Smoky new diesels
Author
Discussion

JohnL

Original Poster:

1,766 posts

296 months

Monday 21st April 2003
quotequote all
My cousin has a brand new BMW 525d. It was 6 days old when I saw him yesterday. Anyway he drove off pouring black smoke out the back ... should diseasels do that on a cold start or is it sh@gged already (quality German craftsmanship)?

Toffer

1,528 posts

292 months

Monday 21st April 2003
quotequote all
My C5 2.2Hdi has done over 20,000 miles and the INSIDE of the exhaust tail pipes are absolutely as clean as the day I bought the car..it does have a particulate filter though

IMO, I reckon there will be thousands of smoky diesels smogging up our roads with their stinky exhaust. This will be thanks to the governments company car tax policy that induces company car drivers to buy diesels. Modern petrol cars are astonishingly clean when compared to cars produced only 20 years ago...but so are modern WELL MAINTAINED diesel cars!

I think that the mass of used, huge mileage diesel cars that will be populating our roads in four or five years time are potentially going to be a nasty legacy issue and ironically may be one of the reasons that the government will accelerate the introduction of city car tolls to reduce the polution that they will have been largely, indirectly responsible for creating!

agent006

12,058 posts

295 months

Monday 21st April 2003
quotequote all
Might not be run in properly yet? Most diesels will puff a bit of smoke when you really hoof it, but not usually. That 2.5 BMW diesel engine is getting quite old now though.

jaydee

1,107 posts

300 months

Monday 21st April 2003
quotequote all
You have to nail the throttle from v.v.cold to get a visible puff of smoke from my Saab diesel (3l TiD V6), so I can't imagine he should be getting black clouds unless it's running v. rich, maybe the map sensor's shagged ?

pbrettle

3,280 posts

314 months

Monday 21st April 2003
quotequote all
Due to the nature of Diesel engines (except those with particle filters), you will get a puff of black soot. Its all to do with the unburnt crud in the engine that collects if you are ambling along at low revs and speed. As soon as you push it a little harder it will flush the crud out and hey presto a puff of black smoke....

Nothing necessarily wrong - except if it does it all of the time and on a trailing throttle - but its the nature of the engine type rather than anything else...

Jaydee - no black smoke on your Saab - its an indication that you have been driving it (as in using the rev range as they say). This isnt a bad thing though...

Cheers,

Paul

littlegearl

3,139 posts

288 months

Monday 21st April 2003
quotequote all
haven't noticed any new diesels kicking out smoke, but lots of 1 year old cars chucking it out the back, like they've fcukered their injectors already...

regmolehusband

4,116 posts

288 months

Monday 21st April 2003
quotequote all
When I floor my one year old Golf 130TDI in the dark I can see a fair bit of smoke between me and car headlights behind.

I don't like to think they know I'm flooring it !!