use it!
IMHO it's certainly better than a 9mm or .357 stop, but it has inherant dangers which I'm sure madcop has been trained in/on????

nmlowe

1,666 posts

298 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
About the heart thing, what sort of old-age-pensioner would you use it on anyway?, or maybe its a warning against using it on someone who is clinically...obice..obece..er..fat??

ultimasimon

9,646 posts

289 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all

JMGS4 said: The Tazer was tried by various police forces on the continent (D, NL, F, CH). It is lethal (the 25watt version) to anyone who may have a heart condition, definitely lethal for anyone with a pacemaker, and can be a killer for anyone whose heartbeat is "in anomaly" especially through use of drugs (can't remember the name but the one which gives them "superhuman" strength!) It is BANNED in Europe by an EU parliament comittee due to its expected lethality!!! so expect the Police to be subject of an ECHR case if they try to use it!
IMHO it's certainly better than a 9mm or .357 stop, but it has inherant dangers which I'm sure madcop has been trained in/on????


Granted, but if an assailant did have a heart attack, all police officers have been trained in first aid and re-suss, so the chances are that they would be able to bring them back.

I say - Live by the sword, die by the sword. You always have a choice.

AJLintern

4,397 posts

294 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
What if the pins hit you in the eyes? Would 50kv make them go pop?
nasty

CraigAlsop

1,991 posts

299 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
I think the worry is that police will start using it as a precaution, rather than a response (as has happened a couple of times in USA IIRC)

When police use guns, they know they are using deadly force, but when they use tasers, they believe that it will cause no harm - this is obviously a problem to anyone with a heart problem that has been zapped "just-in-case"

There is an article in the New Scientist 15th Feb 2003 which discusses the taser introduction to UK. In this, the Taser instructors suggest that the Taser was "good for demonstrators" too, including "tree huggers" and those shouting "hell no, we won't go", and also emotionally disturbed people.
They also advocate "early, aggressive use"

At a taser conference police officers at the conference only had to complete a written test in order to become approved Taser instructors. A copy of the test with answers was included in the course notes

So I personally have a fair amount of disquiet about this introduction - especially as there have been some medical tests which are less sanguine about the effects on people (according to same article)

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all

ultimasimon said: Granted, but if an assailant did have a heart attack, all police officers have been trained in first aid and re-suss, so the chances are that they would be able to bring them back.
Too right they would - it's no fun beating the crap out of a dead guy in the back of the paddy wagon

Seriously though, I'm concerned about talk of these things being used as a precaution rather than a necessary last resort. I hope the rules for Taser use here are interpreted by all according to the spirit intended.

I'm disappointed though, with MadCop's limp wristed live and let live attitude toward those in posession of a chair leg - anyone in posession of a chair leg is clearly a terrorist and should accordingly be shown no mercy. If you coppers kept your eyes open for chair legs and the like - particularly when searching suspects' homes - you'd get a lot more bloody results!!!

Oh well, my paper-thin faith in humanity is tested to the limit and beyond once again

>> Edited by CarZee (moderator) on Friday 18th April 12:27

moleamol

15,887 posts

294 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all

AJLintern said: What if the pins hit you in the eyes? Would 50kv make them go pop?
nasty
Probably not, but pulling barbed hook jobbies out of them might not be much fun

madcop

6,649 posts

294 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
The use of Taser is only given authority when the option for firearms has already been given. It is a seperate authority and at the present time will only be used in conjunction with firearms at such incidents requiring the deployment of firearms. It will not be given authority for use without the first authority for firearms response.

The problem Police have at present is that if someone whom is obviously very dangerous at a particular point in an incident either to other people, Police in attendance or themselves, the present policy and guidelines do not allow for the Police to use deadly force if they are purely non compliant to instruction. The options at the moment to resolve a problem of non compliance are to continue to contain the person. To use other control methods such as baton strikes or CS deployment or to send in a Police dog to deal with the problem. Police dogs are trained to stand off and not attack a person that is standing still. If at this point the subject has a weapon such as a blade or club of some sort, the dog is likely to get injured as is a Police officer having to get close to deploy baton or CS strikes.

