The false economy of diesel.
The false economy of diesel.
Author
Discussion

Somnophore

Original Poster:

1,364 posts

207 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Just seen this illustrated by a friend of mine who just doesn't get it. He's bought a leon cupra tdi on a 54 plate, nice car, very torquey good mpg, great no problem. However he paid £7800 for it from a dealer. In the same showroom was a Cupra 1.8t with 180bhp, it was same colour, same milage give or take, almost same in every way, except that was £5800.

Now what he doesn't get is with him only doing 10k a year or there about it'll be 4 years probably before he earns back the extra he's paying for the (less powerful) diesel. He only sees the cost per fill/mothly running costs, doesn't really get the big picture.

Tend to find most people are like that nowadays. I can understand people wanna reduce monthly spend, but you gotta look at the big pictures.

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
The extra spent on the diesel isn't all lost though, it'll be worth more when he comes to sell it.

The BIG running cost that people all too often don't take into account, is depreciation.

Lost soul

8,712 posts

213 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
Just seen this illustrated by a friend of mine who just doesn't get it. He's bought a leon cupra tdi on a 54 plate, nice car, very torquey good mpg, great no problem. However he paid £7800 for it from a dealer. In the same showroom was a Cupra 1.8t with 180bhp, it was same colour, same milage give or take, almost same in every way, except that was £5800.

Now what he doesn't get is with him only doing 10k a year or there about it'll be 4 years probably before he earns back the extra he's paying for the (less powerful) diesel. He only sees the cost per fill/mothly running costs, doesn't really get the big picture.

Tend to find most people are like that nowadays. I can understand people wanna reduce monthly spend, but you gotta look at the big pictures.
What is your problem with what he decides to run , when he comes to sell it it will be worth more so it all equals out in the end

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
My friend just did the same thing, he traded in his ML CDI against a C class coupe.
He paid £7k for a 2001 55k diesel auto, when he could have paid £5-5500 for an identical petrol which would also be faster! If he had done that he could almost have done a straight swap for his ML.

Somnophore

Original Poster:

1,364 posts

207 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
I do get the depreciation arguement, although he only keeps his cars a couple of years so I don't think it will balance out still. I love the cupra tdi, just couldn't justify the extra cost over the petrol.

Diesels have higher servicing costs and can be more expensive if they go wrong.

varsas

4,077 posts

233 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
I do get the depreciation arguement, although he only keeps his cars a couple of years so I don't think it will balance out still. I love the cupra tdi, just couldn't justify the extra cost over the petrol.

Diesels have higher servicing costs and can be more expensive if they go wrong.
Maybe with N/A petrol vs turbo diesel, but you are comparing a turbo petrol with a turbo diesel. Are the servicing schedules that different (I don't know, just asking, I expect a turbo petrol will need servicing more then a N/A petrol?) and ther's just as much to go wrong...

tr7v8

7,628 posts

259 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
I do get the depreciation arguement, although he only keeps his cars a couple of years so I don't think it will balance out still. I love the cupra tdi, just couldn't justify the extra cost over the petrol.

Diesels have higher servicing costs and can be more expensive if they go wrong.
Not necessarily the Jag has 15K service intervals & costs around the same as the 3L petrol which is 12.5K
A lot of diesels don't go wrong but agreed if they do then it can be big bucks.

Somnophore

Original Poster:

1,364 posts

207 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
This was merely an illustration, my point was lots of people buy diesels over petrols purely on the fuel economy idea, when they in fact do very few miles and will never earn that extra cost back on the initial purchase.

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
Diesels have higher servicing costs and can be more expensive if they go wrong.
How do they have higher servicing costs?

Dare2Fail

3,808 posts

239 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Provided the diesel and the petrol cars both depreciate at roughly the same rate then he won't have lost out as it will balance out. The only time it would be a false economy is where is diesel depreciates £2k more than the petrol car. Given that you have said he doesn't hold onto his cars for long it doesn't sound like this is very likely to happen. Or am I missing something?

softtop

3,173 posts

278 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
This was merely an illustration, my point was lots of people buy diesels over petrols purely on the fuel economy idea, when they in fact do very few miles and will never earn that extra cost back on the initial purchase.
I know there are always two sides to every story but picture this conversation, "there is no point my wife driving the Mercedes ML, it uses too much fuel, so we bought this one year old mini to run about in." So you cannot afford the petrol for the school run but can afford £15,000 for a more economical car to run about in? I have not done the maths but how old will the Mini be before the cost reduction starts?

