US based - What Car?

Poll: US based - What Car?

Total Members Polled: 106

997 C4S: 44%
Shelby GT500 Mustang + winter beater: 56%
Author
Discussion

EK993

Original Poster:

1,957 posts

282 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
I have moved to the US and am looking for a new car. Am in Connecticut which has severe weather, snow from November through to late Feb / early March.

I need a car to drive to the office every day about 2 miles away, and for general use.

My two options are:

a) 997 C4S with winter tyres in the colder months - 2006 car circa $65,000


b) Shelby Mustang GT500 - 2010 car circa $48,000 plus buy a winter beater for the snowy months

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
A C4S on winter 'tires' still won't cut the mustard in extreme weather. Ground clearance and tread width conspire against them IMO. Fine for a bit of ice and poor weather but they aren't made for really extreme conditions.

Buy a used 997 Carrera S and a $10K Subaru would be my advice.

Our 09 Impreza has proved to be a faultless all weather hack that's entertaining enough given a bit of stick. A Forester or Impreza should be well within your price range.


StefV

93 posts

204 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Not sure whether it is the same in Connecticut, and you may already be aware of it, but I'm informed by the locals that here in SoCal, Mustangs are driven exclusively by women and marines. Not quite the same image as a 911.

Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Outside the US, the Mustang may well be exlusive, and different, but I don't think that is the case in the US. They are essentially the US' Focus RS, or Scooby. Quite run of the mill, and 10 a penny. The Shelby is different, but still, I'd go for the Porsche, rather than the Mustang. I think you'll be disappointed by the interior material on the Mustang.

What about an NSX, and a great big Cummins diesel truck? :P

Edited by Blue Meanie on Monday 8th March 03:38

thunderbelmont

2,982 posts

255 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
I have one word for you.

Camaro.


Blue Meanie

73,668 posts

286 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
thunderbelmont said:
I have one word for you.

Challenger.
HTH

norby1

472 posts

204 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
A few more words for you....Ford F150 Raptor...5.4l V8, 320bhp/390lb/ft $44,000. Check out this month's Evo mag for more info. smile

sawman

5,179 posts

261 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Motorrad said:
A C4S on winter 'tires' still won't cut the mustard in extreme weather. Ground clearance and tread width conspire against them IMO. Fine for a bit of ice and poor weather but they aren't made for really extreme conditions.

Buy a used 997 Carrera S and a $10K Subaru would be my advice.

Our 09 Impreza has proved to be a faultless all weather hack that's entertaining enough given a bit of stick. A Forester or Impreza should be well within your price range.
this would be my advice too. My pal in winnipeg has a C4S but he uses a landcruiser in the winter.

Also 'stangs seem a bit chavvy in N america

MadmanO/T People

911 posts

236 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Trust me, Mustangs are common at dirt here in the States and have a somewhat dodgy reputation, too.

If you want to look like you've just robbed a liquor store and you're on your way back to the trailer park to check on your meth lab, then get a Mustang. However, if your knuckles don't drag the ground when you walk upright, get the Porsche.


Cheers,
Madman of the People

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
EK993 said:
I have moved to the US and am looking for a new car. Am in Connecticut which has severe weather, snow from November through to late Feb / early March.

I need a car to drive to the office every day about 2 miles away, and for general use.

My two options are:



b) Shelby Mustang GT500 - 2010 car circa $48,000 plus buy a winter beater for the snowy months
Sadly this is probably not the website to ask such a question on.

Mostly because too many people on here don't even know what the Mustang is, and out of those none have been in one or have a clue.

In reality the Porsche is a nice car, but even in the US you'll be seen as a bit of a rich w*%^ker in one.

The Mustang is much more of a blue collar car and will likely be appreciated by many more. Although to be fair it will be a more common sight in the US than here in the UK.

Other points. The Mustang will cost peanuts to run and be easy to sell on.

And as the US is a place of modified cars, you should get the Mustang, add a catback, CAI, pulley change and a remap. Reckon you should see around 650hp+

And no matter what anyone says, on US roads it'll happily show the Porsche which way to go.

Then just buy a 4x4 beater for when the weather is too bad, maybe a Wrangler, XJ Cherokee or a Bronco.

MATT427

1,653 posts

210 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
mustang

alxce

417 posts

252 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
MATT427 said:
mustang
+1. I lived in the US 2001 to 2005. I sold a 911 here before I went and bought a new Mustang Bullitt special edition when I got there, loved every minute of ownership right down to the trade-in for a Corvette almost three years later. When I got back to UK I bought a C4S. I think it's a case of making the most of what's available in the US because you are unlikely to do those sort of cars in the UK.
I would also agree that you are much better off with a cheap 4x4 for the Connecticut winter than trying to get around in a C4S.

130R

7,128 posts

237 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Why not a Corvette out of interest?

RB26DETT

2,519 posts

206 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Mustang. In black with silver stripes.

HTH

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all

soad

34,769 posts

207 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Porsche looks more classy (going by those two photos). Would be my choice.

petersLUFC

372 posts

211 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
EK993 said:
b) Shelby Mustang GT500 - 2010 car circa $48,000 plus buy a winter beater for the snowy months
That is hideous vomit

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
petersLUFC said:
EK993 said:
b) Shelby Mustang GT500 - 2010 car circa $48,000 plus buy a winter beater for the snowy months
That is hideous vomit
Coming from the Audi A3 driver rolleyes


laugh

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Mustang, Corvette, Camaro... and a cheapo Japanese 4x4 of some description. may as well have something you wouldn't be able to enjoy back home.

soad

34,769 posts

207 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Mustang, Corvette, Camaro... and a cheapo Japanese 4x4 of some description. may as well have something you wouldn't be able to enjoy back home.
Now that you put it that way - seems much better value too.