Write off my car
Author
Discussion

1987

Original Poster:

89 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Hoping to get some advice here. I have a 3 month old Clio 200 which was rear ended yesterday. The boot lid, rear bumper, diffuser and floor pan (which im worried about most) were all damaged extensively.

I want the car to be written off as i'll always know that it's not the same with having a new floor welded in. I expect the damage to be around £4-5k so they may write it off but is there anything i can say to fight my corner if they don't?


Defcon5

6,479 posts

222 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Any creasing to the roof?

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
It'll need to be something like 70% value of the car for repairs to make it a write off...A lot of the bits you mentioned are unique to the 200 I suspect. Which may make them expensive....

Or if the floor is really bent it may not be repairable regardless of costs.

saaby93

32,038 posts

209 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Its a third party no fault claim
Does your own insurance give you a new car if its within 12 months old?

Otherwise youre probably best not involving your insurance ( apart from telling them) and going through someone like Europa.
You're entitled to be in the same position you were pre-accident, which might well be a new car at only 3 months old.

poo at Paul's

14,621 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
They may not write it off, and it is unlikely they will have to weld in a new boot floor, unless it really is mangled beyond belief. Once the more structural bent peices are removed, the floor will proabbly just pop straight.
As for the rear panel, well that will need welding in, but done properly, it should not affec tthe end result one iota.
The problem you have is if it is written off, hwo much you will get back. You may well have had the clio at the cheap price that they were being offered at back end of last year, and tbh they have jumped up a couple of grand this year, so you may not get enough to replace it.

Why not wait and see what the insurance say first, and dont believe all you read and hear about cars "not being the same" after a crash. They are made of a series of parts, all welded and bolted together, once dmage parts are replaced, they it will again be made of a series of parts welded and bolted together!
If it is written off, even assuming the accident was not your fault, you will be paying for this on your insuarance for many years to come, and the larger the claim payout, the worse it will be!


If the quarters and wheel arches are all ok, not kinked and stoved in, and damage is limited to the tailgate and rear panel as you suggest, they probably will fix it. You cannot insist it is written off, but it IS your car, and you can certainly make your wished known. You always have the option of having it fixed to your satisfication then selling it immediately after to recoup what you can.

Also, what colour is it? Liquid eyllow is notoriously difficult to paint mathc, but the blue, green and white are Ok, so if it is one of these, the repair whould be indistinguisable if done right.


Sorry to hear about your accident, it must feel crap to have a nice new car stoved in, but have faith, there are some amazing bodyshops out there who can do miracles!

1987

Original Poster:

89 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. It was not my fault and the other party has accepted liability but to confuse matters we are both with the same insurance company.

They have compensated me £150 for no use of a car over the weekend and seem eager to look after me.

Interesting part about being in a position as i was pre accident. May use this if they decide to repair.

The boot floor is bent into a 'v' shape so its pretty bad. I assume this would require cutting out and replacing?

saaby93

32,038 posts

209 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
1987 said:
Thanks for the replies. It was not my fault and the other party has accepted liability but to confuse matters we are both with the same insurance company.
It's any guess whether that's helpful

Give these people a ring if you have so much as a sniff of it going pear shaped - or before
http://www.europaconsultants.co.uk/

poo at Paul's

14,621 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Unfortunately, even as a non fault calim, you premiums will increase! Their stats tell them if you have had one non fault claim, you are more likely to make another claim of some sort.
No comfort to you, but it is fact, and as a result< I'd always to to mittigate the extent of the claim as far as you can.

Of course if you had GAP insurance, it's not an issue.

See what they say next week maybe?

CDP

8,062 posts

285 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
poo at Paul's said:
As for the rear panel, well that will need welding in, but done properly, it should not affec tthe end result one iota.
I'm not sure about the Clio but most modern cars are galvanised these days and you could never reproduce that level of protection in a modern paint shop. Amongst other things they simply can't get to the insides of the joints and even weld through primers get burnt away from the immediate area of the weld.

Insist the insurance company will match the Renault warranty rather than just the three years most paint shops require. Certainly on many cars that's now 12 years. On Mercedes it's 30.

TheCarpetCleaner

7,294 posts

233 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Just for reference - for some reason they don't seem to be writing cars off any more.

My business partners car - a rover worth £2,500 at the time. He rearended another car - total repair cost was £2,350 and they still repaired it.

My own car - Mondeo TDCi - my girlfriend rearended another car at low speed on the motorway. Low speed but needed new bumper, new foglights, loads of new plastics and various other bits. Car was worth around £1,800 - repairs came to £2,000 - they fixed the car.

I don't know whether there is a new government drive to not write cars off at the moment, but these two accidents happened about 2-3 years ago, and we were both shocked (and in his case, annoyed hehe ) that they did not write the cars off.

