Graphics card advice
Author
Discussion

nevpugh308

Original Poster:

4,454 posts

300 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
I'm a bit out of touch with what's good graphics card wise at the moment.

I have 2 machines :
Evesham AMD 1800plus 512mb with WinFast GeForce3 Ti200 64mb
Compaq EN 933mhz 384mb with Voodoo3 16mb PCI (dont laugh )

The 2nd machine struggles with UT2003 (640x480 with no effects is just about playable ) so the missus has offered to buy me a new card for my birthday (it's only coz I can't get her off UT2003 on the main machine ! Damn broadband and online gaming !)

I have two choices ....
1) Buy a new card for the 933
2) Buy a new card for the 1800plus and put the GeForce3 in the 933 (ASSUMING it will work/fit ?) I think the 933 has an AGP slot, but I've no idea what spec (1,2,4,8 ?)

Budget of about £100-£150. What would anyone advise .... is something like a GeForce4 128mb a significant step on on the GeoForce3 I've got at the moment, or would I be better off just spending £100 or so on an average card for the 933 machine ? Has anyone got any recommendations on specific cards ? Is the GeForce3 card likely to fit in the 933 ?

Cheers !

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
The Radeon 9x00 series are getting rave reviews at the moment...

Matt.

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
To be fair, I think the 2nd machine is always going to struggle with UT2003.

Probably not worth getting a state of the art card for it, as it won't be getting data as fast as it would like and so will be a waste of processing power.

My choice would be to put the GeForce3 in there and get a top of the line card for the Athlon.

8ball

91 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all

I'm a bit out of touch with what's good graphics card wise at the moment.

I have 2 machines :
Evesham AMD 1800plus 512mb with WinFast GeForce3 Ti200 64mb
Compaq EN 933mhz 384mb with Voodoo3 16mb PCI (dont laugh )

The 2nd machine struggles with UT2003 (640x480 with no effects is just about playable ) so the missus has offered to buy me a new card for my birthday (it's only coz I can't get her off UT2003 on the main machine ! Damn broadband and online gaming !)

I have two choices ....
1) Buy a new card for the 933
2) Buy a new card for the 1800plus and put the GeForce3 in the 933 (ASSUMING it will work/fit ?) I think the 933 has an AGP slot, but I've no idea what spec (1,2,4,8 ?)

Budget of about £100-£150. What would anyone advise .... is something like a GeForce4 128mb a significant step on on the GeoForce3 I've got at the moment, or would I be better off just spending £100 or so on an average card for the 933 machine ? Has anyone got any recommendations on specific cards ? Is the GeForce3 card likely to fit in the 933 ?

Cheers !



The 933 system will more than likely not have a AGP slot (guess from the spec, its using a PCI Voodoo 3 but its worth checking)

The 1800 system should have a AGP because its using a Geforce 3 so I would upgrade that one.

As for which card to buy, it all depends on how much money she thinks your worth

Best cards for the money at the mo are ATi 9500/9600 Pro's.

If money is not a object, a 9700/9800 Pro is best.

nVidia products (FX range) are good at the moment but just cant quite beat the ATi stuff in performance. Features both ATi (9500 to 9800) and nVidia (FX range) are DX9 compliant but nvidias high end cards are suppose to be a little loud.

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all

8ball said:The 933 system will more than likely not have a AGP slot (guess from the spec, its using a PCI Voodoo 3 but its worth checking)

I would find that very suprising, but the fact that you have a PCI Voodoo card might suggest that this is in fact the case?

nevpugh308

Original Poster:

4,454 posts

300 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
Actually that's a good point .... I've just had a look inside a similar machine, and I've got a nasty feeling it HASNT got a AGP slot

What are the feelings about PCI cards then, for example :

Radeon 9000 64MB DDR PCI RP
GeForce 4 MX440SE 64MB PCI RP VO

(not brill, but got to be better than the Voodoo surely ?)

8ball

91 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
Both a lot better than a voodoo yea

I would say at a pinch the MX440SE would be slightly better than the ATi 9000

GregE240

10,857 posts

298 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
Rubbish, 8ball.