Armed Police are not permitted to use deadly force unless they perceive an immediate like threat to themselves or someone else. If a person is holding a weapon and is not doing as he/she is told but slowly starts to walk away from the containment, the only method at present is to risk injury to those Police on the containment to stop the subject by physical intervention. You cannot shoot someone in the back! (or the front if they are pointing the weapon skywards).

Taser allows the option of dealing with an armed suspect from a positive reaction distance (21 feet). Taser will never be deployed against a subject who is holding a firearm as the resulting muscle spasm and paralysis including falling to the floor is likely to see a discharge of the firearm due to the lack of control from the suspect. Firearms will still be dealt with by firearms officers until they are no longer a threat.

Those suspected of being in immediate possession of a firearm and who do not comply as long as it is not in their hand at the time are likley to be Tasered.

With regard to the worries about pacemakers and those with dodgy hearts, all the research to date (and there has been a huge amount of this done) shows that the deployment of Taser has no effect on the function of the pacemaker or the heart rythem. No one has died as a direct result of being tasered. There have been deaths of people who have been tasered but not as a result of the application of that method of controlling them. They have died from other unrelated circumstances or problems.

I have seen this work at first hand recently and it is a good piece of kit. When the trials have finished there may be wider distribution of the equipment for use other than at firearms incidents.

When Police officers were issued with CS sprays, there were huge concerns that they would be widely misused and abused. That has turned out not to be the case.
Personally I have carried CS spray for 5 years now and have used it once when trying to control two women fighting each other who turned their attention to me when I intervened (I work alone and had no readily available back up). The alternative was a good right hook to the mandible which in my book you do not apply to a lady even when she is pulling your hair and kicking you in the crown jewels!

Taser has a system of memory that cannot be accessed by the users. It also has a system where aphid trace confetti with a specific serial number is released when the cartridge is fired. Each piece of confetti which are smaller than the debris from hole punch machines for paperwork carries the identification code for that cartridge. There are hundreds of them that blow around in the wind when the device is shot at a suspect and impossible to recover all which have been discharged unless a full search team is used.

This device will not stop the use of Police firearms being discharged but it will give those that need to have a degree of protection from personal serious injury from dangerous suspects a different option other than releasing a small piece of lead at 1400 feet per second.

MoJocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
"problem of non compliance are to continue to contain the person."

In this case all for it.

Look if a copper points his H&K at me I'm gonna do EXACTLY what he says, very carefully (not that I expect that to happen 'cos I'm a good guy).
I would not advocate walking away or towards an armed officer, you might not get shot but I bet a H&K butt tasted pretty foul.

gemini

11,352 posts

295 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all
Am I right that it has to be used with pepper spray and not CS as CS is inflamable

CraigAlsop

1,991 posts

299 months

Friday 18th April 2003
quotequote all

madcop said:
With regard to the worries about pacemakers and those with dodgy hearts, all the research to date (and there has been a huge amount of this done) shows that the deployment of Taser has no effect on the function of the pacemaker or the heart rythem. No one has died as a direct result of being tasered.
Well this is still in dispute - in the Journal of Forensic Sciences (vol 37, p 956), a Los Angeles forensics officer alleges that Taser use has resulted in death. But the manufacturers point out that this has never been proven. A Taser weapon has already been implicated in the miscarriage of a pregnant woman in the US. The darts sent a current across her uterus, and she miscarried the next day. No one has ever carried out a thorough, independent medical review of the Taser's effects. What reviews there have been, have looked at the effects of the earlier version, which delivers a quarter of the power.

From the new Scientist article, I quote "Company-commissioned research appears to allay concerns about people with pacemakers, a heart condition or who are under the influence of illicit drugs. But past medical studies that have come to less reassuring conclusions did not figure in the course for "master instructors" on the first day of the conference. Neither was there any mention of the limited amount of independent testing and regulation in the US and elsewhere. For those who stayed on for the second day of the conference, a medical consultant who has written a report on the weapon for Taser International acknowledged that there will always be concerns about its effects on susceptible people. But, he added, "epileptic pregnant junkie ladies with pacemakers will not rob banks."


Edited to say that I am somewhat reassured by the guidelines that you mention the UK police have to follow - somewhat different from your US colleagues

>> Edited by CraigAlsop on Friday 18th April 23:59