Citman

305 posts

215 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
It's not as silly as it sounds, really - the week-to-week running costs are more important to me than the initial purchase price, which will either have been saved up for or paid in instalments anyway.

Edited by Citman on Sunday 7th March 13:55

Chris_w666

22,655 posts

230 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
jagracer said:
Somnophore said:
Diesels have higher servicing costs and can be more expensive if they go wrong.
How do they have higher servicing costs?
...and in comparing a 1.9 Turbo Diesel and a 1.8 Turbo Petrol, explain to the class which bits of the diesel are vastly more likely to be ruinously expensive compared to the petrol?

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Why do you give a hoot about what your friend buys? Why buy the 1.8T for 5.8K, when you could buy an older 1.8 Escort for a few hundred? Think of the money he'd save. OR, you could just buy a bicycle for a few hundred, and have zero insurance, tax, and fuel costs! Think of the money you'll save.

let him buy what he wants, for the reasons he wants, as it has nothing to do with you. We certainly don't need another diesel thread.

Urban Sports

11,321 posts

234 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Blue Meanie said:
Why do you give a hoot about what your friend buys? Why buy the 1.8T for 5.8K, when you could buy an older 1.8 Escort for a few hundred? Think of the money he'd save. OR, you could just buy a bicycle for a few hundred, and have zero insurance, tax, and fuel costs! Think of the money you'll save.

let him buy what he wants, for the reasons he wants, as it has nothing to do with you. We certainly don't need another diesel thread.
I think you will find the OP can post what he likes.

smile

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
He can, I never said he shouldn't post it. I just don't see why it couldn't have just been added to the countless other diesel threads we've had in the last weeks. Oddly enough, when we have 2 threads on the same subject, one tends to get closed down, as there is a thread running. It's never that way with diesel threads.

Lost soul

8,712 posts

213 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
Just seen this illustrated by a friend of mine who just doesn't get it.
Maybe it just you who dosen't get it biggrin

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all

In the case of the car in question here the 1.8T drives better, sounds better (although st the 1.8T sounds better than the primitive, clattery bag of nails that's the 1.9 unit) and costs less.
The 1.9 diesel is a worse car in every respect other than range.
Maybe though the friend likes coarse power units that deliver all their shove in one short burst rather than an almost linear engine that provides a broader spread of power? Maybe he likes nose heavy terminal understeer?

Still I wouldn't give a fk what they bought unless of course they'd wasted my time asking for advice which they then ignored for no good reason.

skyslimit

524 posts

203 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Rightly or wrongly, diesels do have higher residuals when you come to sell. Your friend will recoup his money then I'd hope.

In the meantime he's missed out on a better driving experience (in your eyes) but he's mot spent as much at the pumps either.

The pther end of the scale is the much loved bangeromics. I've mothballed my decent cars right now, and I'm doing the bangeromics thing because I'm between jobs.

Namely, £200 Rover 600 L series diesel, which I can squeeze 700 miles per tank from if I'm in no hurry. Which as I'm unemployed, I'm not. It'll still be worth £200 when I sell it, and in the meantime its cheap as dirt motoring. They are old tech, not common rail, not fuel sensitive and never go wrong. Oh, and the added benefit of not caring where I leave it etc. Something I cant say about my BMW etc.

Diesels can make a lot of sense. If you know what way to play it.

BlueMR2

9,476 posts

233 months

Sunday 7th March 2010
quotequote all
Chris_w666 said:
jagracer said:
Somnophore said:
Diesels have higher servicing costs and can be more expensive if they go wrong.
How do they have higher servicing costs?
...and in comparing a 1.9 Turbo Diesel and a 1.8 Turbo Petrol, explain to the class which bits of the diesel are vastly more likely to be ruinously expensive compared to the petrol?
I'd go with the fuel pump and injectors to start with.