Golf or A3?
Author
Discussion

dontlift

9,396 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

My car is up for sale and I'm either going to get a golf or an A3? hopefully the 1.8T model. which would you get?


golf

tim_s

Original Poster:

299 posts

285 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
My car is up for sale and I'm either going to get a golf or an A3? hopefully the 1.8T model. which would you get?

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
New or used...?

With the A3, you can get a 1.8T Quattro, if that floats your boat...

AnarchyStorm

943 posts

287 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Golf, R32 would be nice - otherwise the 1.8T. But definately a Golf if possible. It is teh R32 I am thinking of isnt it?!!

tim_s

Original Poster:

299 posts

285 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

Podie said: New or used...?

With the A3, you can get a 1.8T Quattro, if that floats your boat...


used. probably a 2000 model. insurance is too expensive on the quattro

>> Edited by tim_s on Tuesday 22 April 10:15

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Personally I don't think there is a great deal of difference between the two cars... think it's more a case of which styling you prefer, or which you can find a better example of... IMHO.

FWIW, my old man has had a FWD A3 1.8T and a Quattro one... the former was actually a better drive, although not quite as quick...

Big Chris

378 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
You see i would say Audi 1.8 T .... Golfs just dont look as special for some reason.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

Big Chris said: You see i would say Audi 1.8 T .... Golfs just dont look as special for some reason.


Bit more understated I s'pose...

Which gives you the most toys for your money...?

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
A3

Hand finishing makes a difference...

Matt.

Big Chris

378 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

Podie said:

Big Chris said: You see i would say Audi 1.8 T .... Golfs just dont look as special for some reason.


Bit more understated I s'pose...

Which gives you the most toys for your money...?



I reckon the alloys are better on the Audi as well .... having said that the Golf does have the funky Neon Blue dashboard lights........ nope i still say Audi

mechsympathy

58,926 posts

286 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

Big Chris said: You see i would say Audi 1.8 T .... Golfs just dont look as special for some reason.


Likewise, but then I'd go for the Octavia as its much more of a Q car, and you'll get more for the money. And the 4x4 version doesn't have the quattro label, despite being the same system (I think). And at 6'2" its the only car I have driven that truly fitted me, apart from the landcruiser.

AnarchyStorm

943 posts

287 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
What about a BORA? They go really nicely and look quite good too. A bit different from a Golf and definately not as boring as an A3.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Octavia RS is a good call... VERY under-rated IMHO.

Audi build quality has been good in the examples my old man has owned... and had no problems at all with any of the 3 A3's he's owned (not even the coil pack thingy).

When we looked at the Golf / A3 thing, it basically came down to styling and equipment. Both drove as well as each other... so he went the badge engineering route to be honest. Oh, and the dealer experience with Audi has been fantastic... never had an issue, and the collect the car and drop him off at the station etc when it goes for a service.

domster

8,431 posts

301 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
I have driven both a Mk IV Golf 2.0 GTi and an Audi A3 1.8T.

I would take the A3 any day of the week. It was more stylish, felt of a better quality and had more feelgood factor. All IMHO.

I suggest you test drive both, and see what you reckon. I thought a Golf would be amazing, but to be honest the Mk2 Golf GTi is a ton more fun than either of the cars listed above. The A3 has a 'BMWness' about it in terms of luxury and quality that the Golf lacks. The Golf is good, but merely feels like a well made household appliance.

alfa dave

967 posts

315 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Or a 3 Series Compact? - RWD similar prices to A3....

miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Definitely A3. We had a Golf GTi 1.8T and an A3 1.8T Sport on our fleet and the A3 was a far better drive IMO.

mikeylad

34,605 posts

284 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Octavia vRS for me. LOADS of kit, lovely seats, fast, saloon not hatch.

And i reckon driving a skoda now actually says good things, not bad things about you. not concerned about badge, appreciative of quality, unvain, etc.

just my opinion.

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

298 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Come and buy a Hyundai Coupe from me...

FIVE YEAR WARRANTY

We don't have large quantities of customers waiting for ignition parts...

just a thought....

Chris

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Firmly based in the neither camp i'm afraid...

Might be half tempted by either Seat Toledo or Leon, or probably the skoda RS. A mate of mine had the RS, not that i ever got a ride before he sold it on again ....

just can't get into the VW group cars, none of them are really exciting cars for your money (which is over priced i might add) and there are better driving cars out there for the same cash.

If you are definitely 100% set on a golf or audi with no room for movement then it has to be the A3 - it doesn't have quite the same pretentious middle england appearance and i had a loaner golf (well two actually) over 6 weeks last summer, both brand new <10 miles on the clock and both did nothing but wind me up! Gutless, lacking in cornering ability, body roll, none of that build quality you're supposed to get - oh the cup holders swished when they opend and the FM handles (fcuk me handles above the doors) were dampened, but not enough to impress me i'm afraid....

Sorry...

All IMHO of course

Buff



miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

Buffalo said: Gutless, lacking in cornering ability, body roll,


Exactly what I found, coming rather too quickly into the roundabout onto the M27 from Salisbury... that was too damn near to the armco for my liking.

Something that is to my liking, however, "FM handles" - nice - consider that definition stolen!