The MX440SE is a kevved up GeF3, if you're going to go GeForce, do the decent thing and at least get a TI series.

ATI seems to be the best right now, and cooling wise seems better - I've heard horror stories of GeF's running "a bit warm"...

All MHO.

v8guinness

204 posts

312 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
I'd agree, pretty much everything had a AGp slot a few years before we got to 933 Celerons...
Also the card should work in a slower port, you just loose a little performance...

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all

GregE240 said:The MX440SE is a kevved up GeF3, if you're going to go GeForce, do the decent thing and at least get a TI series.

True, but did anyone ever make a Ti series card with a PCI interface? Would seem more than a little pointless...

D3ano

7,414 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
I have a PC with a 1GHz Pentium3 and 256RAM and a GeForce 3 ti500 card and this runs UT2003 quite well. This is res of 1024x768. I recommend getting a Geforce 3 ti500 if your budget stretch, it definantly takes a load off your CPU.

8ball

91 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all

D3ano said: I have a PC with a 1GHz Pentium3 and 256RAM and a GeForce 3 ti500 card and this runs UT2003 quite well. This is res of 1024x768. I recommend getting a Geforce 3 ti500 if your budget stretch, it definantly takes a load off your CPU.


Only problem is sourcing one. They no longer make the chipset any more so it might be hard to find one.

8ball

91 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all

v8guinness said: I'd agree, pretty much everything had a AGp slot a few years before we got to 933 Celerons...
Also the card should work in a slower port, you just loose a little performance...


All depends, OEMS like Compaq, Evesham DELL etc etc oftern use motherboards without AGP slots as they are cheaper. Somtimes they even ask to have the ports removed to save a few $$$.

Still worth taking the case of the check.



>> Edited by 8ball on Thursday 24th April 12:13

nevpugh308

Original Poster:

4,454 posts

300 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
(I've just found the specs for my machine and it DEFINATELY doesn't have an AGP slot)

(edited to say : 8ball, you're spot on ... it is a Compaq so I guess that's why the penny pinching g*ts have done it. typical.)

>> Edited by nevpugh308 on Thursday 24th April 10:40

GregE240

10,857 posts

298 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all

pdV6 said:

GregE240 said:The MX440SE is a kevved up GeF3, if you're going to go GeForce, do the decent thing and at least get a TI series.

True, but did anyone ever make a Ti series card with a PCI interface? Would seem more than a little pointless...


Ah. Yes, good point. Hadn't thought of that, sorry.

outlaw

1,893 posts

297 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
get a gefouse 2 64 meg for second one
as it would be a wast of mone oputting a top card in one of that spec.

8ball

91 posts

292 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all

GregE240 said: Rubbish, 8ball.

The MX440SE is a kevved up GeF3, if you're going to go GeForce, do the decent thing and at least get a TI series.

ATI seems to be the best right now, and cooling wise seems better - I've heard horror stories of GeF's running "a bit warm"...

All MHO.



The MX range is the budget version of the G4's (if even that). No way is it a Kevved up version of a G3.

Its not even Dx8 compliant were as the G3's are.

Its a slow performing card, ment for main stream sales.

You wont be able to get any of the Ti (geforce 3 or 4) range in PCI form.



>> Edited by 8ball on Thursday 24th April 12:33

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
Creative did a Geforce2 in a PCI slot...

Matt.

AnarchyStorm

943 posts

287 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
Before you buy the graphics card - you might also want to find out what sort of RAM the card is using. I have just upgraded to the Geforce Ti4600 or 4800, cant remember now and it's using DDR RAM which is a lot quicker than an ordinary Geforce/ATI card. They are slightly pricier but a better quality graphics card. Oh, and the difference between the ATI Radeon high end cards compared to teh Geforce FX cards is very little. They are both a quality set of cards and I would recommend either. Me being bias would always go nvidia anyway LOL!

nevpugh308

Original Poster:

4,454 posts

300 months

Thursday 24th April 2003
quotequote all
Thanks all for your thoughts

(AnarchyStorm - by nvidia do you mean the Radeon ?)