5 years ago, friend hit a roundabout in his old 3 series, car worth around £4,000 - damage (couple of panels and some paintwork) £2,200 - they wrote the car off... No structural reasons apparently.

I hope someone from the industry may be able to explain the above - because we are at a loss confused

1987

Original Poster:

89 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Poo at pauls (i'm a bit fan of your adverts btw) thanks for the advice. I fully understand waht your saying about the 'car never being the same again' but its not like its 3 year old, its 3 months old. The reason i bought a new car was for that feeling that it had never been damaged, sprayed, abused etc and paid a premium for that and now i'm no longer in that position.

I don't mind about the payout as long as I was to get the value of waht a used one of the same age and mileage are selling for.



Edited by 1987 on Sunday 28th February 15:58

1987

Original Poster:

89 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
poo at Paul's said:
Unfortunately, even as a non fault calim, you premiums will increase! Their stats tell them if you have had one non fault claim, you are more likely to make another claim of some sort.
I can barely stomach the insurance premium as it is. This is ridiculous!

Just seems like i'll be the one with a repaired car, higher insurance premiums, whiplash and everyone assuming that it was my fault because i'm a young driver.

Again thanks for all the knowledge and advice.

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
I dont thnk anyone is assuming it is your fault but, as been said before, regardless of fault your premium is affected due to the fact that you have been in an incident.

I had protected NCB when my wife wrote my Z3M off and I expected my premium to stay the same.....wrong, the discount stays the same but the initial premium goes up inline with the claim/incident.

Edited by falkster on Sunday 28th February 15:20

1987

Original Poster:

89 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
I didn't mean on here that everyone assumes that it was my fault, sorry.

Just had a call to say they will collect my car tomorrow. I will also let the insurance company know that I would prefer a payout and see what they say.

Have taken some pictures but won't post them in case i have to keep the car and sell it in future!

sy534534

249 posts

208 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
saaby93 said:
1987 said:
Thanks for the replies. It was not my fault and the other party has accepted liability but to confuse matters we are both with the same insurance company.
It's any guess whether that's helpful

Give these people a ring if you have so much as a sniff of it going pear shaped - or before
http://www.europaconsultants.co.uk/
I would seriously follow this advice. From my long time lurking i've seen the results Anniesdad gets (europaconsultants). Let them deal with it for you and avoid any trouble. Give them a ring, what have you got to lose?

saaby93

32,038 posts

209 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
1987 said:
Just seems like i'll be the one with a repaired car, higher insurance premiums, whiplash and everyone assuming that it was my fault because i'm a young driver.
Havent copied what values you put in another post but you ought to edit them out. Your starting point, with 3 months old and being in position you were, ought to be replacement car
unless of course you prefer the cash now.
The insurers would trade your car at auction and get a decent amount for it.
Whether they'll go for replacement is a fine balance



Edited by saaby93 on Sunday 28th February 15:59

1987

Original Poster:

89 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
A new car would be lovely, but I believe that would put me in a postion of betterment (if thats a word!) which is not really what i'm after. I just don't want a crash repaired car and would rather have a cash payout.


fridaypassion

11,458 posts

259 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Wont be a writeoff with that damage. RRP is about 18k on these isnt it?

saaby93

32,038 posts

209 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
1987 said:
A new car would be lovely, but I believe that would put me in a postion of betterment (if thats a word!) which is not really what i'm after. I just don't want a crash repaired car and would rather have a cash payout.
Whose side are you on biggrin
I think you need help wink
The usual trade off with having your car repaired is that they'll never be able to repair it exactly as it was ( there've been suggestions above by other posters) but in exchange you get new paint in place of old ( which may not quite match or fade the same way) and new body panels in place of old ones
The difficulty with yours is it's only 3 months old so the new panels and new paint isn't that much of a benefit to trade with the different type of paint and other issues mentioned, so a replacement car could win, especially if youre going to spend months quibling if it isnt quite right.

A cash offer could be related to the current trade value of the car so may not be so useful.
I think you need help

KungFuPanda

4,655 posts

201 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
I doubt that it wil be a write off with that damage however note that it is 3 month old performance car. In this respect I have seen claims presented for the diminution of value of a nearly new or prestige vehicle. This amounts to about 10% of the Pre Accident Value and is intended to recompense the owner of a repaired vehicle for the fact that it has undergone major repairs and could well be spotted by a later purchaser on an inspection. Perhaps this maybe the sort of claim that you should be presenting?

If you do want to go down this route, maybe you could see if you have Legal Expenses Insurance or see an Accident Management Company as you will need an Engineer's Report to confirm the value of the vehicle, standard of repairs etc etc.