Honesty - The best policy???????
Honesty - The best policy???????
Author
Discussion

Marcos maniac

Original Poster:

3,148 posts

292 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
?

Is honesty the best policy?

just popped in to the bookies with a hot tip for a dog had a flutter £10 at 3/1 and it won.

I go up to collect my winnings and get paid out at 8/1
Would you have said anything to the bookie about the error?

pies

13,116 posts

287 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Bloody well not,shop yes bookie NO

icamm

2,153 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

?

Is honesty the best policy?

just popped in to the bookies with a hot tip for a dog had a flutter £10 at 3/1 and it won.

I go up to collect my winnings and get paid out at 8/1
Would you have said anything to the bookie about the error?
Well having noticed it you are now aware that an error has been made in your favour and it is technically theft (have you seen those VW? car ad's).

This was discussed a while ago and I believe it was Madcop who gave the definition that theft occurs at the time that the "decision to deprive" was taken (paraphrased of course). IE the moment you realised the mistake and decided to keep the money you committed theft. Up until that point it was an honest mistake and, therefore, not theft.

As to the moral judgement - only you can make that. I can say what I would like to think I would do - but would I in practice? faced with the money in my hand.

>> Edited by icamm on Wednesday 23 April 15:47

gopher

5,160 posts

290 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
this is not a case of you not sticking the price at 3-1 and the dog came in at 8-1 is it?

JohnL

1,766 posts

296 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
A while ago in Oxford I handed over a Scottish £1 note to pay for something costing about 50p. The assistant thought it was a £5 and gave me £4.50 change. Following the honesty is the best policy idea, I pointed out it was a £1.

"Oh, I don't think we can take that, I'll have to call the manager .." 10 minutes of pissing about later, assurances from another customer that it was quite valid, and I was finally allowed to go on my way.

Honesty the best policy? What do you think I'll do the next time?

Marcos maniac

Original Poster:

3,148 posts

292 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

gopher said: this is not a case of you not sticking the price at 3-1 and the dog came in at 8-1 is it?




Nope - Took first show at 3-1. at the off it dropped to 9-4 favourite.

gargamel

16,427 posts

292 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
its not theft - its Karma

You have led a good life - and this bonus £50 is God's way of saying thanks.

If you feel bad - give the bonus fifty to charity

(thus saving even more Karma)

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
I thought gambling in this country was more of a "gentleman's agreement" type situation and not protected/enforced by law (e.g. gambling debts not recoverable through courts). Therefore the payment made out though incorrect fot the type of bet was still "winnings" and not stealing? Legal position someone?

MikeyT

18,515 posts

302 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Bloke at our local petrol station is a bit of a gormo - never meets your eye, just stares out at girls on the forecourt etc.

One day he gave me change for a £20 instead of a tenner. Realised as soon as grabbed the change AND the tenner from his drawer.

Did I tell him? No. It may teach the twat to concentrate at his £4 an hour job instead of ogling the customers ...

And the kids got ice creams into the bargain so he did his bit for harmony round at ours.

Edited for spellin'

>> Edited by MikeyT on Wednesday 23 April 16:30

MilnerR

8,273 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Put the extra £50 on a real outsider. If it comes in then you were meant to have it. If it doesn't then you've given the bookie his money back..... problem solved!

>> Edited by MilnerR on Wednesday 23 April 16:55

>> Edited by MilnerR on Wednesday 23 April 16:56

TUS 373

5,243 posts

312 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
My better half calls this kind of situation "Stupidity Tax". If someone is daft enough to make a mistake - then it is their fault. The only way for them to improve themselves is to learn by their mistakes - usually when the till gets totted up and the end of the day. You pax taxes don't you - time you got something back then!

gbgaffer

546 posts

301 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Many Years ago, I was asked to take some oriental customers out for an evening in London. They wanted to visit some of the Metropolis's more 'esoteric' establishments. I explained before entering the premises of one of the better known 'Revue' bars that they would get ripped off if opportunity presented itself by some of the scallies employed in such places. So we all trooped in and they paid their £5 entrance fee at the door.

When it was my turn to pay, I handed over a note and was surprised to be given only a fiver as change. 'Oi' says I in me best 'sarf of the river accent', 'I'm not a tourist - give me the right change!'. 'Oh sorry mate' says laddie on the door, and hands me a tenner. It was only after we had left the building in search of more savoury pursuits that I realised that I had only given him a £10 note to start with, and he was obviously so used to short changing customers that he had mistakenly thought he had done it to me!

Obviously I took the money back at the first opportunity

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

298 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

Jinx said: I thought gambling in this country was more of a "gentleman's agreement" type situation and not protected/enforced by law (e.g. gambling debts not recoverable through courts). Therefore the payment made out though incorrect fot the type of bet was still "winnings" and not stealing? Legal position someone?


This sound right to me. I always understood that your winnings are not legally collectable if the bookie folds / fails to pay out / decides to pay out a different amount / etc.

just keep quiet & enjoy it.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

gargamel said: its not theft - its Karma

You have led a good life - and this bonus £50 is God's way of saying thanks.

If you feel bad - give the bonus fifty to charity

(thus saving even more Karma)


my view as well (FWIW!)

Psychobert

6,318 posts

287 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

TUS 373 said: My better half calls this kind of situation "Stupidity Tax".


Like it..

PatHeald

8,058 posts

287 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
I was mistakenly given change from a tenner after I only handed over a fiver.

I realised outside the shop and went back to do the decent thing.

I then noticed the sign that said "please check your change as mistakes cannot be rectified after you have left the shop."

So I turned back round and went on my way.

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
They were asking for it!