Buyer pulled out and wants refund on deposit - Advice please
Buyer pulled out and wants refund on deposit - Advice please
Author
Discussion

Chuck21

Original Poster:

181 posts

226 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Hi all,

I recently advertised a car on here and having come and looked at the car a chap phoned me to confirm an offer (which I accepted) and transfered me a £500 deposit (total sale price £3,900).

He seemed to be stalling for about 10 days and I couldn't get him to confirm when he'd be collecting the car and paying the balance; today he's emailed me to say that due to a 'family crisis' he can no longer buy the car and would like us to refund £300 of the £500 deposit. In the meantime I've received over a dozen calls on the car that I've turned away and even two offers.

I'm a reasonable guy and if his situation is genuine there's a part of me that wants to reach a compromise. On the other hand this is why deposits are made and I'm partly inclined to keep the full £500.

Emotion/good will/subjectivity aside, can anybody advise on the legal standing ?

Thanks!
Charlie

Fartgalen

6,940 posts

238 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Give him 300 quid back, and try and sell it elsewhere ?

Greeny

1,423 posts

290 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Maybe you could agree to refund his deposit once you have sold the car.

DavidY

4,492 posts

315 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
If you have dozen's of calls then you'll sell it easily anyway, give him his £300 back, at least he has been honest (and not asked for it all back). Put yourself in his postion, or maybe it will happen to you one day!

davidy

LuS1fer

43,572 posts

276 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Give him £250 back. I'm sure he'll be glad to see half of it.

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Did you discuss with him at the time whether the deposit was refundable or not?

Personally, I'd go halves and give him £250 back if he seems genuine.

soad

34,769 posts

207 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Just refund him the £300. That way there's no more hassle.

You'll sell the car easy enough, i assume.

eztiger

836 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Risotto said:
Did you discuss with him at the time whether the deposit was refundable or not?

Personally, I'd go halves and give him £250 back if he seems genuine.
I'd agree - you're still seeing an effective £250 deposit and he's not asking for the whole lot back.

You should have bashed this out in advance though (for both parties)

MarsellusWallace

1,180 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Unless you put it in writing on the reciept you gave him for the deposit that it was non refundable then you could have problems,and if it goes that far then he may be entitled to all his money back.

Probably better to take the £200 and readvertise the car.

I recently sold a car and took a non refundable deposit.I was messed about by the buyer then he gave me a sob story that his partner had been made redundant and he desperately needed the deposit back.As I am a fair and understanding person I told him that although the deposit was strictly non refundable I would give it him back because of the extreme circumstances as long as he provided me with some evidence of his partners redundancy.

Im still waiting.....

Negative Creep

26,153 posts

258 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
I asked the same thing a few weeks ago. No legal obligation to return the deposit as he broke the Contract of Sale. So if he gets it back depends how nice you are feeling basically

Drederick Tatum

1,033 posts

216 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
I am tempted to say keep the full deposit as if this guy is a proper time waster it may make him think twice next time he pulls the same trick, whats the family crisis?

Big_Dog

996 posts

216 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
I would give him the £300 back. If you have had that many calls, selling it shouldnt be a drama. Hes not asking for all of it and £200 buys a lot of advertising.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
£500 deposit for a £3900 car seems a lot to me, i paid the same on my 220! This isn't some kind of scam is it? How is he requesting the part refund?

Andehh

7,623 posts

237 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
What goes around comes around, who knows the crisis he is in and you'll still be £200 up for a small amount of hassle! smile. Re-list on PH with ''RELISTED'' in the title and im sure the potential buyers will come flooding back.

Edited by Andehh on Wednesday 10th March 11:05

Gad-Westy

16,668 posts

244 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Big_Dog said:
I would give him the £300 back. If you have had that many calls, selling it shouldnt be a drama. Hes not asking for all of it and £200 buys a lot of advertising.
Agree with this. You're still £200 up and the buyer gets what they ask for. Seems like an amicable conclusion.

Chuck21

Original Poster:

181 posts

226 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks everybody, I never expected so many replies so quickly - it's a great help !

I think I'll go ahead as follows by way of a compromise; return £200 now and then another £100 provided the car sells for the original £3,900 or more (which it should).

Thanks again !

NB. If anyone's interested in a low mileage saab 9-3 Convertible let me know !

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Good choice smile

He obviously seems like a decent(ish) chap as well - the fact he's not asking for the full lot means he recognises you've been put out etc. Though it does beg a question what he gave you the full 500 for in the first place!

havoc

33,538 posts

266 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
yes

If nothing, then he gets more than £300 back. If you lose loads, then keep the lot.

Fair to both parties...all you'll have lost is the last 2 weeks...and it's then up to you whether you put a financial cost on that.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Dave_ST220 said:
£500 deposit for a £3900 car seems a lot to me, i paid the same on my 220! This isn't some kind of scam is it? How is he requesting the part refund?
More importantly,how did he make the deposit?

marlinmunro

3,071 posts

236 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
esselte said:
Dave_ST220 said:
£500 deposit for a £3900 car seems a lot to me, i paid the same on my 220! This isn't some kind of scam is it? How is he requesting the part refund?
More importantly,how did he make the deposit?
Agree, was it a cheque, its not uncommon for banks to advise cleared payment, then down the line ops! it has not cleared