What's with winter tyres?
What's with winter tyres?
Author
Discussion

HellDiver

Original Poster:

5,708 posts

213 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
So I've got myself a cheap set of 17" alloys for the car for winter wheels.

I've been trying to get prices for some winter tyres locally, and so far the couple of tyre dealers I've tried have looked at me like I've got horns growing out of my head.

One spotty youth in one of the dealers had never even heard of winter tyres and had to be shown a web site so he'd believe they actually existed.

Surely these guys should be actively trying to sell winter tyres considering how much of the year is below the 7C temp range of summer tyres?

Anyone else had this problem, or does anyone else actually bother with winter tyres?

Looks like Mytyres or Camskill may be by only option...

Edited by HellDiver on Tuesday 1st September 11:48

pritt stick

80 posts

207 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
Crikey its only turned Autumn

Puddenchucker

6,000 posts

249 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
This is just my (non-expert) opinion, but unless you live somewhere that gets a lot of snow, you many be better off with a set of 'All Season' tyres (e.g. Vredestein Quatrac) rather than full winter tyres.

cptsideways

13,902 posts

283 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
Oct/Nov time they become stocked, though the UK is'nt always the best source as its a limited market over here so you can't always get what you want at a fair price.

HellDiver

Original Poster:

5,708 posts

213 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
I have summer tyres on my 18" rims, the 17" winter tyres (I was thinking Wintrac Extremes) would only be October/November to April. The area I work is quite high, and frost and ice is generally on the ground for 2 months solid around the Christmas period, and it's the place where it snows long before anywhere else in the country.

I'm a bit early but I'm away in Spain for most of the rest of September.

The Quatrac 3 would be ideal, unfortunately not available in the size I need. The Goodyear Vector 4 Seasons is available, but they seem to get mediocre reviews.

Edited by HellDiver on Tuesday 1st September 12:00

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
I drive a Merc and a few people on the Merc forum change to winter tyres - one guy runs them year round and gets good mileage from them. They cease to be "officially" (not that that matters in the UK) winter tyres when they're worn to 4mm.

I've seen them described as a "night & day" difference to summer tyres.

HellDiver

Original Poster:

5,708 posts

213 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
dibbers006 said:
However, having all wheel drive, the slightly under grippy Summer tyres are an awful lot of fun come the slippy rain time so I tend to stick with what I have driving

hehe
Unfortunately I only have FWD, and Toyo T1-R which are defeated by rain, so I suspect they're going to be useless on snow or ice.

matt21

4,404 posts

235 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
HellDiver said:
dibbers006 said:
However, having all wheel drive, the slightly under grippy Summer tyres are an awful lot of fun come the slippy rain time so I tend to stick with what I have driving

hehe
Unfortunately I only have FWD, and Toyo T1-R which are defeated by rain, so I suspect they're going to be useless on snow or ice.
My Cooper S had Toyo T1-R with around 3mm of tread and I wheel spun my way to work on "that" very snowy day. Took 3hrs to do 30 miles, but I was virtually the only one there!


ZesPak

26,164 posts

227 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
HellDiver said:
dibbers006 said:
However, having all wheel drive, the slightly under grippy Summer tyres are an awful lot of fun come the slippy rain time so I tend to stick with what I have driving

hehe
Unfortunately I only have FWD, and Toyo T1-R which are defeated by rain, so I suspect they're going to be useless on snow or ice.
I had those Toyo's on my 307 SW and they were defeated by rain like you say.
ot: when a tyre centre doesn't know winter tyres, I wouldn't want to go there.

WorAl

10,877 posts

219 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
never bothered with winter tyres to be honest, just be a little more cautious.

dtmpower

3,972 posts

276 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
pritt stick said:
Crikey its only turned Autumn
Not yet - 3 weeks to go...

bazking69

8,620 posts

221 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
Is there really a need for proper winter tyres in this country?

I drove my RWD car in the driving snow last winter with about 2mm of tread on all tyres and didn't have one issue as long as I went easy, even on the backroads that hadn't been gritted and the snow was settling on at sub zero temperatures.

ExPat2B

2,159 posts

231 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
The thing with Winter tyres is that they ONLY give superior performance when the roads are both wet AND below 4 degrees C.

Due to the climate in England, it is very rarely wet and and below 4 degrees at the same time as the rain acts like a blanket and brings the tempreture up.

So Winter tyres are only better than regular summer tyres 4 or 5 days a year, and the sports tyres give better performance on all other days.

I have lived in countries where snow tyres are needed, and the favourite brand is Nokian and available on the Web, but for the UK, the facts are that you are better off with summer tyres 99% of the time unless you live very far up north.


iggletiggle

1,380 posts

216 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
never bother with winters to be honest

i had Toyo T1Rs on my VTS (both of them) and never had a problem, superb in the wet and dry.. came a little interesting in the ice/snow but still kept me where i needed to be..!


Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
Without winter tyres last winter, I would not have been driving to wrok on two or three occasions. With winter tyres and DSC off, my silly powerful rwd car got up our steep hill in the snow with slightly squirmy ease, unlike a neighbour's silly wide summer tyre-shod Touareg.

Winter tyres give more grip below 7 degrees C. From the end of Novemeber through to late March this yer, most mornings the temperature was at or below 7 degrees according to the outside temperature display in my car.

HellDiver

Original Poster:

5,708 posts

213 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
ExPat2B said:
The thing with Winter tyres is that they ONLY give superior performance when the roads are both wet AND below 4 degrees C.

Due to the climate in England
I'm not in England. I'm at the top of N. Ireland, on high ground around my work place, and at home the place is a bit of a microclimate that's always 2-3C colder than anywhere else.

ExPat2B said:
So Winter tyres are only better than regular summer tyres 4 or 5 days a year, and the sports tyres give better performance on all other days.
As I said, I've seen frost not thaw for 2 months, and here the snow is still lying at the sides of the road for weeks after it's gone elsewhere.

Edit: What's with the daffy quoting on this board?!?



Edited by HellDiver on Tuesday 1st September 13:20

Eddh

4,656 posts

223 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
I run T1-Rs on the BMW all year round and they are fine.

The CRX is off the road in the winter, r888s and ~200bhp in a FWD car... its not even worth bothering.

Deerfoot

5,258 posts

215 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
ExPat2B said:
The thing with Winter tyres is that they ONLY give superior performance when the roads are both wet AND below 4 degrees C.
I don`t think this is strictly true.

HellDiver

Original Poster:

5,708 posts

213 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
This isn't a thread about Toyo T1-R really. I've had threads about them - they suit some cars better than other. They don't work on my Lancer at all, I think it's too heavy for them at 1465kg.

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Tuesday 1st September 2009
quotequote all
Zod said:
Winter tyres give more grip below 7 degrees C. From the end of Novemeber through to late March this yer, most mornings the temperature was at or below 7 degrees according to the outside temperature display in my car.
Has anyone mentioned that Winter tyres are cheaper than summer tyres yet ?

With winter tyres, not only do you get a tyre check every time you switch
over (usually when the clocks change), but also you get cheaper and safer
motoring during the winter too.

Mind you, down here in the deep south, where we run around in shorts
and T shirt from March to November, it's not worth it.