Alfa 156 2.0 vs E39 523i running costs/driving experience.
Alfa 156 2.0 vs E39 523i running costs/driving experience.
Author
Discussion

sparks87

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
I've just seen another car I like! Was considering an Alfa but have been liking the 5 series a lot recently, is there much difference in running costs, and would £3500 be enough to pick me up a great 1998 onwards 523i with preferably less than 100k? I can have the newer slightly quicker Alfa for £3500, but I like the possibility of having RWD!. Before anyone asks I really don't want an E36 3 series coupe, some may think I'm odd but for what it is the E39 5 series is a very good looking car. Also am I right in thinking the 523i is the best comparison to the 156?

bks just realised I'm in P&P, sorry chaps please move to general gassing.silly

Edited by sparks87 on Saturday 19th July 19:36

sparks87

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
Is 100,00 miles a lot for a 5 series? I've seen some that have done 150,000+ and they seem fine, I just wondered if they start to have problems approaching the 100k milestone...

sparks87

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
I'm getting a manual if I can find a decent one.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
I've no experience with BMW's, but the 156 is a cracking car. For a 2.0 4-pot, the engine sounds fantastic. Providing you get one that's been looked after then you shouldn't have any problems. In the current climate you should be able to get either of your choices at a reasonable price.

Dover Nige

1,308 posts

274 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
I bought an E39 523i SE auto off another PH'er and I must say, I'm loving it. Click on my user name and there's plenty fo posts asking about 5's where I've given my opinion. It's now at 117k miles, has not needed anything doing and drives superbly (probably a lot to do with Derin100 who I bought it off). I use it for commuting and going back and forth to Wales and it takes it all in it's stride. It's comfortable, wonderfully balanced, and MPG hovers around the high 20's into low 30's, more on a motorway run and it's built like a tank. I really rate them after driving this one.

[TW]Fox

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
523i's are a waste of time. They are no more economical and no cheaper to run than the 528i so you might as well just get one of those.

retrorider

1,339 posts

232 months

Saturday 19th July 2008
quotequote all
and while we're at it the alfa V6 is the much better engine and the 2.5 is about the same on mpg as the twin spark 2.0 4 cylinder...

OperationAlfa

2,014 posts

228 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Alfas sound like a diesel on startup if the variator has gone. It should be changed at the same time as the cambelt.. £90 for the part. No extra service time should be charged.

mat205125

17,790 posts

244 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Go for the V6 Alfa. The extra few quid in fuel will be worth it for the soundtrack. I used to be able to get 35+ mpg on a run in mine anyway. Lovely lovely car, and not as unreliable as people make out so long as you do not neglect it.

OperationAlfa

2,014 posts

228 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
+1 for the V6! biggrin

Fiddlemesticks

14,472 posts

247 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
I had a 156 (1.8 though) and am Alfa through and through. love em to bits and would have another.

Unless i had the money for an E39.

The Alfa is great but the 5 series has that much more space inside, better build quality (panel gaps etc), is RWD and if it was the top up between a 120k mile 156 or a 120k 5 series i think i'd take the 5 series every day of the week.

I also think servicing costs on a 156 might work out more in the long term.

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
There are 29 E39 523s on autotrader at the moment with less than 100K on the clock for less than £3K, if that answers your question about availability....

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
retrorider said:
and while we're at it the alfa V6 is the much better engine and the 2.5 is about the same on mpg as the twin spark 2.0 4 cylinder...
You're joking, right? When I had a V6, the fuel costs were close to my RX7!

On average I got low 20s, the 145 2.0 I had previously averaged high 20s doing the same journeys!

broadhat

718 posts

244 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
mat205125 said:
Go for the V6 Alfa. The extra few quid in fuel will be worth it for the soundtrack. I used to be able to get 35+ mpg on a run in mine anyway. Lovely lovely car, and not as unreliable as people make out so long as you do not neglect it.
and

Mave said:
retrorider said:
and while we're at it the alfa V6 is the much better engine and the 2.5 is about the same on mpg as the twin spark 2.0 4 cylinder...
You're joking, right? When I had a V6, the fuel costs were close to my RX7!

On average I got low 20s, the 145 2.0 I had previously averaged high 20s doing the same journeys!
My 02 plate V6 gives around low 20s. Took it to France a few weeks back so some decent motorway runs but definitely nothing like 35+ maybe high 20s.

So far no reliability issues and it's on 85k. Fantastic car, made for hooning.

swiftpete

1,894 posts

224 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
The bmw wont give you the same driving feel as they are pretty heavy cars anyway. With the low powered engine it will just be a get you from a to b type car. I have one with the 4.4 v8 and that is not bad to drive but only cos it has a fair amount of power. The same car with no power would not really appeal. Depends if you want to give it a bit of stick. I'd go for the alfa if you want to chuck it about.

sparks87

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
swiftpete said:
The bmw wont give you the same driving feel as they are pretty heavy cars anyway. With the low powered engine it will just be a get you from a to b type car. I have one with the 4.4 v8 and that is not bad to drive but only cos it has a fair amount of power. The same car with no power would not really appeal. Depends if you want to give it a bit of stick. I'd go for the alfa if you want to chuck it about.
In fairness I'm going from a 13 year old 1.4 306 to this car, believe me sometimes I feel a Tesco's trolley would be an improvement. The only good thing about the 306 is the way it looks. I know I don't speak for all 306's but mine has been a bit of a dog. The 523i does the 0-60 in less than 9 seconds, will cruise at *ahem*70*ahem* with no effort and is cheap to insure for my age (21) at £700. Maybe in the future I might upgrade to the more powerful model but I'm sure I'll be quite content with what the 523i is capable of. I'm after a car that is comfortable, good looking, a fantastic drive, reliable and relatively quick and doesn't guzzle too much fuel. The E39 5 series fits my criteria perfectly, although I must admit the Alfa is better looking.

I don't want to chuck it around carelessly, although I don't drive like a grandad, I've got out of the "boy racer" phase of my life. Its a shame the higher performance models are out of the question at the moment, I long for a V8 but the insurance and running costs would be ruiningcry

Edited by sparks87 on Sunday 20th July 17:33

matt21

4,404 posts

235 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
i would definitely go for the 523i SE.

I have a E34 525i SE Touring that has just passed 215,000 miles, not a hitch since I owned it at 202,000. Simply brilliant cars.

Look out for Niksil problems on some models. Any car built before week 10 1998 may suffer although most should have expired by now if they have the problem.

I would also recommend getting one with leather and auto, far easier to sell and makes them a much nicer place to be.

The 523i is a good engine as it is a slightly detuned 2.5 litre so has little stress. The 528i is (i think from the 5 forum) about 1-2mpg more thirsty generally speaking but offers far more grunt. DOnt even touch a 520i uses the same amount of fuel and you have to thrash it more!

I would defo go BMW route, you wont be disappointed. Visit www.bmw5.co.uk, loads of good info and buyers guides there smile

Matt

sparks87

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
Thanks a lot guys, I hope the 5 series isn't to "normal" a car to put one or two PH stickers on, I resisted the urge to put them on the Pug!

matt21

4,404 posts

235 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
sparks87 said:
Thanks a lot guys, I hope the 5 series isn't to "normal" a car to put one or two PH stickers on, I resisted the urge to put them on the Pug!
i have PH stickers on my BM smile

sparks87

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 20th July 2008
quotequote all
matt21 said:
sparks87 said:
Thanks a lot guys, I hope the 5 series isn't to "normal" a car to put one or two PH stickers on, I resisted the urge to put them on the Pug!
i have PH stickers on my BM smile
That settles it thensmile